SC Trading Thread (Part I)

[Judd_Magic]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Def. Malceski, Gilbert, Hodge, Silvagni, Kennely, Gram, Waters, Maguire and Hunt

Mid. Barlow, O'keefe, Goddard, Murphy, Cooney, Ablett, Moles, Basitnac

Rucks. Kreuzer, Seaby, Lobbe, Warnock

For. Riewoldt, Brown, Murphy, Higgins, Dangerfield, J.Kennedy, Ballantyne, Peterson, Hitchcock

With $10,800 left

I'm happy with my team but i feel obliged to make a trade at this point. ideas???

Kennelly > Nason and then J.Kennedy to ROK is what I would do.

Start Maguire on the field.

 

[jonesy86]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I'm going to keep Suckling for another week as with 3 forced changes (Hooper, Osborne and Shiels) he will most likely come back this week.

Tomorrow I'm gonna trade Tippett and Sam Wright for Danger and Bob Murphy.

 

[Antz]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Judd Magic or anyone please comment on mine please.

Bock to Malceski

Hall to Brown

This will leave me with spare cash when it is time to upgrade my mids. I am thinking Bock as Adelaide don't look like winning many games soon and I already have Goodwin.


Or

Tippet to Seaby

Hall to Brown

Will still have cash left over but not as much.

 

[jonesy86]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I'd do the Tippett one. He's in the Mitch Clark category this year.

Bock will still get easy touches in defense.

 

[GoesBangFrom50]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

And Howett will stay in our team. Was in the best 5 or 6 players for us last week, many more are on the chopping block before him (Looking at you Davey, Williams, Myers and Dyson).

Howlett OUT.

Also Monfries who was injured at training today (I think McVeigh, Davey and one or 2 more as well)

 

[Antz]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I'd do the Tippett one. He's in the Mitch Clark category this year.

Bock will still get easy touches in defense.

Thanks...I still like the Bock trade. It will leave me with more cash and Malceski will hopefully average the same or more than Bock.

 

[sirviv]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Would love some feedback on Clark - Nic Nat Hall - Brown. Would leave me with Hille and Nic Nat as ruck cant afford Sandi. Or should I burn 1 trade and go for Kruzer. Not keen on his kick:handball ratio though. Not sure if he can keep those high scores going

 

[Judd_Magic]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Judd Magic or anyone please comment on mine please.

Bock to Malceski

Hall to Brown

This will leave me with spare cash when it is time to upgrade my mids. I am thinking Bock as Adelaide don't look like winning many games soon and I already have Goodwin.


Or

Tippet to Seaby

Hall to Brown

Will still have cash left over but not as much.

I like option b) which I have highlighted mate.

Get rid of Tippet while you can. If he was the stock exchange you'd be sh1tting yourself!

 

[lloyd136]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Howlett OUT.

Also Monfries who was injured at training today (I think McVeigh, Davey and one or 2 more as well)

Well **** me.. Prismall dropped too... And Colyer in...

Good to see we're tanking.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I can afford Masten > Bastinac & Warren > J Brown.

I'm seriously considering it - any thoughts?

Do it without any hesitation and push the trade button mate, your on a winner there.

 

[Antz]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I like option b) which I have highlighted mate.

Get rid of Tippet while you can. If he was the stock exchange you'd be sh1tting yourself!

Cheers ...but I so like the Bock trade...what to do...what to do lol

 

[Spartans FC]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Kennelly > Nason and then J.Kennedy to ROK is what I would do.

Start Maguire on the field.

You dumb Carlton supporter can't you see that he has ROK in the midfield already. Pretty sure you can't put the same players in twice.

 

[thomas_m18]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Hmmm, almost sold on this trade now.

OUT: Ball, Gray
IN: Dangerfield, Brown

Thoughts?

 

[kangagirl7]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Current Backline
Goddard
Malceski
Gilbee
Kennelly
Krakouer
Patfull
Adcock

who to trade Adcock for Carrazzo/Hodge anyone else?

As i feel like an idiot for not picking up Barlow in the first place and as much as I hate to do sideways trades, who to trade out Trengrove, Jetta or Martin?

I could trade Trengrove out for Barlow and then Adcock out for Gilbert/Enright

Thanks in Advance

 

[peteshep]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Hmmm, almost sold on this trade now.

