SFNL Div 1 2025

[Greg Tivendale]

Dalyston along with Hutchison. Not sure of the link. Would think Cale should go alright in that comp

They must love cherry picking from the SFNL, i'm pretty sure thats where Murfett and Karamoshos also play?

 

[champp53]

They must love cherry picking from the SFNL, i'm pretty sure thats where Murfett and Karamoshos also play?

Over the years Dalyston have also dragged a number of players including coaches from the Eastern Footy League but only short term when the $$$ are good

 

[Peta Deutschland]

Over the years Dalyston have also dragged a number of players including coaches from the Eastern Footy League but only short term when the $$$ are good [emoji4]

Farmers must be doing really well by all reports


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[batfink]

Over the years Dalyston have also dragged a number of players including coaches from the Eastern Footy League but only short term when the $$$ are good

Nice to not have a salary cap to worry about.

Tell Keillor that

 

[Wild Thing]

Tell Keillor that

Most clubs can get away with it as leagues are too soft to sanction anything to do with it. Unfortunately for Wangaratta Magpies and now possibly Keilor they were stiff and got caught resulting in losing a flag because of it.

 

[bedford]

Most clubs can get away with it as leagues are too soft to sanction anything to do with it. Unfortunately for Wangaratta Magpies and now possibly Keilor they were stiff and got caught resulting in losing a flag because of it.

Keilor will get a slap on the wrist

 

[JohnHancock]

Most clubs can get away with it as leagues are too soft to sanction anything to do with it. Unfortunately for Wangaratta Magpies and now possibly Keilor they were stiff and got caught resulting in losing a flag because of it.

What benefit do leagues have to enforce it?? Waste time and money to audit the books for what benefit?

If clubs like East Brighton pay a mountain for players then it brings good players to the comp and better publicity for the league.

Overall that is good for the league so they have no reason to investigate, unless a lot of clubs complain which I don’t think any in D1 would because they all just want a strong competition.

Another thing with the salary cap I think a lot of people underestimate how hard it would be for most clubs in D1 to raise enough money to break the salary cap. Coaches, equipment and players are all from canteen, bar and sponsors.

No pokies like other clubs in eastern etc, tons of competition for local viewers with the density of clubs in the area and also almost none can charge gate so if a club can raise over 200k a year from its community to go over then that’s a credit to them in some ways and just makes our league stronger.
Only way to truly control it is with a stronger points system.

 

[damochandler]

Keilor will get a slap on the wrist

If afl vic are handing out the punishment yep. Who know what the league will do

 

[bedford]

If afl vic are handing out the punishment yep. Who know what the league will do

They did sfa to Ian Aitkin who was training his club during covid bans at another clubs ground , that should've been a ban

 

[chumbawumba]

Ins and outs

 

[Boo boy]

I definitely see your point the council put in money at several clubs around city of Casey and they are awesome facilities but have been told they can’t display memorabilia like premiership flags team photos and honour boreds in the main room only in one small part usually in the entrance that a small alcove on the side it absolutely ridiculous as the first thing I always did playing against any side was go look at all those things it’s great looking at other clubs history I think

This is the same council that is marching into people's private property and seizing private vehicles.

 

[Boo boy]

This is the same council that is marching into people's private property and seizing private vehicles.

 

[MoorabbinMauler2]

As the season draws closer. I've tried to take a stab at ranking the top 50 players in the SFNL (with some honourable mentions too!). Obviously not going to get it right, but I reckon I've made a solid fist of it.
Let me know if there's anyone I've forgot and all thoughts are welcomed!

1. Keath (EB) - Big call, but has the potential to become Bontempelli-esque in SFNL as a 6'6 bullocking midfielder who is elite by foot. Should make up for the loss of Hutchinson and then some.
2. Lonie (CHE) - Classiest player in the SFNL. His skill and guile can turn a game at the drop of a hat.
3. C. Clarke (PMC) - Prodigal son returns fresh out of the AFL system. Should function as a goalkicking midfielder, wouldn't be surprised to see him kick 40 goals.
4. Roscoe (CRA) - Reigning Ellis medallist, ridicuously classy mid/fwd who impacts the scoreboard massively - had an outstanding second half of the year.
5. Sketcher (SD) - One of the most decorated local players of his generation returns home, giving Springy a bona fide superstar midfielder who will propel them towards the zenith of division one.
6. C Lewis (DIN) - Imposing key forward who almost single-handedly turned the grand final the way of the Dingoes. Would expect him to feature more prominently at VFL level this season but undoubtedly the best forward in the competition when plying his trade at the local level.
7. Beveridge (SPM) - Superstar midfielder who actually received more votes than Roscoe for the Ellis medal, but was ineligible due to suspension. Absolutely elite stoppage player who serves as the blue collar Dogs' talisman in the middle.
8. K. Mutimer (NW) - Former AFL Eagle who has dominated in the trenches for his junior club since his return from the elite level.
9. Downie (EB) - Probably the best two-way midfielder in the competition, his tackling and speed should complement Keath nicely in a stacked Vampires engine room.
10. Hayes (CHE) - His return from the VFL sealed the premiership for Cheltenham, lockdown key defender who also provides dash off the half back line. Perfect modern day defender.
11. Hibberd (PMC) - Came in to last season a bit underdone, but with fireman training now completed, the 2021 premiership Dee looks set to have a big say this season as yet another superstar in the Colts' cosmos.
12. Kreymborg (SPM) - The two time Ellis medallist remains a matchup nightmare even as he ages (gracefully I must add), with his strength, adeptness at ground level and overhead prowess giving opposing defenders fits.
13. Feehan (DIN) - The Dingoes stalwart still reigns as one of the premier defenders in the competition, with his aerial lockdown abilities and sure kicking serving as the bedrock for one of the stingiest defensive units in the competition.
14. Dunnell (CHE) - Criminally underrated Rosella who was cruelly denied a flag by an untimely injury. Elite overhead and by foot, and his smarts and ability to hit the scoreboard allow him to be the ultimate "Mr Fix it" for the two time reigning premiers.
15. R McComb (PMC) - The former Dog comes across the west gate to join his twin brother. Should get a stack of the ball and further strengthen one of the premier midfield's in the competition.
16. T Toner (NW) - Budding superstar who is ready to take the SFNL by storm, tough and classy.
17. J Edwards (CHE) - Premier big man in the competition with simply freakish athleticism at 6'11. Needs to become a force aerially to complement his stellar game at ground level.
18. S Lai (CHE) - Superstar laser footed half back who will have AFL clubs on high alert after the success of his brother. Very similar player who should spend a lot of time with the Tigers' VFL team.
19. Walmsley (DIN) - Evergreen wingman who still runs as well as opponents 15 years younger , can 'Noodles' stave off father time for much longer?
20. Horton-Milne (DIN) - Former Dingoes champion returns home to less fanfare than his more heralded Noble Park teammates, adds another jewel to the glistening crown that is the Dingoes midfield.
21. B O'Toole (SPM) - Rangy key forward who has a superb aerobic capacity and a brilliant set shot, his poise dovetails beautifully with Kreymborg's power.
22. Taylor (PMC) - The lionhearted colts champion has been a star for a decade now, with his brutal inside game and gaudy tackle stats anchoring Port's power packed midfield.
23. Martin (SD) - Best local footy player of our generation arrives to Southern after a simply ridiculous spell with Noble Park. I've marked him down a bit due to only playing a handful of games last season, but could quickly skyrocket up this list if he gets a full preseason under his belt
24. Lamb (EB) - Mercurial key forward who is probably the best pack mark in the competition and a nightmare matchup for defenders when he's on, but inconsistency and poor set shot kicking prevent him for reaching the precipice of this list.
25. Hunt (SPM) - The Dogs will be crossing all of their fingers, toes and other parts that the towering key defender stays healthy. His booming kicking and aerial prowess will be even more valuable with the retirement of Knox and departure of Aneet.
26. Helmore (SD) - Star mid-forward who doesn't garner the plaudits he should. The Gippslander makes chances seemingly materialise out of thin air and should have a huge say in the Demons' chances in 2025
27. Pollard (MRM) - Nuggety former VFL captain who is a tackling machine in the midfield. Beena need him on song to be competitive in top echelon.
28. Windhager (DIN) - Supremely athletic key defender who is probably the best pure lockdown back in the comp. The brother of AFL Saint Marcus can also play ruck to give the Dingoes' midfield a supercharge in dire circumstances.
29. Weickhardt (CHE) - Cheltenham stalwart who has done everything in Southern footy, beginning to show his age now (only played a handful of games in 2024) but as good as any in the competition on his day.
30. Purcell (SPM) - The VFL listed big man has a sizeable impact in any area of the ground, particularly in the ruck, where his grace and athleticism contrasts the physicality of Halliday beautifully. Might be seen less at Southern level this year.
31. Lehmann (PMC) - SANFL premiership player arrives at the Colts to finally give them some structure behind the ball, may be the competition's pre-eminent shutdown defender by season's end.
32. Garnaut (CHE) - Soldily built ruck-forward with a great set of hands and deadeye accuracy. Remains to be seen if he'll play more in the ruck this year as his tap work is phenomenal.
33. Rodgers (MRM) - Diminutive, electric utility who can play a variety of roles for Beena (or in the VFL), with his manic pressure and panache with the ball giving the Lions a true game-breaker.
34. Corp (EB) - Uber consistent forward who provides a brilliant option for the Vampires forward of centre. Elite link-up player due to his excellent work rate.
35. Dessent (EB) - Arrives at the Vampires with big wraps, the former Montrose captain is ready to fill the Hutchison sized hole in their midfield. His dominance in the Eastern league should translate well to the SFNL.
36. Stretton (DIN) - Contested beast in the midfield who does the dirty work, freeing up his more attacking teammates to wreak havoc going forward.
37. Michael (MRM) - The former Division 2 league medallist steps up to the top level. His agility, sure kicking and ability to hit the scoreboard work well with Pollard's dogged defensive intent.
38. Smart (BNT) - Dominant ruckman who makes his return to Southern after a couple of years as an elite ruckman in the strong Gippsland league. Whether or not he can provide his midfielders first use will prove telling in the Demons' survival hopes.
39. Scollo (MRM) - Murrumbeena's marquee recruit. 2022 Sandringham Dragons premiership player who has plied his trade in the VFL and for De La Salle in the VAFA as a strong marking utility. Will probably wind up playing forward to replace Elton.
40. Darbyshire (CRA) - Towering wingman with a habit of hitting the scoreboard. His offensive flair serves as the Eagles' secondary attacking engine behind Roscoe.
41. Richardson (NW) - Former OEFNL league medallist in 2023 for the Magpies. Returns after a year off but is apparently in cracking shape. Will be handful for opposing centre half-backs.
42. Hendy (SD) - Opportunistic forward who has as much creativity as he does pressure. Expect a massive amount of goals from him now that Springy will be stronger through the middle of the ground.
43. Benton (DIN) - Injury ravaged the young gun's 2024, but there is no doubt that he is one of the most talented wingmen in the competition. Came back for the finals series and was one of the Dingoes' best as they fell agonizingly short of glory. Expect to see him prominently at VFL level this year.
44. Bragg-Taylor (SD) - Spring heeled utility who competes manfully against much larger opponents. Very, very effective one on one defender due to his ability to handle both larger, brawnier opponents as well as fleet footed smalls.
45. Peet (DIN) - Inspirational Dingoes captain who is still a force in the midfield, despite being closer to the end of his career than the beginning. May need to adapt to a half back role due to Dingley's embarrassment of riches through the middle.
46. Mitchell-Rusell (PMC) - Human highlight reel of a footballer, with his aerial prowess and deft kicking anchoring the Colts' defence. Should be freed up offensively by Lehmann's arrival.
47. Howe (NW) - Gun Magpie who is always a threat to hit the scoreboard.
48. Ryan (CHE) - Lanky key forward who is one of the competition's best at involving his teammates. Also has excellent tap work in the ruck.
49. Sziller (SPM) - Flashy utility with class in spades. Equally good with his defensive intent.
50. J Berry (PMC) - Hulking ruckman who rarely strays far from the Colts' best. Tristan Xerri like tackling for a big man.

