Showdown Medal

[RooDog]

Mattner for sure! i was at the game and was rather suprised when Roo won, he did play well but i thought he was behind Mattner, Torney and McGregor. Mattner ran hard all day, chased, delivered the ball well, broke the lines, i think the problem with this is those people all had the stats and what normally happens happend, they give the best player to the noe with more stats. Well done Marty great game

 

[arrowman]

At the time of the announcement I was thinking (in between booing Rucci ) "This is going to be hard, Mattner?". So I'll stick with that.

(Looks at poll) Hmm, I'm a judge

Could have been any one of 4 or 5, including Roo.

I'm glad The Fearless Leader got it, end of the day I'm sure it was a close vote.

 

[Jars458]

If Mattner had done what Roo did we would have made him the automatic choice.

Roo gets judged by higher standards and I gueess we all thought Mattner should win it because its close to his best game for the Club.

Roo was very good though and was deserving of the win. Now he is tied with Francou! Lets hop he gets ahead of him in the next one!

 

[lozstar]

It didnt bother me that Roo won, because he did deserve it.. Just it would have been nice if somebody else had, say Mattner for example, as it would have been a nice confidence booster for him.

 

[Steve Dore]

I tipped Roo for the medal. Not being a Crows supporter I probably did not attribute some of what Mattner did to Marty as he's not as instantly recognisable as Roo .........plus I was having trouble seeing through the tears

 

[Damp Squarie]

what about goodwin? am i the only one to vote for him, his long kicking was very good, esp going forward

He played a great game.
I yearn for the day his accuracy on goal returns. He's not far off a bagful in a season but I seem to remember his accuracy earlier in his career was a lot better.

Dunno if anybody could provide some stats on that....maybe its just a perception I have.

...and Macca23 its been a great two days.
Believe it or not I had two Pork supporters come to my office today to offer congratulations on a game well won

 

[macca23]

...and Macca23 its been a great two days.
Believe it or not I had two Pork supporters come to my office today to offer congratulations on a game well won

Times have changed TJ.

In the old days you would have copped nothing but abuse and get told to fk off!!