Admin Notice S36 Rules and serial_thrilla Thread

[Wosh]

Well at least now we know where fumbler is.

 

[Tonga Bob]

Boring.

 

[Ligma]

Oh you know me too well

Silly of sante for even asking

 

[Tigerturbulance]

Where did he confirm that publicly?

For the same reason we require people to make posts confirming their intent to play as recruiting is often done in private, there needs to be public permission here that Fumbler has agreed to sign up for OOB. Until then, he's not and shouldn't be considered an OOB player.

I could have PM'd you last week Turbo and said I want to play for the Old Boys (though let's be real, never going to happen). You couldn't just add me to your list and think you have the moral ground here. My club hasn't been informed of my departure, I have not made anything public. Just saying I want to play for the OOB isn't enough to literally have me signed on the dotted line. It's all smoke and shadows behind the mirrors

Until Fumbler comes in here and confirms his intention to play for the Old Boys, you don't have the right, in my opinion, to have him listed in your squad list. Dragons on the other hand seem to be acting quite responsibly with all respect. They're claiming that they weren't informed he was leaving and I can see why they'd be on the front foot here. If they weren't, it sets awfully bad precedent for clubs to just start naming whoever to their squad lists from other squads at submission deadline.

where has he told the dragons he will play for them S36, show me where he posted that

 

[T2B_]

She a baddie, she know nut-ten.

 

[Ligma]

She a baddie, she know nut-ten.

 

[ClarkeM]

where has he told the dragons he will play for them S36, show me where he posted that

For the same reason that I don't have to announce I'm going to play for the Wonders each and every season I do, there is a reasonably assumed carryover of player contracts from one season to the next unless, and here's the real sticking point, they inform their club that they wish to leave. Given it's the off-season, a club can't hold onto players wanting to leave at all (not like clubs would) but all of this relies on the player to make it well known publicly where they're going.

 

[sante]

Oh you know me too well

Silly of sante for even asking

My bad. Usually you’re the first to jump in and defend your team.

 

[Ligma]

My bad. Usually you’re the first to jump in and defend your team.

I am not in the leadership group therefore I do not know the details of this, that’s why I am not engaging in the tough debate

 

[Wacky Tiger]

Old Boys seem very desperate to have an absolute inactive play for them. Smells like desperation.

 

[The Filth Wizard]

Ok two inactives.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

fumbler when he finally sees this thread..

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

So you know concede that fumbler casually indicated that he'd join the OOB's, cracks are showing now!

I took from fumbler when he said 'I'm in' that he was IN, not casually indicating he might join OOB

What's next, we knew he was joining OOB and just wanted fun. As I said the Dragons need to be penalized hard once this fiasco is shown to be what it is, a Dragons lame attempt to be relevant

Dragons, this seasons Gumbies. Which one does the DenieD and melts themselves out of existence?

You seem a little emotional about this, Turbo. Might be a good time for you to log out for a little bit and calm down.

lazy trope. try harder

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

And I'm sure he'd much rather see the club he played seasons for survive, but none of it is worth betting a club over.

White feather incoming

he does love the Furies, but the dragons have shown their not worth keeping

If they fold, we don't have a bye

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

No, I said you're coming across as being obnoxious.

Easy without seeing the PMs to say this.

You don't have all the info, and this is a poor call.

 

[DragoDelph]

Dragons, this seasons Gumbies. Which one does the DenieD and melts themselves out of existence?

lazy trope. try harder

Seems that your captain is the only one melting here mate. Your off season has really gone helter skelter, huh?

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Seems that your captain is the only one melting here mate. Your off season has really gone helter skelter, huh?

No, he's not melting. If you think that is Turbo melting, I suggest you go back to school and make English your priority subject. That's also a very poor no U.

He is maintaining a position against multiple people, and good on him. It's going to be highly amusing in a short space of time.

 

[Mrs Turbo]

No, he's not melting. If you think that is Turbo melting, I suggest you go back to school and make English your priority subject. That's also a very poor no U.

He is maintaining a position against multiple people, and good on him. It's going to be highly amusing in a short space of time.

You know him so well Wigs




and are totally right - It would take a hell of a lot more then this little debacle to make the 245kgs melt...

 

[DragoDelph]

No, he's not melting. If you think that is Turbo melting, I suggest you go back to school and make English your priority subject. That's also a very poor no U.

He is maintaining a position against multiple people, and good on him. It's going to be highly amusing in a short space of time.

Oh yes, it’s the sheeple and the rest of the world that are wrong. Admirable of you to stand firm in the face of all the facts, precedents, and general consensus.

Attempts at personal attacks however diminish your points.

Or blink twice if you need help.

From our end, when (and if), fumbler returns and makes it known that they wish to join you, we will acquiesce.

I wish fumbler all the best fortune for whatever is going in the real world. This is just a stupid game all things considered. However the contract can only be terminated by the interested party, not by a third party.

 

[Bonz]

Bonz for fumbler

We'll take Bonz

If I'm getting tagged in a rules thread...

Usually I think it's for something else

 

[Elton Johns Wig]

Admirable of you to stand firm in the face of all the facts, precedents, and general consensus.

We have the facts, you don't possess them all. Judging by your captains posting he's omitted a fair bit so I hope you haven't been lead down the garden path.

And general consensus means jack shit.

 

[BLUEALLTHRU]

What have I missed ? Throw them all in Banhammer!

 

[omgfridge]

where has he told the dragons he will play for them S36, show me where he posted that

So if they havent posted since last season, players are fair game? Or 5 seasons ago for that matter.

Confirming I just signed half the Gumbies list.

 

[ClarkeM]

Easy without seeing the PMs to say this.

You don't have all the info, and this is a poor call.

Easy without PMs to say anything but fact of the matter remains that two clubs are staking a claim to Fumbler and the last club that he played for just so happens to be one of those two.

Regardless of what he has agreed to or not, he hasn’t showed up since the end of Season 35 and the lead up to Season 36. It’s fair and reasonable to assume that the Dragons remains his home until we hear from him himself. I would go one further and in the unique situation that this is in, is enforce both clubs to delist Fumbler and should Fumbler wish to return to the Sweet FA, he is given that opportunity in the sign up thread.

It is the only logical solution to what is right now, a he said she said situation and the Old Boys grossly exacerbating the issue by their stubbornness. Whether they’re entitled to it or not is a different question, but it’s certainly true that this is getting out of hand and Team Sheet deadline approaches.

Imagine both teams name Fumbler… chaos will ensue.

 

[ClarkeM]

So if they havent posted since last season, players are fair game? Or 5 seasons ago for that matter.

Confirming I just signed half the Gumbies list.

It’s such a weak argument to make. Exactly, Fumbler last played for the Dragons and did so after this supposed PM was made. So without anything being made publicly, he has to be considered as a Dragons player until we know more.