Honourable Mentions

Theodoropoulos (BNT) - Probably the competition's best under 18 player and a real shot at being drafted. Ridiculously skilful, only knock on him is his size. Should be playing for the Dragons most weeks.
B Osborne (CRA) - Lionhearted defender who would've featured if not for a devastating knee injury.
Moran (CHE) - VFL
Bonner (CHE) - VFL
Johnson (CHE) - VFL
Freeman (DIN) - Looked underdone in the grand final, but no questioning his ability when he's on the park and firing. A travesty that his hammies are made of plasticine.
Duscher (DIN) - Big in for the Dingoes. His class with ball in hand should be unlocked now that there's more bodies to share the load.
McCarthy (DIN) - VFL
Reid (EB) - Not sure what sort of shape he is in given his lengthy injury history and the fact that he didn't play for Wangaratta last season. If he's firing, will be supreme in the air. Should benefit from the SFNL's lower standard when compared to the O & M.
Grima (EB) - Another great in for the Vamps, should further bolster their defence and free up Head for more attacking duties
Head (EB) - Sure footed third tall defender that needs to stay on the park to give the Vampires' some propulsion going forward. Didn't play enough last year.
Tolongs (MRM) - Physical specimen of a key forward with vice like hands that has put up some gaudy goal totals in Divison 2. Wayward kicking and a tendency to go missing in big games have dogged him for years - however the ball's in his court to prove the doubters wrong. Will be a handful in the confined spaces of the Beena Arena regardless.
Minchin (MRM) - Former SANFL ruckman arrives at the Beena Arena with big wraps. Should adjust well to the standard given he's coming from the strong Geelong league.
S Toner (NW) - VFL
Hargraves (PMC) - VFL
L McComb (PMC) - Gaudy counting stats, but impact with ball in hand sometimes leaves a little to be desired.
M Clarke (PMC) - Despite being the reason the Colts' reserves were ruled ineligible for finals, the livewire small forward is an omnipresent threat around the big sticks and should benefit with his brother's arrival.
Soylemez (PMC) - Similar to Clarke, very skilful small who is equally adept in the air. Needs to improve his consistency for the Colts to take the next step.
Wetering (SD) - Had a very down year in 2024, culminating in his dropping for finals. Seemed to be a bit underdone, but the talent is well and truly there for a phoenix like rise in 2025.
Russell (SD) - Excellent and reliable wingman. Springvale skipper who should be unlocked further by the bolstering of their inside midfield.
Tatupu?? - Not sure if he's returning to the SFNL this year. A matchup against Edwards would be a mouth-watering prospect.
O'Brien (SPM) - Young star coming off an ACL injury. If he can return to his 2023 heights, will climb this list rapidly.
Munday (SPM) - Ever reliable defender who can rotate through the midfield as well. Does his job with minimal fuss.

 

[wonk I]

As the season draws closer. I've tried to take a stab at ranking the top 50 players in the SFNL (with some honourable mentions too!). Obviously not going to get it right, but I reckon I've made a solid fist of it.
Let me know if there's anyone I've forgot and all thoughts are welcomed!

