Round 8 Trades

[bones25]

Bradshaw has taken over Brownies spot because just maybe Jonathan is coming back home and Matthews already knows this. Just a possibility.

 

[samwise]

hill (going down in price) to b johnson (going up) & cop a 0 for symes
or
symes to milburn (going down) & leave hill to go down more
or
keep symes 0 and hill going down and hope milburn can go down 17k or pfeiffer go up 17k so i can trade pfeiffer to milburn

(have proud playing for pfeiffer atm)

what do people think?

 

[lmaohelp]

u sure milburn is going down ??

i think he is going up after this week and yeh get rid of symes he is on the way down...?

 

[bbco49]

hill (going down in price) to b johnson (going up) & cop a 0 for symes
or
symes to milburn (going down) & leave hill to go down more
or
keep symes 0 and hill going down and hope milburn can go down 17k or pfeiffer go up 17k so i can trade pfeiffer to milburn

(have proud playing for pfeiffer atm)

what do people think?

same situation mate. i think im going hill>BJ and just cop 0 for Symes. Hill will drop heaps next game (thats if hes selected in the first place) and BJ will go up heaps, while Symes' price aint goin anywhere

 

[lmaohelp]

trade symes hes BE weneva he does play in over 150

 

[CaptainCarrazzo]

Thoughts on:

Out - Fev and rioli

In - BJ and Gian (giving me 30k in bank) or Pav (leaving 6k)

Good trade or waste?

 

[thebaxters]

Thoughts on:

Out - Fev and rioli

In - BJ and Gian (giving me 30k in bank) or Pav (leaving 6k)

Good trade or waste?

Fev too inconsistent to stay, Rioli prob has a few weeks in him before he tops out, but if you don't trade him now, you may miss BJ and Pav, both looking like increasing in value. Pav>Gia for me, more consistent and durable.

If you haven't spent too many trades, looks good. If you've burned too many already, maybe just Fev>BJ for now.

 

[lmaohelp]

need to get rid of symes for milburn

and then i need to trade a rookie for money for the following round.

who should i downgrade out of my rookies -

Pfeiffer Houli palmer Bird Tippett rioli or dew

and for who ?/?

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

I'm thinking of upgrading Xavier Ellis, Ed Barlow or Jason Gram.
Are there players in particular I should try to get for them?

Aim for either P.Burgoyne or Milburn. I'd say Ellis and Barlow are priority upgrades there. Gram is annoyingly inconsistent but at least he is capable of 90+ scores so he can wait a few weeks in your case.

What's everyone's thoughts?

I am going to trade in Heath Shaw this week, but am unsure who to trade out (losses I will make so far in brackets)... All 3 have slumped, but who is least likely to rebound later??

Sam Fisher ($22k) $317k
Adam McPhee ($84k) $304k
Beau Waters ($57k) $283k

I'd say Waters is the most likely to bounce back. Once he hits the form he showed in Rounds 1-3 then he will be right up there with the best backmen. Its only a matter of time, and really depends on when the Eagles improve as a team.

 

[kangaroo19]

Who would be the best defender to target under $350k? I already have Milburn and Goddard.

Cheers!

 

[lmaohelp]

birchall or guerra ? both average around 80

need to get rid of symes for milburn

and then i need to trade a rookie for money for the following round.

who should i downgrade out of my rookies -

Pfeiffer Houli palmer Bird Tippett rioli or dew

and for who ?/?

 

[Tippaz]

i'm preparing for:

Bird -> Browne
Rioli -> Giansiracusa

i have a feeling this is the 'sell Craig Bird for Steven Browne' week for many DTers.
Rioli has hit a mini-peak. pretty good time to upgrade.
Travis Cloke is playing on my mind. i would use any excuse to sell (if Valenti's name comes up on the teamsheet - i would reconsider my moves!). otherwise, he's on his last chance.

 

[Butane]

Get rid of Jordan Lewis

-he's falling heavily so trade now so not too much cash is lost

also if u have the cash consider Richo + Cam the Bruce

Nice way to waste a trade.

 

[Tippaz]

Thoughts on:

Out - Fev and rioli

In - BJ and Gian (giving me 30k in bank) or Pav (leaving 6k)

Good trade or waste?

why get rid of Fev

 

[Tippaz]

Who would be the best defender to target under $350k? I already have Milburn and Goddard.

