Round 6 votes

[sapaul]

Good win, last few minutes where we finished Richmond off was very good.So many good players, votes were hard to give.

Player of the year

5 votes- Tyson Stenglein
4 votes- Nathan Bassett
3 votes- Simon Goodwin
2 votes- Andrew McLeod
1 vote- Graham Johncock

Just missing out were Hart, Smart, Burton, Bickley and Welsh.

Top team man

3 votes- Tyson Stenglein
2 votes- Mark Bickley
1 vote- Nathan Bassett

Rookie

3 votes- Graham Johncock
2 votes- Michael Doughty
1 vote- SFA

 

[Damp Squarie]

Tiger Tougher

BOG
5 McLeod
4 Edwards
3 Marsh
2 Bickley
1 Johncock

That was very difficult to pick....

ROOKIE
3 Johncock
2 Pass
1 Doughety

TMAN
3 Marsh
2 Hart
1 Smart

We were atrocious in front of goal and still sh8t in.
Richmond also had a few lucky bounces that paid the scoreboard.

Roo was not in my Votes but he wasstiff

Thought Marsh filled the holes around the ground. Clarke done some good tap work that went unrewarded.

Saving Massie til late in third quarter was a strange move, { I know his leg work last week was inspirational} but he would of had a picnic in the second qrtr.


And on a final note...JARMAN earn ya stripes.

Sarge ...well done mate, good body work

 

[ant]

BOG votes

5 McLeod
4 Goodwin
3 Stenglein
2 Bickley
1 Doughty

Best Team Man

3 Stenglein
2 Welsh - sensational pressure in our forward 50 (goes for everyone really)
1 Smart

Rookie Award

3 Doughty
2 Johncock
1 ---

 

[dogs105]

Best

5- A.McLeod
4- S.Goodwin
3- T.Stenglein
4- T.Edwards
5- M.Clarke

Team

3- T.Stenglein
2- B.Hart
1- T.Edwards

Rookie

3- M.Doughty
2- G.Johncock

Honourable Mentions to Bicks, Roo, Welshy, Birdman, Sarge.

 

[Jars458]

5 A McLeod
4 T Stenglein
3 N Smart
2 S Goodwin
1 G Johncock


Team man

3 M Clarke
2 S Welsh
1 M Bickley


Rookie

3 Johncock
2 pass
1 - doughty


Player that should be dropped

3 Marsh
2 Marsh
1 Marsh

 

[noddy]

Could be a good 3 weeks coming up, [maybe]

Player of the Round

5 votes = A Mcleod
4 votes = T Stenglein
3 votes = T Edwards
2 votes = S Welsh
1 vote = S Goodwin

Best Team Man

3 votes = M Bickley
2 votes = M Ricciuto
1 vote = M Clarke

Rookie of the Year

3 votes = G Johncock
2 votes = M Doughty

You may be right about Ben Marsh jars 458,
all that promise & yet to deliver.

 

[Spogs]

BEST:

5. McLeod
4. Goodwin
3. Doughty
2. Smart
1. Ricciuto


TEAM MAN:

3. Smart
2. Bickley
1. Clark


ROOKIE:

3. Doughty
2. Johncock
1. ---------

 

[ozgeek]

BOG

5. A. McLeod
4. T. Stenglein
3. M. Bickley
2. S. Goodwin
1. Graham Johncock

Team Man

3. M. Bickley
2. T. Stenglein
1. N. Bassett

Rookie

3. M. Doughty
2. G. Johncock
1. pass

An enthralling game which should have resulted in a thrashing for the Tigers. Difficult to understand how the Crows could kick 5 goals without a miss and then have trouble finding the goals for the rest of the game. They were clearly dominant and yet let Richmond "off the hook".

 

[schells_hunny27]

My votes:

5: Tyson Stenglein sensational game
4: McLeod
3: Bickley
2: Goodwin
1: Johncock

Best team man

3: Stenglein - great game on Bowden
2: Welsh - fabulous tackling and pressure in the forward line.
1: Smart

Rookie

3: Johncock
2: Doughty
1: n/a

Bring back Schell!!!!!
McGregor has to go!!!

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Best on Ground
5. Stenglein - great job on Bowden & got plenty of the ball himself.
4. McLeod - just class & finished the game off well (just loved watching him kick that goal in the last quarter).
3. Smart - curbed Richo's influence (that 1st goal was lucky!)
2. Bassett - consistent performer all year.
1. Goodwin - would have ranked him higher if he didn't waste the ball a bit (also he started the rot with the points in the 2nd quarter).