1. Keath (EB) - Big call, but has the potential to become Bontempelli-esque in SFNL as a 6'6 bullocking midfielder who is elite by foot. Should make up for the loss of Hutchinson and then some.
2. Lonie (CHE) - Classiest player in the SFNL. His skill and guile can turn a game at the drop of a hat.
3. C. Clarke (PMC) - Prodigal son returns fresh out of the AFL system. Should function as a goalkicking midfielder, wouldn't be surprised to see him kick 40 goals.
4. Roscoe (CRA) - Reigning Ellis medallist, ridicuously classy mid/fwd who impacts the scoreboard massively - had an outstanding second half of the year.
5. Sketcher (SD) - One of the most decorated local players of his generation returns home, giving Springy a bona fide superstar midfielder who will propel them towards the zenith of division one.
6. C Lewis (DIN) - Imposing key forward who almost single-handedly turned the grand final the way of the Dingoes. Would expect him to feature more prominently at VFL level this season but undoubtedly the best forward in the competition when plying his trade at the local level.
7. Beveridge (SPM) - Superstar midfielder who actually received more votes than Roscoe for the Ellis medal, but was ineligible due to suspension. Absolutely elite stoppage player who serves as the blue collar Dogs' talisman in the middle.
8. K. Mutimer (NW) - Former AFL Eagle who has dominated in the trenches for his junior club since his return from the elite level.
9. Downie (EB) - Probably the best two-way midfielder in the competition, his tackling and speed should complement Keath nicely in a stacked Vampires engine room.
10. Hayes (CHE) - His return from the VFL sealed the premiership for Cheltenham, lockdown key defender who also provides dash off the half back line. Perfect modern day defender.
11. Hibberd (PMC) - Came in to last season a bit underdone, but with fireman training now completed, the 2021 premiership Dee looks set to have a big say this season as yet another superstar in the Colts' cosmos.
12. Kreymborg (SPM) - The two time Ellis medallist remains a matchup nightmare even as he ages (gracefully I must add), with his strength, adeptness at ground level and overhead prowess giving opposing defenders fits.
13. Feehan (DIN) - The Dingoes stalwart still reigns as one of the premier defenders in the competition, with his aerial lockdown abilities and sure kicking serving as the bedrock for one of the stingiest defensive units in the competition.
14. Dunnell (CHE) - Criminally underrated Rosella who was cruelly denied a flag by an untimely injury. Elite overhead and by foot, and his smarts and ability to hit the scoreboard allow him to be the ultimate "Mr Fix it" for the two time reigning premiers.
15. R McComb (PMC) - The former Dog comes across the west gate to join his twin brother. Should get a stack of the ball and further strengthen one of the premier midfield's in the competition.
16. T Toner (NW) - Budding superstar who is ready to take the SFNL by storm, tough and classy.
17. J Edwards (CHE) - Premier big man in the competition with simply freakish athleticism at 6'11. Needs to become a force aerially to complement his stellar game at ground level.
18. S Lai (CHE) - Superstar laser footed half back who will have AFL clubs on high alert after the success of his brother. Very similar player who should spend a lot of time with the Tigers' VFL team.
19. Walmsley (DIN) - Evergreen wingman who still runs as well as opponents 15 years younger , can 'Noodles' stave off father time for much longer?
20. Horton-Milne (DIN) - Former Dingoes champion returns home to less fanfare than his more heralded Noble Park teammates, adds another jewel to the glistening crown that is the Dingoes midfield.
21. B O'Toole (SPM) - Rangy key forward who has a superb aerobic capacity and a brilliant set shot, his poise dovetails beautifully with Kreymborg's power.
22. Taylor (PMC) - The lionhearted colts champion has been a star for a decade now, with his brutal inside game and gaudy tackle stats anchoring Port's power packed midfield.
23. Martin (SD) - Best local footy player of our generation arrives to Southern after a simply ridiculous spell with Noble Park. I've marked him down a bit due to only playing a handful of games last season, but could quickly skyrocket up this list if he gets a full preseason under his belt
24. Lamb (EB) - Mercurial key forward who is probably the best pack mark in the competition and a nightmare matchup for defenders when he's on, but inconsistency and poor set shot kicking prevent him for reaching the precipice of this list.
25. Hunt (SPM) - The Dogs will be crossing all of their fingers, toes and other parts that the towering key defender stays healthy. His booming kicking and aerial prowess will be even more valuable with the retirement of Knox and departure of Aneet.
26. Helmore (SD) - Star mid-forward who doesn't garner the plaudits he should. The Gippslander makes chances seemingly materialise out of thin air and should have a huge say in the Demons' chances in 2025
27. Pollard (MRM) - Nuggety former VFL captain who is a tackling machine in the midfield. Beena need him on song to be competitive in top echelon.
28. Windhager (DIN) - Supremely athletic key defender who is probably the best pure lockdown back in the comp. The brother of AFL Saint Marcus can also play ruck to give the Dingoes' midfield a supercharge in dire circumstances.
29. Weickhardt (CHE) - Cheltenham stalwart who has done everything in Southern footy, beginning to show his age now (only played a handful of games in 2024) but as good as any in the competition on his day.
30. Purcell (SPM) - The VFL listed big man has a sizeable impact in any area of the ground, particularly in the ruck, where his grace and athleticism contrasts the physicality of Halliday beautifully. Might be seen less at Southern level this year.
31. Lehmann (PMC) - SANFL premiership player arrives at the Colts to finally give them some structure behind the ball, may be the competition's pre-eminent shutdown defender by season's end.
32. Garnaut (CHE) - Soldily built ruck-forward with a great set of hands and deadeye accuracy. Remains to be seen if he'll play more in the ruck this year as his tap work is phenomenal.
33. Rodgers (MRM) - Diminutive, electric utility who can play a variety of roles for Beena (or in the VFL), with his manic pressure and panache with the ball giving the Lions a true game-breaker.
34. Corp (EB) - Uber consistent forward who provides a brilliant option for the Vampires forward of centre. Elite link-up player due to his excellent work rate.
35. Dessent (EB) - Arrives at the Vampires with big wraps, the former Montrose captain is ready to fill the Hutchison sized hole in their midfield. His dominance in the Eastern league should translate well to the SFNL.
36. Stretton (DIN) - Contested beast in the midfield who does the dirty work, freeing up his more attacking teammates to wreak havoc going forward.
37. Michael (MRM) - The former Division 2 league medallist steps up to the top level. His agility, sure kicking and ability to hit the scoreboard work well with Pollard's dogged defensive intent.
38. Smart (BNT) - Dominant ruckman who makes his return to Southern after a couple of years as an elite ruckman in the strong Gippsland league. Whether or not he can provide his midfielders first use will prove telling in the Demons' survival hopes.
39. Scollo (MRM) - Murrumbeena's marquee recruit. 2022 Sandringham Dragons premiership player who has plied his trade in the VFL and for De La Salle in the VAFA as a strong marking utility. Will probably wind up playing forward to replace Elton.
40. Darbyshire (CRA) - Towering wingman with a habit of hitting the scoreboard. His offensive flair serves as the Eagles' secondary attacking engine behind Roscoe.
41. Richardson (NW) - Former OEFNL league medallist in 2023 for the Magpies. Returns after a year off but is apparently in cracking shape. Will be handful for opposing centre half-backs.
42. Hendy (SD) - Opportunistic forward who has as much creativity as he does pressure. Expect a massive amount of goals from him now that Springy will be stronger through the middle of the ground.
43. Benton (DIN) - Injury ravaged the young gun's 2024, but there is no doubt that he is one of the most talented wingmen in the competition. Came back for the finals series and was one of the Dingoes' best as they fell agonizingly short of glory. Expect to see him prominently at VFL level this year.
44. Bragg-Taylor (SD) - Spring heeled utility who competes manfully against much larger opponents. Very, very effective one on one defender due to his ability to handle both larger, brawnier opponents as well as fleet footed smalls.
45. Peet (DIN) - Inspirational Dingoes captain who is still a force in the midfield, despite being closer to the end of his career than the beginning. May need to adapt to a half back role due to Dingley's embarrassment of riches through the middle.
46. Mitchell-Rusell (PMC) - Human highlight reel of a footballer, with his aerial prowess and deft kicking anchoring the Colts' defence. Should be freed up offensively by Lehmann's arrival.
47. Howe (NW) - Gun Magpie who is always a threat to hit the scoreboard.
48. Ryan (CHE) - Lanky key forward who is one of the competition's best at involving his teammates. Also has excellent tap work in the ruck.
49. Sziller (SPM) - Flashy utility with class in spades. Equally good with his defensive intent.
50. J Berry (PMC) - Hulking ruckman who rarely strays far from the Colts' best. Tristan Xerri like tackling for a big man.