OUT: Ball, Gray
IN: Dangerfield, Brown

Thoughts?

Yeah i'd say go for it thomas... Dangerfield (my man) is looking very good and considering he's averaging 95 despite a disappointing Adelaide team one would only assume he could well score even more when they start winning! Preferably you'd want him up forward but definitely take him in the mids if that's not possible.

And the Gray to Brown trade looks good too.

I will probably be doing this myself along with Clark-Kruez..

Seems like the best option for me. anyone have any thoughts on those trades?

 

[Judd_Magic]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

You dumb Carlton supporter can't you see that he has ROK in the midfield already. Pretty sure you can't put the same players in twice.

Sorry you muppet, wasn't really looking at his team, just did a quick suggestion.

Back into your play pen you mental midget.

 

[russea]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Hmmm, almost sold on this trade now.

OUT: Ball, Gray
IN: Dangerfield, Brown

Thoughts?

not a bad trade tom just heres my idea
uv got kennelly right? you could downgrade to hunt/nason
and then upgrade gray to brown, next week with the extra cash u could trade in Judd and Ball out just a thought i had mabye u'll like mabye u wont

 

[russea]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Still like this change now iv seen the teams

Out: Hall, Tippet
In: Brown, Bilbo (Ballantyne)

 

[Lotch]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Current Backline
Goddard
Malceski
Gilbee
Kennelly
Krakouer
Patfull
Adcock

who to trade Adcock for Carrazzo/Hodge anyone else?

As i feel like an idiot for not picking up Barlow in the first place and as much as I hate to do sideways trades, who to trade out Trengrove, Jetta or Martin?

I could trade Trengrove out for Barlow and then Adcock out for Gilbert/Enright

Thanks in Advance

I'm surprised you don't have Hodge in the first place. I would say he is the ideal replacement for Adcock.

Not sure about the sideways trade

 

[shavedham2kg]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I wanted to trade down Ball to a rookie to upgrade Hall to Brown. Now that Howlett has been dropped I am not sure which midfield rookie to pick I already have

Martin
Barlow
Bastinac
Banner
Trengove

So who should I downgrade Ball to?

 

[Antz]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I wanted to trade down Ball to a rookie to upgrade Hall to Brown. Now that Howlett has been dropped I am not sure which midfield rookie to pick I already have

Martin
Barlow
Bastinac
Banner
Trengove

So who should I downgrade Ball to?

You could go Shuey or Jetta.

 

[russea]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I wanted to trade down Ball to a rookie to upgrade Hall to Brown. Now that Howlett has been dropped I am not sure which midfield rookie to pick I already have

Martin
Barlow
Bastinac
Banner
Trengove

So who should I downgrade Ball to?

Barlow is a must get him now

 

[Ed_Gein]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

Barlow is a must get him now

He already has him.

Luke Ball,Persist with him, or trade him out? Was hoping to use him as a cash cow sort of thing to get Judd in a few weeks. :/ Boak, Higgins, Cornes and a few others i've looked at trading him to. What to do.... ??

EDIT: Also, can anyone tell me what Ball needs to maintain his price?

 

[russea]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I wanted to trade down Ball to a rookie to upgrade Hall to Brown. Now that Howlett has been dropped I am not sure which midfield rookie to pick I already have

Martin
Barlow
Bastinac
Banner
Trengove

So who should I downgrade Ball to?

whoops didnt see him there then shueys the way to go

 

[Fademan77]

Re: SC Trading Thread - 2010

I'm in exactly the same situation.
I need to free up cash to go : Thursfield -> Malceski (costs $50k)

Do i trade out Deledio for Cornes and pocket the 20k?

I don't want to trade a premium either!

Thoughts anyone?

Deledio -> Cornes ... which will give me enough cash for
Thursfield -> Malceski

Thursfield was dropped by Richmond this week, so I definately need to swap him out.

Should I be looking at freeing up cash from someone else, other than a premium?

My other iffy players are:
(I need to free up 51k to do the thursfield to malceski trade)

Hille
Masten
B Hall
R. Hargrave

Anyone have any other suggestions? Or should i bite the bullet and pull the trigger on Deledio?