Sam Gilbert vs Ben Stratton

[Roughies Boys]

Who would relinquish the third tall option?

Career Stats:

Sam Gilbert: St Kilda

Pick #33 in the 2005 National Draft

Ave Per-Game:

Kicks: 10.7
Handballs: 7.1
Disposals: 17.8
Marks: 5.9
Goals: 0.2
Tackles: 2.8


Ben Stratton: Hawthorn

Pick #46 in the 2009 National Draft

Ave Per-Game:

Kicks: 8.3
Handballs: 5.2
Disposals: 13.5
Marks: 4.9
Goals: 0
Tackles: 2.4

 

[Quixote]

Is there a stat for defensive 50 rebounds? Think that's important.

 

[Roughies Boys]

Is there a stat for defensive 50 rebounds? Think that's important.

Not that I know of.

 

[Rioli magic]

Is there a stat for defensive 50 rebounds? Think that's important.

Sam Gilbert:
2011:
Tot: 59
Avg: 2.7

2010:
Tot: 97
Avg: 3.7

Ben Stratton:
2011:
Tot: 12
Avg: 2

2010:
Tot: 46
Avg: 2.2

 

[Brown n Gold]

Gilbert is far more offensive than Stratton. Gilbert is a better comparison v's Birchall imo.

Stratton is the perfect 3rd man up, can also play on small agile dangerous forwards.. reads the play beautifully seems to have a knack of knowing when to mark and when to spoil.

 

[saintkildaman]

Gilbert in 09-10 form. I'd still go Gilbert just now because of his offence.