Honourable Mentions

Theodoropoulos (BNT) - Probably the competition's best under 18 player and a real shot at being drafted. Ridiculously skilful, only knock on him is his size. Should be playing for the Dragons most weeks.
B Osborne (CRA) - Lionhearted defender who would've featured if not for a devastating knee injury.
Moran (CHE) - VFL
Bonner (CHE) - VFL
Johnson (CHE) - VFL
Freeman (DIN) - Looked underdone in the grand final, but no questioning his ability when he's on the park and firing. A travesty that his hammies are made of plasticine.
Duscher (DIN) - Big in for the Dingoes. His class with ball in hand should be unlocked now that there's more bodies to share the load.
McCarthy (DIN) - VFL
Reid (EB) - Not sure what sort of shape he is in given his lengthy injury history and the fact that he didn't play for Wangaratta last season. If he's firing, will be supreme in the air. Should benefit from the SFNL's lower standard when compared to the O & M.
Grima (EB) - Another great in for the Vamps, should further bolster their defence and free up Head for more attacking duties
Head (EB) - Sure footed third tall defender that needs to stay on the park to give the Vampires' some propulsion going forward. Didn't play enough last year.
Tolongs (MRM) - Physical specimen of a key forward with vice like hands that has put up some gaudy goal totals in Divison 2. Wayward kicking and a tendency to go missing in big games have dogged him for years - however the ball's in his court to prove the doubters wrong. Will be a handful in the confined spaces of the Beena Arena regardless.
Minchin (MRM) - Former SANFL ruckman arrives at the Beena Arena with big wraps. Should adjust well to the standard given he's coming from the strong Geelong league.
S Toner (NW) - VFL
Hargraves (PMC) - VFL
L McComb (PMC) - Gaudy counting stats, but impact with ball in hand sometimes leaves a little to be desired.
M Clarke (PMC) - Despite being the reason the Colts' reserves were ruled ineligible for finals, the livewire small forward is an omnipresent threat around the big sticks and should benefit with his brother's arrival.
Soylemez (PMC) - Similar to Clarke, very skilful small who is equally adept in the air. Needs to improve his consistency for the Colts to take the next step.
Wetering (SD) - Had a very down year in 2024, culminating in his dropping for finals. Seemed to be a bit underdone, but the talent is well and truly there for a phoenix like rise in 2025.
Russell (SD) - Excellent and reliable wingman. Springvale skipper who should be unlocked further by the bolstering of their inside midfield.
Tatupu?? - Not sure if he's returning to the SFNL this year. A matchup against Edwards would be a mouth-watering prospect.
O'Brien (SPM) - Young star coming off an ACL injury. If he can return to his 2023 heights, will climb this list rapidly.
Munday (SPM) - Ever reliable defender who can rotate through the midfield as well. Does his job with minimal fuss.

Fantastic work there.
I have a friend from the country who really rates Cooper who has ended up at E. Bri after initially signing with a club in the WAFL

 

[Wild Thing]

As the season draws closer. I've tried to take a stab at ranking the top 50 players in the SFNL (with some honourable mentions too!). Obviously not going to get it right, but I reckon I've made a solid fist of it.
Let me know if there's anyone I've forgot and all thoughts are welcomed!

1. Keath (EB) - Big call, but has the potential to become Bontempelli-esque in SFNL as a 6'6 bullocking midfielder who is elite by foot. Should make up for the loss of Hutchinson and then some.
2. Lonie (CHE) - Classiest player in the SFNL. His skill and guile can turn a game at the drop of a hat.
3. C. Clarke (PMC) - Prodigal son returns fresh out of the AFL system. Should function as a goalkicking midfielder, wouldn't be surprised to see him kick 40 goals.
4. Roscoe (CRA) - Reigning Ellis medallist, ridicuously classy mid/fwd who impacts the scoreboard massively - had an outstanding second half of the year.
5. Sketcher (SD) - One of the most decorated local players of his generation returns home, giving Springy a bona fide superstar midfielder who will propel them towards the zenith of division one.
6. C Lewis (DIN) - Imposing key forward who almost single-handedly turned the grand final the way of the Dingoes. Would expect him to feature more prominently at VFL level this season but undoubtedly the best forward in the competition when plying his trade at the local level.
7. Beveridge (SPM) - Superstar midfielder who actually received more votes than Roscoe for the Ellis medal, but was ineligible due to suspension. Absolutely elite stoppage player who serves as the blue collar Dogs' talisman in the middle.
8. K. Mutimer (NW) - Former AFL Eagle who has dominated in the trenches for his junior club since his return from the elite level.
9. Downie (EB) - Probably the best two-way midfielder in the competition, his tackling and speed should complement Keath nicely in a stacked Vampires engine room.
10. Hayes (CHE) - His return from the VFL sealed the premiership for Cheltenham, lockdown key defender who also provides dash off the half back line. Perfect modern day defender.
11. Hibberd (PMC) - Came in to last season a bit underdone, but with fireman training now completed, the 2021 premiership Dee looks set to have a big say this season as yet another superstar in the Colts' cosmos.
12. Kreymborg (SPM) - The two time Ellis medallist remains a matchup nightmare even as he ages (gracefully I must add), with his strength, adeptness at ground level and overhead prowess giving opposing defenders fits.
13. Feehan (DIN) - The Dingoes stalwart still reigns as one of the premier defenders in the competition, with his aerial lockdown abilities and sure kicking serving as the bedrock for one of the stingiest defensive units in the competition.
14. Dunnell (CHE) - Criminally underrated Rosella who was cruelly denied a flag by an untimely injury. Elite overhead and by foot, and his smarts and ability to hit the scoreboard allow him to be the ultimate "Mr Fix it" for the two time reigning premiers.
15. R McComb (PMC) - The former Dog comes across the west gate to join his twin brother. Should get a stack of the ball and further strengthen one of the premier midfield's in the competition.
16. T Toner (NW) - Budding superstar who is ready to take the SFNL by storm, tough and classy.
17. J Edwards (CHE) - Premier big man in the competition with simply freakish athleticism at 6'11. Needs to become a force aerially to complement his stellar game at ground level.
18. S Lai (CHE) - Superstar laser footed half back who will have AFL clubs on high alert after the success of his brother. Very similar player who should spend a lot of time with the Tigers' VFL team.
19. Walmsley (DIN) - Evergreen wingman who still runs as well as opponents 15 years younger , can 'Noodles' stave off father time for much longer?
20. Horton-Milne (DIN) - Former Dingoes champion returns home to less fanfare than his more heralded Noble Park teammates, adds another jewel to the glistening crown that is the Dingoes midfield.
21. B O'Toole (SPM) - Rangy key forward who has a superb aerobic capacity and a brilliant set shot, his poise dovetails beautifully with Kreymborg's power.
22. Taylor (PMC) - The lionhearted colts champion has been a star for a decade now, with his brutal inside game and gaudy tackle stats anchoring Port's power packed midfield.
23. Martin (SD) - Best local footy player of our generation arrives to Southern after a simply ridiculous spell with Noble Park. I've marked him down a bit due to only playing a handful of games last season, but could quickly skyrocket up this list if he gets a full preseason under his belt
24. Lamb (EB) - Mercurial key forward who is probably the best pack mark in the competition and a nightmare matchup for defenders when he's on, but inconsistency and poor set shot kicking prevent him for reaching the precipice of this list.
25. Hunt (SPM) - The Dogs will be crossing all of their fingers, toes and other parts that the towering key defender stays healthy. His booming kicking and aerial prowess will be even more valuable with the retirement of Knox and departure of Aneet.
26. Helmore (SD) - Star mid-forward who doesn't garner the plaudits he should. The Gippslander makes chances seemingly materialise out of thin air and should have a huge say in the Demons' chances in 2025
27. Pollard (MRM) - Nuggety former VFL captain who is a tackling machine in the midfield. Beena need him on song to be competitive in top echelon.
28. Windhager (DIN) - Supremely athletic key defender who is probably the best pure lockdown back in the comp. The brother of AFL Saint Marcus can also play ruck to give the Dingoes' midfield a supercharge in dire circumstances.
29. Weickhardt (CHE) - Cheltenham stalwart who has done everything in Southern footy, beginning to show his age now (only played a handful of games in 2024) but as good as any in the competition on his day.
30. Purcell (SPM) - The VFL listed big man has a sizeable impact in any area of the ground, particularly in the ruck, where his grace and athleticism contrasts the physicality of Halliday beautifully. Might be seen less at Southern level this year.
31. Lehmann (PMC) - SANFL premiership player arrives at the Colts to finally give them some structure behind the ball, may be the competition's pre-eminent shutdown defender by season's end.
32. Garnaut (CHE) - Soldily built ruck-forward with a great set of hands and deadeye accuracy. Remains to be seen if he'll play more in the ruck this year as his tap work is phenomenal.
33. Rodgers (MRM) - Diminutive, electric utility who can play a variety of roles for Beena (or in the VFL), with his manic pressure and panache with the ball giving the Lions a true game-breaker.
34. Corp (EB) - Uber consistent forward who provides a brilliant option for the Vampires forward of centre. Elite link-up player due to his excellent work rate.
35. Dessent (EB) - Arrives at the Vampires with big wraps, the former Montrose captain is ready to fill the Hutchison sized hole in their midfield. His dominance in the Eastern league should translate well to the SFNL.
36. Stretton (DIN) - Contested beast in the midfield who does the dirty work, freeing up his more attacking teammates to wreak havoc going forward.
37. Michael (MRM) - The former Division 2 league medallist steps up to the top level. His agility, sure kicking and ability to hit the scoreboard work well with Pollard's dogged defensive intent.
38. Smart (BNT) - Dominant ruckman who makes his return to Southern after a couple of years as an elite ruckman in the strong Gippsland league. Whether or not he can provide his midfielders first use will prove telling in the Demons' survival hopes.
39. Scollo (MRM) - Murrumbeena's marquee recruit. 2022 Sandringham Dragons premiership player who has plied his trade in the VFL and for De La Salle in the VAFA as a strong marking utility. Will probably wind up playing forward to replace Elton.
40. Darbyshire (CRA) - Towering wingman with a habit of hitting the scoreboard. His offensive flair serves as the Eagles' secondary attacking engine behind Roscoe.
41. Richardson (NW) - Former OEFNL league medallist in 2023 for the Magpies. Returns after a year off but is apparently in cracking shape. Will be handful for opposing centre half-backs.
42. Hendy (SD) - Opportunistic forward who has as much creativity as he does pressure. Expect a massive amount of goals from him now that Springy will be stronger through the middle of the ground.
43. Benton (DIN) - Injury ravaged the young gun's 2024, but there is no doubt that he is one of the most talented wingmen in the competition. Came back for the finals series and was one of the Dingoes' best as they fell agonizingly short of glory. Expect to see him prominently at VFL level this year.
44. Bragg-Taylor (SD) - Spring heeled utility who competes manfully against much larger opponents. Very, very effective one on one defender due to his ability to handle both larger, brawnier opponents as well as fleet footed smalls.
45. Peet (DIN) - Inspirational Dingoes captain who is still a force in the midfield, despite being closer to the end of his career than the beginning. May need to adapt to a half back role due to Dingley's embarrassment of riches through the middle.
46. Mitchell-Rusell (PMC) - Human highlight reel of a footballer, with his aerial prowess and deft kicking anchoring the Colts' defence. Should be freed up offensively by Lehmann's arrival.
47. Howe (NW) - Gun Magpie who is always a threat to hit the scoreboard.
48. Ryan (CHE) - Lanky key forward who is one of the competition's best at involving his teammates. Also has excellent tap work in the ruck.
49. Sziller (SPM) - Flashy utility with class in spades. Equally good with his defensive intent.
50. J Berry (PMC) - Hulking ruckman who rarely strays far from the Colts' best. Tristan Xerri like tackling for a big man.