Cheers!

p.burgoyne

 

[kangaroo19]

i'm preparing for:

Bird -> Browne
Rioli -> Giansiracusa

i have a feeling this is the 'sell Craig Bird for Steven Browne' week for many DTers.
Rioli has hit a mini-peak. pretty good time to upgrade.
Travis Cloke is playing on my mind. i would use any excuse to sell (if Valenti's name comes up on the teamsheet - i would reconsider my moves!). otherwise, he's on his last chance.

Cloke is on my mind as well, and I think I will trade him out next week. This week, his BE is 63 and he is playing an undermanned defence of the Saints so I think he will go up slightly. I want to pick up BJ while he is relatively cheap, but have other priorities this week. I will probably be upgrading Cloke to BJ and downgrade Rioli to Neagle, with Gamble taking the 7th forward spot. Then, the following week, Gamble can be turned into Chappy...

so three trades =

In: BJ, Chapman, Neagle (or other rookie leaving him and Tippet as emergencies)
Out: Rioli, Cloke, Gamble.

 

[kangaroo19]

p.burgoyne

Yeah, that's what I was thinking, but would he be likely to go down in value soon or has he already bottomed? Also tossing up whether or not I want the consistency of Birchall... but he doesn't seem to get as many big scores...

 

[Outburst]

vince > josh kennedy
symes > havnt decided yet but there is stuff all to chose from in the backs..
milburn, gilbee, pburgoyne

already have bock, mcloud, goddard

 

[Tippaz]

vince > josh kennedy
symes > havnt decided yet but there is stuff all to chose from in the backs..
milburn, gilbee, pburgoyne

already have bock, mcloud, goddard

you're getting rid of Symes

 

[Outburst]

yea hes peaked and out till round 10

 

[Cruiser23]

you're getting rid of Symes

I think i will be. I really all depends on your situation. If i don't trade him, i will have zeros for a few weeks because Brown is already filling in for Cornes. He isn't killing it, he isn't averaging 90+ as a backman, there are a lot better options than Symes and i'm don't want to loose 160 odd points for a person how is going to average 70-75. If it was Shaw or C.Cornes i wouldn't trade because they are stand outs but there are so many better options than Symes.

 

[lmaohelp]

need to get rid of symes for milburn

and then i need to trade a rookie for money for the following round.

who should i downgrade out of my rookies -

Pfeiffer Houli palmer Bird Tippett rioli or dew

and for who ?/?

 

[Colin D'Cops]

you're getting rid of Symes

I think i will be. I really all depends on your situation. If i don't trade him, i will have zeros for a few weeks because Brown is already filling in for Cornes. He isn't killing it, he isn't averaging 90+ as a backman, there are a lot better options than Symes and i'm don't want to loose 160 odd points for a person how is going to average 70-75. If it was Shaw or C.Cornes i wouldn't trade because they are stand outs but there are so many better options than Symes.

Yeah, Symes' ankle has gotten a fair bit worse from what was initually thought, could miss up to 5 weeks max...With Reilly & Knights getting in the side regularly and hitting their straps by 5 weeks from their injuries, that would mean less midfield time for Symes, so he would naturally get less of the ball because he'd either be on the pine or in the back pocket...I've got the same situation, in two minds about whether to trade him, though I really like the thought of getting Milburn in and making cash off that trade as well because in my eyes it's a bit of an upgrade...But I don't really like the thought of wasting to many trades early on because trades become valuable during the tail end of the season because of injuries & tanking D)...We've got a bit of time to analyse the negatives against the positives, longer than usual, so I'm sure whatever decision people come up with they'll be quite confident in imo...

 

[Porps_is_HOT_loz]

Thoughts on:

Out - Fev and rioli

In - BJ and Gian (giving me 30k in bank) or Pav (leaving 6k)

Good trade or waste?

I have the Fev.
Thats a waste of a trade..IMO
Wait a while.
The fevolution could start any day from now

 

[Dalsantowhatastar]

Symes-->Burgoyne/Gilbee/Milburn/Goddard.
Bradshaw-->Burgoyne/Gilbee/Milburn/Goddard.