Sam Mitchell vs Lenny Hayes

[Danger Mouse]

Who would you rather have in your team?

 

[Neville Bartos]

Tough call. I can't really answer without being biased as I've only watched a few Saints games in full this year.
Hayes is having a super year, with himself and Ball practically holding up the midfield.
The're both great at clearances, while Hayes is probably a bit quicker with top foot skills and can therefore get the footy out, and be there to hit a forward on the chest. So he probably has more bows to his string.

Mitchell on the other hand is all about clearances, and is probably the best in the league with consistency. At the hawks, we really need that type of player as we are a stoppages specialist team, and Mitch is the best at it so we'd keep him. It all depends on what your team needs as to which player you'd take

 

[Joffaboy]

Both.

I would say both clubs are happy they have at least one.

 

[worthy]

It's a no lose choice really, both very good players.

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

I'd like to think Sam would win this poll....but sadly my vote goes against my team.

Hayes for me, though (in something of a first for BF) it's a good comparison. Sammy's having a bit of a down year (with plenty of others taking up the slack it must be said), whilst it appears to me Hayes has been close to in career best form - for which I'm glad, after the knee injury(ies?) he suffered previously.

 

[Neville Bartos]

I'd like to think Sam would win this poll....but sadly my vote goes against my team.

Hayes for me, though (in something of a first for BF) it's a good comparison. Sammy's having a bit of a down year (with plenty of others taking up the slack it must be said), whilst it appears to me Hayes has been close to in career best form - for which I'm glad, after the knee injury(ies?) he suffered previously.

A down year? He's coming first in the Age player of the year competition!!!!!!!!!

I'd hate to see his good year

 

[Cohzee]

Moved to the polls board, where's the poll?

 

[Simon_Nesbit]

A down year? He's coming first in the Age player of the year competition!!!!!!!!!

I'd hate to see his good year

You're kidding right? I've only got him our 3rd best for the year! (Behind Franklin, and Osborne - and only ahead of Sewell and Bateman due to their injury woes).

 

[Alatna]

Lenny for me, but you'd be happy with either.

 

[hawks_time]

As much as I love Ozzie, he has nowhere near been playing better than Sammy, top 10 maybe but definitely not 2. And FWIW I'd take Sammy, although admittedly I haven't seen too much of Hayes' work.

 

[Magpie Magic]

They're both great players and both play an important role for their team.

I'd probably take Hayes, only by the barest of margins though.

 

[Normza]

I'd like to think Sam would win this poll....but sadly my vote goes against my team.

Hayes for me, though (in something of a first for BF) it's a good comparison. Sammy's having a bit of a down year (with plenty of others taking up the slack it must be said), whilst it appears to me Hayes has been close to in career best form - for which I'm glad, after the knee injury(ies?) he suffered previously.

Dude, he's winning the Age player of the year and in the top 4 for the Coach's votes in footy classified. Gee u have high standards.

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

Again I can't say I've seen many Hawks games this year, but I love Lennydog and wouldnt trade him for anyone.