Honourable Mentions

Theodoropoulos (BNT) - Probably the competition's best under 18 player and a real shot at being drafted. Ridiculously skilful, only knock on him is his size. Should be playing for the Dragons most weeks.
B Osborne (CRA) - Lionhearted defender who would've featured if not for a devastating knee injury.
Moran (CHE) - VFL
Bonner (CHE) - VFL
Johnson (CHE) - VFL
Freeman (DIN) - Looked underdone in the grand final, but no questioning his ability when he's on the park and firing. A travesty that his hammies are made of plasticine.
Duscher (DIN) - Big in for the Dingoes. His class with ball in hand should be unlocked now that there's more bodies to share the load.
McCarthy (DIN) - VFL
Reid (EB) - Not sure what sort of shape he is in given his lengthy injury history and the fact that he didn't play for Wangaratta last season. If he's firing, will be supreme in the air. Should benefit from the SFNL's lower standard when compared to the O & M.
Grima (EB) - Another great in for the Vamps, should further bolster their defence and free up Head for more attacking duties
Head (EB) - Sure footed third tall defender that needs to stay on the park to give the Vampires' some propulsion going forward. Didn't play enough last year.
Tolongs (MRM) - Physical specimen of a key forward with vice like hands that has put up some gaudy goal totals in Divison 2. Wayward kicking and a tendency to go missing in big games have dogged him for years - however the ball's in his court to prove the doubters wrong. Will be a handful in the confined spaces of the Beena Arena regardless.
Minchin (MRM) - Former SANFL ruckman arrives at the Beena Arena with big wraps. Should adjust well to the standard given he's coming from the strong Geelong league.
S Toner (NW) - VFL
Hargraves (PMC) - VFL
L McComb (PMC) - Gaudy counting stats, but impact with ball in hand sometimes leaves a little to be desired.
M Clarke (PMC) - Despite being the reason the Colts' reserves were ruled ineligible for finals, the livewire small forward is an omnipresent threat around the big sticks and should benefit with his brother's arrival.
Soylemez (PMC) - Similar to Clarke, very skilful small who is equally adept in the air. Needs to improve his consistency for the Colts to take the next step.
Wetering (SD) - Had a very down year in 2024, culminating in his dropping for finals. Seemed to be a bit underdone, but the talent is well and truly there for a phoenix like rise in 2025.
Russell (SD) - Excellent and reliable wingman. Springvale skipper who should be unlocked further by the bolstering of their inside midfield.
Tatupu?? - Not sure if he's returning to the SFNL this year. A matchup against Edwards would be a mouth-watering prospect.
O'Brien (SPM) - Young star coming off an ACL injury. If he can return to his 2023 heights, will climb this list rapidly.
Munday (SPM) - Ever reliable defender who can rotate through the midfield as well. Does his job with minimal fuss.

That is some list!
Would like to see your early season ladder predictions

 

[MoorabbinMauler2]

That is some list!
Would like to see your early season ladder predictions

Thanks Mate!
Did a big write up before.
But will summarise it in short (until practice matches tell me otherwise at least!)
1. Chelt (Status Quo)
2. Dingley (Not going anywhere + loaded up big time)
3. Narre (Absolute powerhouse by all accounts)
4. Springy (Great depth, have added the gamebreakers they need in Martin + Sketcher. Arms and Walker out hurt though)
5. St Paul's (Retained pretty much the same list, other teams around them have got better. Will be around the mark again)
6. EB (Have recruited brilliantly - still worried their small forwards and backs will hold them back though)
7. Port (Elite top end, but depth will cost them)
8. Cranny (Too reliant on too few, plus their forward line looks toothless on paper)
9. Beena (Massive home ground advantage, just need to consolidate while their 19s develop massively)
10. Bentleigh (Don't really have the cattle to compete at this stage unless their youngsters take a massive step)

I'd say all of the top 8 can make finals and there will be no easy beats - competition is in a brilliant state and super keen for round 1!

 

[MoorabbinMauler2]

Fantastic work there.
I have a friend from the country who really rates Cooper who has ended up at E. Bri after initially signing with a club in the WAFL

Thanks! Haven't heard much about him. But his resume does seem to be elite, looks to be a minor country league but hasn't hampered blokes before. Will keep an eye on him this year!

 

[puppet]

Very good player list selection Mauler!

 

[Big buzz]

As the season draws closer. I've tried to take a stab at ranking the top 50 players in the SFNL (with some honourable mentions too!). Obviously not going to get it right, but I reckon I've made a solid fist of it.
Let me know if there's anyone I've forgot and all thoughts are welcomed!

