Opinion Round 13 Changes vs. Richmond

[slicedndiced]

Calm down ya twit.

There is one mention on there of it being 8-10, that persons source apparently a former docker.

Yet you felt the need to post it here before doing a bit of research and then retracting.

No different to last week where people declared Fyfe to be definitely out for the Adelaide game because he was seen at the airport after the game using crutches.

As if crutches being used as a precautionary measure for leg injuries is a new thing

 

[beetz]

More than confident we can cover the loss of McPharlin and Johnson this week with Silvagni and Ibbo playing those roles. Dawson will be all over Riewoldt who the Richmond midfield will be kicking to with 95% of their forward 50 entries.

Who does Crowley tag, an out of form Cotchin or an out of form Deledio?

 

[Freoforever86]

Out - Johnson & McPharlin
In - Silvagni & Sylvia

Need the exp of Sylvia for this game. 2 good games in a row by him, so it's time. Morabito return would be better suited to a lower team, like Brisbane next week. Calls for him to be able to play Johnson's spare man role are silly. No chance he will run out a full game of AFL yet.
Richmond are still a danger team.

Ballantyne will get off, but if suspended Crozier will come in for him.

Spurr Dawson Ibbo
Duff Silvagni D. Pearce
Hil Mundy Suban
Sylvia Pav Mzungu
Ballaz Clarke Mayne
Sandi Fyfe Crowley
Neale Barlow Suttcliffe
Shero sub

 

[Big Animal]

In: accurate kicking; 4 points
Out: thoughts of the MRP as Ballas gets off due to the execution of the perfect and fair bump

 

[salim malik]

Forecast for Sat is cold,wet and windy
Clancee's big body might be the go .Silvagni and Clancee in for Johnno and Luke.

 

[clogged]

Bring back Jono Griffin to tear them apart

 

[Bluelegs]

I am guessing Sylvia has a habit of doing well Against richmond?

Still If Johnson is out yes Silvagni is in.

If ballantyne is out, Bring in Sylvia.

When we did the votes against Richmond this year on our board a mod called it the Colin Sylvia medal. There is one aspect of Sylvia's game that he has always been consistent in and that is his domination against Richmond.

 

[StingBitten]

Forecast for Sat is cold,wet and windy
Clancee's big body might be the go .Silvagni and Clancee in for Johnno and Luke.

I was thinking this actually... C. Pearce was electric in the first quarter back in WAFL but then went missing.. still think with our two best defenders out we need experienced players who can adapt to the role.

 

[mike91]

Bring back Jono Griffin to tear them apart

You mean Griffith?

 

[beetz]

I was thinking this actually... C. Pearce was electric in the first quarter back in WAFL but then went missing.. still think with our two best defenders out we need experienced players who can adapt to the role.

he was probably rooted!

 

[slicedndiced]

he was probably rooted!

He was in awe of the Auskick kid warming up near the boundary and cbf playing anymore.

He knows when he's beat.

 

[beetz]

He was in awe of the Auskick kid warming up near the boundary and cbf playing anymore.

He knows when he's beat.

hahaha I am so intrigued by this damn Auskick kid!

Has it been confirmed that it wasn't in fact Peter Bell having a run around?

 

[slicedndiced]

hahaha I am so intrigued by this damn Auskick kid!

Has it been confirmed that it wasn't in fact Peter Bell having a run around?

Far too tall for Belly.

From all accounts he is as big as Sandi, crashes pack like Carey, defends like McPharlin, is better at clearances than Gablett jnr, is tougher than Troy Cook and meaner than Ron Boucher and Basil Campbell combined.

He is also in training to be an astronaut.

 

[Reginald Perrin]

I'm hearing a lot about this Auskick wonder kid, but can he tackle?

 

[slicedndiced]

I'm hearing a lot about this Auskick wonder kid, but can he tackle?

Nobody's perfect mate.

 

[manpurple]

hahaha I am so intrigued by this damn Auskick kid!

Has it been confirmed that it wasn't in fact Peter Bell having a run around?

Nah Bells never got the air that kid got, ever.

 

[clivenator26]

MJ & Luke out
Silvagni & Sylvia in looks like the logical option, Sylvia no doubt will be sub, make him earn that spot for as long as we can!

Would Alex Pearce be any sort of chance now ?

 

[bone2468]

MJ & Luke out
Silvagni & Sylvia in looks like the logical option, Sylvia no doubt will be sub, make him earn that spot for as long as we can!

Would Alex Pearce be any sort of chance now ?

To skinny would be pushed of the ball majorly.

 

[bloke_]

Is Tanner Smith still injured?

 

[purplerunsdeep]

tyrone and Thomas out for Richmond already.

just have a feeling Sylvia will play this game - away game at the G, he'll be itching to prove himself

 

[Freeeoo]

You would think Scos would be the obvious in. It'll be interesting to see who the other one is. Got a feeling it will be Clancee.

 

[bone2468]

Is Tanner Smith still injured?

another 1-2 weeks away

 

[bloke_]

another 1-2 weeks away

Cheers bone.

Unlikely to get another game this year then

 

[bone2468]

Cheers bone.

Unlikely to get another game this year then

Probably not buddy. Will need to build strength back in the 2nds as it was a pretty bad Hamstring Tear and a big pre-season and hopefully he can crack the senior squad next season.

 

[The Pirate]

I'm a glass half full kinda guy. If we are going to lose our best two defenders then now is probably the run of games we can cover them (no disrespect to our next 4-6 opposition teams). This is a serious opportunity for Silvagni to reignite his career and will give us an option should injuries occur at the pointy end of season. It's all been said before how injury/confidence/fitness has meant when Silvagni has come in the last few years that lack of continuity has shown match day. So I am excited at him getting a run at it.

It's going to be a tough selection night with Mora, Crozier, Sylvia, Clancee and Grey all viable inclusions. I'll leave selections to the match committee but for the same reason I hope Silvagni gets some continuity, I'd also like Sheridan (can't bring myself to call him by his first name)to get another week.