Roughead - Trade

[Monkey Worshipper]

Any chance he could be traded away at year end to bolster your Rucks and / or Backline?

And is so, what would you (realistically) want from WCE?

 

[Thurgood2Dawson]

Roughead + first round for Naitunui

we wont do it, you wont do it, and after last nights effort would you really want him

 

[Jaeger]

I highly doubt we will trade him.

I wouldn't mind Glass, NicNat, Cox and Kerr

 

[Jaeger]

Roughead + first round for Naitunui

we wont do it, you wont do it, and after last nights effort would you really want him

Your username is very odd.

I think every club would still want him

 

[Monkey Worshipper]

Roughead + first round for Naitunui

we wont do it, you wont do it, and after last nights effort would you really want him

Yes, I would really want him.

I'd offer up M.Brown, Sphanger & Lynch

Over to you

 

[Thurgood2Dawson]

cox and your 2nd rounder

 

[Rioli magic]

Yes, I would really want him.

I'd offer up M.Brown, Sphanger & Lynch

Over to you

You're terrible at this. Don't give up your day job.






I want Natinui. Ellis for Natinui. Over to you.

 

[Gunston19]

u rkn gold coast will still offer him 1mill after his shit this year, i think not, no team would give up a great player lyk nicnat for him.

 

[HyperAgressiveDonk]

The problem is with Roughead is he would have little trade value by years end if he continues like this.

2008 he was very good but 09 and the start of 2010 have been embarrassing.

I couldn't imagine too many sides wanting a guy who hasn't performed consistently in 2 years and can't make the distance from 45 metres out..

I think he could come good and I hope he does. Though at the same time he could end up like Chris Tarrant.

I say we play him down back now because he will fill a need for us and could be a premier CHB for the next 10 years

 

[Monkey Worshipper]

You're terrible at this. Don't give up your day job.






I want Natinui. Ellis for Natinui. Over to you.

No offence taken

You're getting:

- A good CHB (young) Brown
- A mid aged clanger king that may / may not come good - Sphanger
- a servicable forward that fills your loss at FF - Lynch (for 3 years whilst you develop another forward)

2 KP Backs & a short term forward. Backline is where you have nothing. Cox wouldn't be on the radar, we could get a top 3 pick from GC for him alone. I'd suggest Roughhead probably wouldn't command as much as Cox if he were traded to GC.

I think that's reasonable, but feel free to remove Lynch & Sphanger and add in another backman to team up with Brown instead. But I'd suggest on current form, last 1.2 years, he isn't worth Brown & another good KP backman.

 

[Hawks1523]

Yes, I would really want him.

I'd offer up M.Brown, Sphanger & Lynch

Over to you

LOL.

Wishful thinking. You can keep all three of them.

 

[walhawk]

There is nothing wrong with most of our players - Roughead can play.

IT is all attitude and confidence which comes from the top.

Blame lies with Clarkson primarily, then Mitchell and the rest of the leadership group.

And also the board & footy directors for not making sure that we get better assistant coaches, and for allowing Pelchan to continue to recruit spuds.

 

[go hawks!!!]

You're terrible at this. Don't give up your day job.






I want Natinui. Ellis for Natinui. Over to you.

come on mate, lets be reasonable, he is asking for a fair trade. scott clayton is saying that gold coast will give up pick 1,2,3 for natanui (which i would trade).

In-turn, i suggest a fair trade for natanui would be Tom Murphy and Ellis. Now lets finalise this trade.

 

[Rioli magic]

No offence taken

You're getting:

- A good CHB (young) Brown
- A mid aged clanger king that may / may not come good - Sphanger
- a servicable forward that fills your loss at FF - Lynch (for 3 years whilst you develop another forward)

2 KP Backs & a short term forward. Backline is where you have nothing. Cox wouldn't be on the radar, we could get a top 3 pick from GC for him alone. I'd suggest Roughhead probably wouldn't command as much as Cox if he were traded to GC.

Wouldn't we just move Roughead to CHB and forget about your list cloggers?

So anyway, Ellis is a top 3 draft pick premiership player with exceptional footskills, we'll chuck in another 100 game premiership player in Osborne for your deficient small forward setup and that would be overpaying for Natanui, who is only your second ruckman.

 

[The Cryptkeeper]

I'd suggest Roughhead probably wouldn't command as much as Cox if he were traded to GC.

Given their respective ages, Roughead would command a damn sight more than Cox.

No offence but it seems that your knowledge on how recruiting works is limited.

23 year old, 60-70 goal per season monster forward with plenty of upside and 8-9 years of AFL football in front of him.
vs
28 year old elite mobile ruckman who is just past his peak and has 3 or 4 years left.

The GC and any other club takes Roughead every day of the week.

 

[LuvMyHawks]

[I]And also the board & footy directors for not making sure that we get better assistant coaches, and for allowing Pelchan to continue to recrui[/I]t spuds.


I think therein lies much of our problem!!

 

[Upgrayedd]

Only if you trade us Naitanui for Beau Dowler Shane Savage and Tom Murphy

 

[Hawka_de_Haven]

Yes, I would really want him.

I'd offer up M.Brown, Sphanger & Lynch

Over to you

Now here is a silly thread!

 

[SweetLeftFoot]

If we got Roughy off you, we'd win a flag within three years.

 

[Tim Hawk]

No trade. This is very short sighted. Roughy is a quality player who is havig a few issues at present. He needs to get right and get his desire and self belief back that's all

 

[spudmaster]

If we got Roughy off you, we'd win a flag within three years.

No, if you got Roughy off us you would have 23 underperforming players to select from every week

 

[tommyk72]

No, if you got Roughy off us you would have 23 underperforming players to select from every week

I hate to say it spudmaster - but something about glass houses and stones springs to mind

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

If we got Roughy off you, we'd win a flag within three years.

Controversial.

But that's what you were aiming for, yeah?

 

[Splodge15]

After the amount of investment we have put into Roughead, I highly doubt we would consider trading him. We simply would not get a fair return.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

Roughead's playing injured and going nowhere.