1. Keath (EB) - Big call, but has the potential to become Bontempelli-esque in SFNL as a 6'6 bullocking midfielder who is elite by foot. Should make up for the loss of Hutchinson and then some.
2. Lonie (CHE) - Classiest player in the SFNL. His skill and guile can turn a game at the drop of a hat.
3. C. Clarke (PMC) - Prodigal son returns fresh out of the AFL system. Should function as a goalkicking midfielder, wouldn't be surprised to see him kick 40 goals.
4. Roscoe (CRA) - Reigning Ellis medallist, ridicuously classy mid/fwd who impacts the scoreboard massively - had an outstanding second half of the year.
5. Sketcher (SD) - One of the most decorated local players of his generation returns home, giving Springy a bona fide superstar midfielder who will propel them towards the zenith of division one.
6. C Lewis (DIN) - Imposing key forward who almost single-handedly turned the grand final the way of the Dingoes. Would expect him to feature more prominently at VFL level this season but undoubtedly the best forward in the competition when plying his trade at the local level.
7. Beveridge (SPM) - Superstar midfielder who actually received more votes than Roscoe for the Ellis medal, but was ineligible due to suspension. Absolutely elite stoppage player who serves as the blue collar Dogs' talisman in the middle.
8. K. Mutimer (NW) - Former AFL Eagle who has dominated in the trenches for his junior club since his return from the elite level.
9. Downie (EB) - Probably the best two-way midfielder in the competition, his tackling and speed should complement Keath nicely in a stacked Vampires engine room.
10. Hayes (CHE) - His return from the VFL sealed the premiership for Cheltenham, lockdown key defender who also provides dash off the half back line. Perfect modern day defender.
11. Hibberd (PMC) - Came in to last season a bit underdone, but with fireman training now completed, the 2021 premiership Dee looks set to have a big say this season as yet another superstar in the Colts' cosmos.
12. Kreymborg (SPM) - The two time Ellis medallist remains a matchup nightmare even as he ages (gracefully I must add), with his strength, adeptness at ground level and overhead prowess giving opposing defenders fits.
13. Feehan (DIN) - The Dingoes stalwart still reigns as one of the premier defenders in the competition, with his aerial lockdown abilities and sure kicking serving as the bedrock for one of the stingiest defensive units in the competition.
14. Dunnell (CHE) - Criminally underrated Rosella who was cruelly denied a flag by an untimely injury. Elite overhead and by foot, and his smarts and ability to hit the scoreboard allow him to be the ultimate "Mr Fix it" for the two time reigning premiers.
15. R McComb (PMC) - The former Dog comes across the west gate to join his twin brother. Should get a stack of the ball and further strengthen one of the premier midfield's in the competition.
16. T Toner (NW) - Budding superstar who is ready to take the SFNL by storm, tough and classy.
17. J Edwards (CHE) - Premier big man in the competition with simply freakish athleticism at 6'11. Needs to become a force aerially to complement his stellar game at ground level.
18. S Lai (CHE) - Superstar laser footed half back who will have AFL clubs on high alert after the success of his brother. Very similar player who should spend a lot of time with the Tigers' VFL team.
19. Walmsley (DIN) - Evergreen wingman who still runs as well as opponents 15 years younger , can 'Noodles' stave off father time for much longer?
20. Horton-Milne (DIN) - Former Dingoes champion returns home to less fanfare than his more heralded Noble Park teammates, adds another jewel to the glistening crown that is the Dingoes midfield.
21. B O'Toole (SPM) - Rangy key forward who has a superb aerobic capacity and a brilliant set shot, his poise dovetails beautifully with Kreymborg's power.
22. Taylor (PMC) - The lionhearted colts champion has been a star for a decade now, with his brutal inside game and gaudy tackle stats anchoring Port's power packed midfield.
23. Martin (SD) - Best local footy player of our generation arrives to Southern after a simply ridiculous spell with Noble Park. I've marked him down a bit due to only playing a handful of games last season, but could quickly skyrocket up this list if he gets a full preseason under his belt
24. Lamb (EB) - Mercurial key forward who is probably the best pack mark in the competition and a nightmare matchup for defenders when he's on, but inconsistency and poor set shot kicking prevent him for reaching the precipice of this list.
25. Hunt (SPM) - The Dogs will be crossing all of their fingers, toes and other parts that the towering key defender stays healthy. His booming kicking and aerial prowess will be even more valuable with the retirement of Knox and departure of Aneet.
26. Helmore (SD) - Star mid-forward who doesn't garner the plaudits he should. The Gippslander makes chances seemingly materialise out of thin air and should have a huge say in the Demons' chances in 2025
27. Pollard (MRM) - Nuggety former VFL captain who is a tackling machine in the midfield. Beena need him on song to be competitive in top echelon.
28. Windhager (DIN) - Supremely athletic key defender who is probably the best pure lockdown back in the comp. The brother of AFL Saint Marcus can also play ruck to give the Dingoes' midfield a supercharge in dire circumstances.
29. Weickhardt (CHE) - Cheltenham stalwart who has done everything in Southern footy, beginning to show his age now (only played a handful of games in 2024) but as good as any in the competition on his day.
30. Purcell (SPM) - The VFL listed big man has a sizeable impact in any area of the ground, particularly in the ruck, where his grace and athleticism contrasts the physicality of Halliday beautifully. Might be seen less at Southern level this year.
31. Lehmann (PMC) - SANFL premiership player arrives at the Colts to finally give them some structure behind the ball, may be the competition's pre-eminent shutdown defender by season's end.
32. Garnaut (CHE) - Soldily built ruck-forward with a great set of hands and deadeye accuracy. Remains to be seen if he'll play more in the ruck this year as his tap work is phenomenal.
33. Rodgers (MRM) - Diminutive, electric utility who can play a variety of roles for Beena (or in the VFL), with his manic pressure and panache with the ball giving the Lions a true game-breaker.
34. Corp (EB) - Uber consistent forward who provides a brilliant option for the Vampires forward of centre. Elite link-up player due to his excellent work rate.
35. Dessent (EB) - Arrives at the Vampires with big wraps, the former Montrose captain is ready to fill the Hutchison sized hole in their midfield. His dominance in the Eastern league should translate well to the SFNL.
36. Stretton (DIN) - Contested beast in the midfield who does the dirty work, freeing up his more attacking teammates to wreak havoc going forward.
37. Michael (MRM) - The former Division 2 league medallist steps up to the top level. His agility, sure kicking and ability to hit the scoreboard work well with Pollard's dogged defensive intent.
38. Smart (BNT) - Dominant ruckman who makes his return to Southern after a couple of years as an elite ruckman in the strong Gippsland league. Whether or not he can provide his midfielders first use will prove telling in the Demons' survival hopes.
39. Scollo (MRM) - Murrumbeena's marquee recruit. 2022 Sandringham Dragons premiership player who has plied his trade in the VFL and for De La Salle in the VAFA as a strong marking utility. Will probably wind up playing forward to replace Elton.
40. Darbyshire (CRA) - Towering wingman with a habit of hitting the scoreboard. His offensive flair serves as the Eagles' secondary attacking engine behind Roscoe.
41. Richardson (NW) - Former OEFNL league medallist in 2023 for the Magpies. Returns after a year off but is apparently in cracking shape. Will be handful for opposing centre half-backs.
42. Hendy (SD) - Opportunistic forward who has as much creativity as he does pressure. Expect a massive amount of goals from him now that Springy will be stronger through the middle of the ground.
43. Benton (DIN) - Injury ravaged the young gun's 2024, but there is no doubt that he is one of the most talented wingmen in the competition. Came back for the finals series and was one of the Dingoes' best as they fell agonizingly short of glory. Expect to see him prominently at VFL level this year.
44. Bragg-Taylor (SD) - Spring heeled utility who competes manfully against much larger opponents. Very, very effective one on one defender due to his ability to handle both larger, brawnier opponents as well as fleet footed smalls.
45. Peet (DIN) - Inspirational Dingoes captain who is still a force in the midfield, despite being closer to the end of his career than the beginning. May need to adapt to a half back role due to Dingley's embarrassment of riches through the middle.
46. Mitchell-Rusell (PMC) - Human highlight reel of a footballer, with his aerial prowess and deft kicking anchoring the Colts' defence. Should be freed up offensively by Lehmann's arrival.
47. Howe (NW) - Gun Magpie who is always a threat to hit the scoreboard.
48. Ryan (CHE) - Lanky key forward who is one of the competition's best at involving his teammates. Also has excellent tap work in the ruck.
49. Sziller (SPM) - Flashy utility with class in spades. Equally good with his defensive intent.
50. J Berry (PMC) - Hulking ruckman who rarely strays far from the Colts' best. Tristan Xerri like tackling for a big man.

