*Rate A Player Thread*

[bLuEbOy1984]

Cambiasso - Freak 8.5/10
Aguero - gret young player and will be awsome in a few years but on current ability 7.5/10
Maicon - superstar 9/10

Now rate these out of 10

Marcos Senna
Obafemi Martins
Jefferson Farfan

Senna - a great performance at the euro was an important part of the midfield... but his body lets him down at times, when fully firing his a great central mideilder 8/10

Obi MArtins - i use to love him when he was at Inter, seemingly hasnt done much ever since his left had a few good games kicked a few great goals... but i have a feeling the whole season his been playing injuried his lighting quick but his finishing has always left him done ...currently - 6/10
if he stays fit and puts in effort he could rise up to about 8/10 his very talented but needs to work harder

 

[Big Kitty]

How do you rate Park out of 10 and how much would you pay for him.

 

[adam10]

How do you rate Park out of 10 and how much would you pay for him.

6.5/10 Pay 2 -4 mil tops.

Tracks back and works hard for his team, underrated.
But i dont think gives enough in attack.

 

[Beamdogg]

6.5/10 Pay 2 -4 mil tops.

Tracks back and works hard for his team, underrated.
But i dont think gives enough in attack.

6/10

Works hard but isnt worth much. Not a dangerous scorer.

 

[TorresIsGod]

0.5/10

I'd want you to give me 5m to take him

 

[bus24]

Park?

You would pay a fair bit for him - and it's got nothing to do with his footballing ability. All about the marketing $$$. Same situation as Dong, really.

Let's be honest - If Park Ji-Sung from South Korea - was Patrick Johnson from Dublin, he wouldn't be at a club like Manchester United.

 

[jd2006]

A bit like Susan Boyle (spelling?)

If she wasnt so god damn ugly would she of made the final of Brittains Got Talent and become world famous

 

[AG]

A bit like Susan Boyle (spelling?)

If she wasnt so god damn ugly would she of made the final of Brittains Got Talent and become world famous

Personally I think she's radical.

 

[jd2006]

Vedran Corluka??

 

[Big Kitty]

0.5/10

I'd want you to give me 5m to take him

Where does that leave Lucas?

Please rate Lucas everybody

 

[TorresIsGod]

Lucas. 1/10

Plays for Liverpool, therefore is rated higher than someone playing for Hacky Utd.

 

[Beamdogg]

Lucas.

0/10

The worst footballer thats pulled on a reds shirt. I think i could do better.

He makes me sick when he shoots for goal.

 

[Crimson King]

The worst footballer thats pulled on a reds shirt. I think i could do better.

He makes me sick when he shoots for goal.

Robbie Keane says hai.

 

[belfast_bomber]

As do Sean Dundee, Salif Diao, Phil Babb, Mark Gonzales, Abel Xavier, David Thompson, Stig Inge Bjornebye, Julian Dicks (s******), Mauricio Pellegrino, Andrea Dossena...

 

[TorresIsGod]

As do Sean Dundee, Salif Diao, Phil Babb, Mark Gonzales, Abel Xavier, David Thompson, Stig Inge Bjornebye, Julian Dicks (s******), Mauricio Pellegrino, Andrea Dossena...

Very good player.

 

[Beamdogg]

Robbie Keane says hai.

He said hi to everyone when he scored at Anfield in our last game there this season.

No one cared about him. He should of pi$$bolted off that pitch.

 

[bighughie]

He said hi to everyone when he scored at Anfield in our last game there this season.

No one cared about him. He should of pi$$bolted off that pitch.

What I'm taking away from your post is that you blame Keane for not being good enough, not the insane power battle between Benitez and Parry that resulted in him being there in the first place and then the inept tactical decisions that stuck a player clearly not suited to the role out on the wing.

Parry and Benitez are more to blame for Keane not succeeding at 'pool than the player himself.

 

[Beamdogg]

What I'm taking away from your post is that you blame Keane for not being good enough, not the insane power battle between Benitez and Parry that resulted in him being there in the first place and then the inept tactical decisions that stuck a player clearly not suited to the role out on the wing.

Parry and Benitez are more to blame for Keane not succeeding at 'pool than the player himself.

Yeah i know that its not liek i wasnt watching the games screaming for Benetiz to put Keane on but he was quiet some games whee we needed him to step up. Suppose im slightly bitter on those draws lol.

 

[TorresIsGod]

Robbie Keane certainly wasn't helped by what went on off the field, but on the field he didn't help himself.

He fresh-aired us into 2nd place.

 

[Benno_900]

Bump.

Maxi Rodriguez

 

[r dub 19]

Sagna is elite. Anyway what would be the official ranking system ...

10 - Not human
9 - Top 10 in the world
8 - Elite
7 - Very Good
6 - Solid
5 - Serviceable
4 - Mediocre
3 - Poor
2 - Absolute dud
1 - Emmanuel Eboue

You may aswell be a spurs supporter to me now.

 

[Jessica Watson]

1 - any current LFC player.
0 - Haxi Rodriguez
-1 - Christian Poosen.

 

[Knowledge]

Where would Konchesky rate on that ranking system?

 

[Benno_900]

You may aswell be a spurs supporter to me now.

Ah c'mon, that was more than two years ago when his shittiness was costing us games.

Eboue ranks a 10 now.

 

[Jessica Watson]

Konchesky is a 1, based on him being a current LFC player that isn't Haxi or Poosen.