Best Team Man
3. Stenglein
2. Smart
1. Welsh - his forward pressure this year has been fantastic.

Best Rookie
3. Johncock - looked more at home across HB & is all class.
2. Doughty - another good performance & only just edged out by Johncock.
1. n/a

PS. ozgeek - I'm a little confused how you have Johncock 5th BOG, yet rate him behind Doughty for the BR

PPS schells_hunny - I would be swapping Fitzy for Schell, as he needs to learn how to mark again for South. IMO, Hewitt should be the player to come in for Kenny.

PPPS Jars458 - I have been one of Marsh's biggest critics, but he competed OK with Ottens (even though he was beaten, he wasn't thrashed). Having said that, he rather than Clarke should make way when Biglands is fit.

 

[Damp Squarie]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin

PPPS Jars458 - I have been one of Marsh's biggest critics, but he competed OK with Ottens (even though he was beaten, he wasn't thrashed). Having said that, he rather than Clarke should make way when Biglands is fit.

Both our Rucks were superb.
Great photograph on the back of the Tiser just about sums it up

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Cumulative Votes (so far)

10 voters so far:

Best on Ground
45 McLeod (5)
33 Stenglein (4)
23 Goodwin (3)
10 Bickley (2)
9 Edwards (1)
8 Smart
6 Bassett
5 Johncock
4 Doughty
3 Marsh
2 Welsh
1 Ricciuto
1 Clarke
150 Total

Best Team Man
17 Stenglein (3)
11 Bickley (2)
8 Smart (1)
7 Welsh
5 Clarke
4 Hart
3 Marsh
2 Bassett
2 Ricciuto
1 Edwards
60 Total

Best Rookie
26 Johncock (3)
24 Doughty (2)
10 n/a
60 Total

 

[ozgeek]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
Best on Ground
PS. ozgeek - I'm a little confused how you have Johncock 5th BOG, yet rate him behind Doughty for the BR

Yes, you are right, I did get it wrong. Is it too late to change it round in the Rookies?

Ozgeek

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

ozgeek - No problem, I will change your rookie votes around.

 

[MarksGirl-kbcrowgirl]

Votes

Here we go boys!

Best on ground

1 Andrew McLeod
2 Simon Goodwin
3 Tyson Stenglein
4 Scott Welsh
5 Mark Riccuitto


Best Team man

1 Scott Welsh
2 Mark Stevens
3 Nathan Bassett

Rookie of the year

1 Doughty
2 Johncock
3 Fitzgerald

 

[Nige_Bix]

Just in time - just had to rush the wife to work.-11am

Ok - back on the job after having to curtail my Internet activity due to my son blowing my monthly allowance by the middle of the month - damn school holidays!!

BOG
1 Andrew McLeod
2 Simon Goodwin
3 Tyson Stenglein
4 Scott Welsh
5 Tyson Edwards

TM
3. Stenglein
2. Welsh
1. Bickley

R
3. Johncock
2. Doughty
1. Schell only joking!!

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Final Cumulative Votes

12 voters:

Best on Ground
55 McLeod (5)
39 Stenglein (4)
31 Goodwin (3)
10 Bickley (2)
10 Edwards (2)
8 Smart
6 Bassett
6 Welsh
5 Johncock
4 Doughty
3 Marsh
2 Ricciuto
1 Clarke
180 Total

Best Team Man
20 Stenglein (3)
12 Bickley (2)
12 Welsh (2)
8 Smart
5 Clarke
4 Hart
3 Marsh
3 Bassett
2 Ricciuto
2 Stevens
1 Edwards
72 Total

Best Rookie
33 Johncock (3)
27 Doughty (2)
12 n/a
72 Total

 

[Jerome]

I keep forgetting this...

5 McLeod
4. Goodwin
3. Welsh
2. Bickley
1. Marsh

TTM

3 Bickley
2 Welsh
1 Smart

Rookie

1. Dogga
2. Johncock

 

[Blues_Girl]

I'm slack yet again!

Best on Ground

5. Andrew McLeod
4. Simon Goodwin
3. Tyson Edwards
2. Scott Welsh
1. Nigel Smart

Top Team Man

3. Mark Bickley
2. Scott Welsh
1. Matty Bode

Best Rookie

3. Grahame Johncock
2. Michael Doughty