Honourable Mentions

Theodoropoulos (BNT) - Probably the competition's best under 18 player and a real shot at being drafted. Ridiculously skilful, only knock on him is his size. Should be playing for the Dragons most weeks.
B Osborne (CRA) - Lionhearted defender who would've featured if not for a devastating knee injury.
Moran (CHE) - VFL
Bonner (CHE) - VFL
Johnson (CHE) - VFL
Freeman (DIN) - Looked underdone in the grand final, but no questioning his ability when he's on the park and firing. A travesty that his hammies are made of plasticine.
Duscher (DIN) - Big in for the Dingoes. His class with ball in hand should be unlocked now that there's more bodies to share the load.
McCarthy (DIN) - VFL
Reid (EB) - Not sure what sort of shape he is in given his lengthy injury history and the fact that he didn't play for Wangaratta last season. If he's firing, will be supreme in the air. Should benefit from the SFNL's lower standard when compared to the O & M.
Grima (EB) - Another great in for the Vamps, should further bolster their defence and free up Head for more attacking duties
Head (EB) - Sure footed third tall defender that needs to stay on the park to give the Vampires' some propulsion going forward. Didn't play enough last year.
Tolongs (MRM) - Physical specimen of a key forward with vice like hands that has put up some gaudy goal totals in Divison 2. Wayward kicking and a tendency to go missing in big games have dogged him for years - however the ball's in his court to prove the doubters wrong. Will be a handful in the confined spaces of the Beena Arena regardless.
Minchin (MRM) - Former SANFL ruckman arrives at the Beena Arena with big wraps. Should adjust well to the standard given he's coming from the strong Geelong league.
S Toner (NW) - VFL
Hargraves (PMC) - VFL
L McComb (PMC) - Gaudy counting stats, but impact with ball in hand sometimes leaves a little to be desired.
M Clarke (PMC) - Despite being the reason the Colts' reserves were ruled ineligible for finals, the livewire small forward is an omnipresent threat around the big sticks and should benefit with his brother's arrival.
Soylemez (PMC) - Similar to Clarke, very skilful small who is equally adept in the air. Needs to improve his consistency for the Colts to take the next step.
Wetering (SD) - Had a very down year in 2024, culminating in his dropping for finals. Seemed to be a bit underdone, but the talent is well and truly there for a phoenix like rise in 2025.
Russell (SD) - Excellent and reliable wingman. Springvale skipper who should be unlocked further by the bolstering of their inside midfield.
Tatupu?? - Not sure if he's returning to the SFNL this year. A matchup against Edwards would be a mouth-watering prospect.
O'Brien (SPM) - Young star coming off an ACL injury. If he can return to his 2023 heights, will climb this list rapidly.
Munday (SPM) - Ever reliable defender who can rotate through the midfield as well. Does his job with minimal fuss.

Great write up m8

 

[FootballGuy95]

Hearing that Andrew walker has left Bentleigh jumping ship just before the season starts

 

[Greg Tivendale]

Thanks Mate!
Did a big write up before.
But will summarise it in short (until practice matches tell me otherwise at least!)
1. Chelt (Status Quo)
2. Dingley (Not going anywhere + loaded up big time)
3. Narre (Absolute powerhouse by all accounts)
4. Springy (Great depth, have added the gamebreakers they need in Martin + Sketcher. Arms and Walker out hurt though)
5. St Paul's (Retained pretty much the same list, other teams around them have got better. Will be around the mark again)
6. EB (Have recruited brilliantly - still worried their small forwards and backs will hold them back though)
7. Port (Elite top end, but depth will cost them)
8. Cranny (Too reliant on too few, plus their forward line looks toothless on paper)
9. Beena (Massive home ground advantage, just need to consolidate while their 19s develop massively)
10. Bentleigh (Don't really have the cattle to compete at this stage unless their youngsters take a massive step)

I'd say all of the top 8 can make finals and there will be no easy beats - competition is in a brilliant state and super keen for round 1!

Great write ups, you obviously know your local football.

O'Brien will be top 20 by year end on your list. Kid has done mountain of rehab and is looking very very fit.

 

[notalegent]

As the season draws closer. I've tried to take a stab at ranking the top 50 players in the SFNL (with some honourable mentions too!). Obviously not going to get it right, but I reckon I've made a solid fist of it.
Let me know if there's anyone I've forgot and all thoughts are welcomed!

1. Keath (EB) - Big call, but has the potential to become Bontempelli-esque in SFNL as a 6'6 bullocking midfielder who is elite by foot. Should make up for the loss of Hutchinson and then some.
2. Lonie (CHE) - Classiest player in the SFNL. His skill and guile can turn a game at the drop of a hat.
3. C. Clarke (PMC) - Prodigal son returns fresh out of the AFL system. Should function as a goalkicking midfielder, wouldn't be surprised to see him kick 40 goals.
4. Roscoe (CRA) - Reigning Ellis medallist, ridicuously classy mid/fwd who impacts the scoreboard massively - had an outstanding second half of the year.
5. Sketcher (SD) - One of the most decorated local players of his generation returns home, giving Springy a bona fide superstar midfielder who will propel them towards the zenith of division one.
6. C Lewis (DIN) - Imposing key forward who almost single-handedly turned the grand final the way of the Dingoes. Would expect him to feature more prominently at VFL level this season but undoubtedly the best forward in the competition when plying his trade at the local level.
7. Beveridge (SPM) - Superstar midfielder who actually received more votes than Roscoe for the Ellis medal, but was ineligible due to suspension. Absolutely elite stoppage player who serves as the blue collar Dogs' talisman in the middle.
8. K. Mutimer (NW) - Former AFL Eagle who has dominated in the trenches for his junior club since his return from the elite level.
9. Downie (EB) - Probably the best two-way midfielder in the competition, his tackling and speed should complement Keath nicely in a stacked Vampires engine room.
10. Hayes (CHE) - His return from the VFL sealed the premiership for Cheltenham, lockdown key defender who also provides dash off the half back line. Perfect modern day defender.
11. Hibberd (PMC) - Came in to last season a bit underdone, but with fireman training now completed, the 2021 premiership Dee looks set to have a big say this season as yet another superstar in the Colts' cosmos.
12. Kreymborg (SPM) - The two time Ellis medallist remains a matchup nightmare even as he ages (gracefully I must add), with his strength, adeptness at ground level and overhead prowess giving opposing defenders fits.
13. Feehan (DIN) - The Dingoes stalwart still reigns as one of the premier defenders in the competition, with his aerial lockdown abilities and sure kicking serving as the bedrock for one of the stingiest defensive units in the competition.
14. Dunnell (CHE) - Criminally underrated Rosella who was cruelly denied a flag by an untimely injury. Elite overhead and by foot, and his smarts and ability to hit the scoreboard allow him to be the ultimate "Mr Fix it" for the two time reigning premiers.
15. R McComb (PMC) - The former Dog comes across the west gate to join his twin brother. Should get a stack of the ball and further strengthen one of the premier midfield's in the competition.
16. T Toner (NW) - Budding superstar who is ready to take the SFNL by storm, tough and classy.
17. J Edwards (CHE) - Premier big man in the competition with simply freakish athleticism at 6'11. Needs to become a force aerially to complement his stellar game at ground level.
18. S Lai (CHE) - Superstar laser footed half back who will have AFL clubs on high alert after the success of his brother. Very similar player who should spend a lot of time with the Tigers' VFL team.
19. Walmsley (DIN) - Evergreen wingman who still runs as well as opponents 15 years younger , can 'Noodles' stave off father time for much longer?
20. Horton-Milne (DIN) - Former Dingoes champion returns home to less fanfare than his more heralded Noble Park teammates, adds another jewel to the glistening crown that is the Dingoes midfield.
21. B O'Toole (SPM) - Rangy key forward who has a superb aerobic capacity and a brilliant set shot, his poise dovetails beautifully with Kreymborg's power.
22. Taylor (PMC) - The lionhearted colts champion has been a star for a decade now, with his brutal inside game and gaudy tackle stats anchoring Port's power packed midfield.
23. Martin (SD) - Best local footy player of our generation arrives to Southern after a simply ridiculous spell with Noble Park. I've marked him down a bit due to only playing a handful of games last season, but could quickly skyrocket up this list if he gets a full preseason under his belt
24. Lamb (EB) - Mercurial key forward who is probably the best pack mark in the competition and a nightmare matchup for defenders when he's on, but inconsistency and poor set shot kicking prevent him for reaching the precipice of this list.
25. Hunt (SPM) - The Dogs will be crossing all of their fingers, toes and other parts that the towering key defender stays healthy. His booming kicking and aerial prowess will be even more valuable with the retirement of Knox and departure of Aneet.
26. Helmore (SD) - Star mid-forward who doesn't garner the plaudits he should. The Gippslander makes chances seemingly materialise out of thin air and should have a huge say in the Demons' chances in 2025
27. Pollard (MRM) - Nuggety former VFL captain who is a tackling machine in the midfield. Beena need him on song to be competitive in top echelon.
28. Windhager (DIN) - Supremely athletic key defender who is probably the best pure lockdown back in the comp. The brother of AFL Saint Marcus can also play ruck to give the Dingoes' midfield a supercharge in dire circumstances.
29. Weickhardt (CHE) - Cheltenham stalwart who has done everything in Southern footy, beginning to show his age now (only played a handful of games in 2024) but as good as any in the competition on his day.
30. Purcell (SPM) - The VFL listed big man has a sizeable impact in any area of the ground, particularly in the ruck, where his grace and athleticism contrasts the physicality of Halliday beautifully. Might be seen less at Southern level this year.
31. Lehmann (PMC) - SANFL premiership player arrives at the Colts to finally give them some structure behind the ball, may be the competition's pre-eminent shutdown defender by season's end.
32. Garnaut (CHE) - Soldily built ruck-forward with a great set of hands and deadeye accuracy. Remains to be seen if he'll play more in the ruck this year as his tap work is phenomenal.
33. Rodgers (MRM) - Diminutive, electric utility who can play a variety of roles for Beena (or in the VFL), with his manic pressure and panache with the ball giving the Lions a true game-breaker.
34. Corp (EB) - Uber consistent forward who provides a brilliant option for the Vampires forward of centre. Elite link-up player due to his excellent work rate.
35. Dessent (EB) - Arrives at the Vampires with big wraps, the former Montrose captain is ready to fill the Hutchison sized hole in their midfield. His dominance in the Eastern league should translate well to the SFNL.
36. Stretton (DIN) - Contested beast in the midfield who does the dirty work, freeing up his more attacking teammates to wreak havoc going forward.
37. Michael (MRM) - The former Division 2 league medallist steps up to the top level. His agility, sure kicking and ability to hit the scoreboard work well with Pollard's dogged defensive intent.
38. Smart (BNT) - Dominant ruckman who makes his return to Southern after a couple of years as an elite ruckman in the strong Gippsland league. Whether or not he can provide his midfielders first use will prove telling in the Demons' survival hopes.
39. Scollo (MRM) - Murrumbeena's marquee recruit. 2022 Sandringham Dragons premiership player who has plied his trade in the VFL and for De La Salle in the VAFA as a strong marking utility. Will probably wind up playing forward to replace Elton.
40. Darbyshire (CRA) - Towering wingman with a habit of hitting the scoreboard. His offensive flair serves as the Eagles' secondary attacking engine behind Roscoe.
41. Richardson (NW) - Former OEFNL league medallist in 2023 for the Magpies. Returns after a year off but is apparently in cracking shape. Will be handful for opposing centre half-backs.
42. Hendy (SD) - Opportunistic forward who has as much creativity as he does pressure. Expect a massive amount of goals from him now that Springy will be stronger through the middle of the ground.
43. Benton (DIN) - Injury ravaged the young gun's 2024, but there is no doubt that he is one of the most talented wingmen in the competition. Came back for the finals series and was one of the Dingoes' best as they fell agonizingly short of glory. Expect to see him prominently at VFL level this year.
44. Bragg-Taylor (SD) - Spring heeled utility who competes manfully against much larger opponents. Very, very effective one on one defender due to his ability to handle both larger, brawnier opponents as well as fleet footed smalls.
45. Peet (DIN) - Inspirational Dingoes captain who is still a force in the midfield, despite being closer to the end of his career than the beginning. May need to adapt to a half back role due to Dingley's embarrassment of riches through the middle.
46. Mitchell-Rusell (PMC) - Human highlight reel of a footballer, with his aerial prowess and deft kicking anchoring the Colts' defence. Should be freed up offensively by Lehmann's arrival.
47. Howe (NW) - Gun Magpie who is always a threat to hit the scoreboard.
48. Ryan (CHE) - Lanky key forward who is one of the competition's best at involving his teammates. Also has excellent tap work in the ruck.
49. Sziller (SPM) - Flashy utility with class in spades. Equally good with his defensive intent.
50. J Berry (PMC) - Hulking ruckman who rarely strays far from the Colts' best. Tristan Xerri like tackling for a big man.

Honourable Mentions

Theodoropoulos (BNT) - Probably the competition's best under 18 player and a real shot at being drafted. Ridiculously skilful, only knock on him is his size. Should be playing for the Dragons most weeks.
B Osborne (CRA) - Lionhearted defender who would've featured if not for a devastating knee injury.
Moran (CHE) - VFL
Bonner (CHE) - VFL
Johnson (CHE) - VFL
Freeman (DIN) - Looked underdone in the grand final, but no questioning his ability when he's on the park and firing. A travesty that his hammies are made of plasticine.
Duscher (DIN) - Big in for the Dingoes. His class with ball in hand should be unlocked now that there's more bodies to share the load.
McCarthy (DIN) - VFL
Reid (EB) - Not sure what sort of shape he is in given his lengthy injury history and the fact that he didn't play for Wangaratta last season. If he's firing, will be supreme in the air. Should benefit from the SFNL's lower standard when compared to the O & M.
Grima (EB) - Another great in for the Vamps, should further bolster their defence and free up Head for more attacking duties
Head (EB) - Sure footed third tall defender that needs to stay on the park to give the Vampires' some propulsion going forward. Didn't play enough last year.
Tolongs (MRM) - Physical specimen of a key forward with vice like hands that has put up some gaudy goal totals in Divison 2. Wayward kicking and a tendency to go missing in big games have dogged him for years - however the ball's in his court to prove the doubters wrong. Will be a handful in the confined spaces of the Beena Arena regardless.
Minchin (MRM) - Former SANFL ruckman arrives at the Beena Arena with big wraps. Should adjust well to the standard given he's coming from the strong Geelong league.
S Toner (NW) - VFL
Hargraves (PMC) - VFL
L McComb (PMC) - Gaudy counting stats, but impact with ball in hand sometimes leaves a little to be desired.
M Clarke (PMC) - Despite being the reason the Colts' reserves were ruled ineligible for finals, the livewire small forward is an omnipresent threat around the big sticks and should benefit with his brother's arrival.
Soylemez (PMC) - Similar to Clarke, very skilful small who is equally adept in the air. Needs to improve his consistency for the Colts to take the next step.
Wetering (SD) - Had a very down year in 2024, culminating in his dropping for finals. Seemed to be a bit underdone, but the talent is well and truly there for a phoenix like rise in 2025.
Russell (SD) - Excellent and reliable wingman. Springvale skipper who should be unlocked further by the bolstering of their inside midfield.
Tatupu?? - Not sure if he's returning to the SFNL this year. A matchup against Edwards would be a mouth-watering prospect.
O'Brien (SPM) - Young star coming off an ACL injury. If he can return to his 2023 heights, will climb this list rapidly.
Munday (SPM) - Ever reliable defender who can rotate through the midfield as well. Does his job with minimal fuss.

no. 25 HUNT, hear he has retired from injuries. Sad he was a VG player.
Any practice matches on the horizon, a fill in now cricket is almost finished.

 

[Nepotism]

Great write ups, you obviously know your local football.

O'Brien will be top 20 by year end on your list. Kid has done mountain of rehab and is looking very very fit.

Aren't you Matt O'Brien's dad?

He is a Great kid.

Is he still on Collingwood's list?

 

[Greg Tivendale]

Aren't you Matt O'Brien's dad?

He is a Great kid.

Is he still on Collingwood's list?

Not his dad, i'm from the club so just can see the focus and commitment this guy has on his approach to football.

He's VFL listed with the Pies which is great as he didn't get a chance to show his ability last year at that level due to injury.

I hope we don't see him play many games in the Doggies colours because it means he'll be cracking in at VFL

 

[bedford]

Not his dad, i'm from the club so just can see the focus and commitment this guy has on his approach to football.

He's VFL listed with the Pies which is great as he didn't get a chance to show his ability last year at that level due to injury.

I hope we don't see him play many games in the Doggies colours because it means he'll be cracking in at VFL

Do you have an under 19s this year