Tackle points you're still waiting for...

[Drummond]

Post in here all the robbed tackle points you've accumulated over the years.

Pav should've had 1 if not 2 more tackles than he's currently being credited for.

And just quietly I'm waiting for a tackle from McLean to count against Brisbane this year and one from Bowden a few years back.

 

[KouDogg]

I could have sworn Goddard had more than 1 tackle on friday.

I counted at least 3-4....

 

[Benno_900]

Just to clarify ... tackle only counts if it stops play, ball goes into dispute or disposal goes to the opposition (in this case even just a tug of the jumper counts). If the tackle is clear but ball goes directly to teammate, it isn't counted.

Aker pinned someone for holding the ball in the first qtr of the last match (can't be any more obvious a tackle) and he still didn't have a tackle on the stats page in the first half. He finished with 2 but have know idea if it was added later on.

 

[geelong16]

Apparently ive lost the eliminator by 1 point, even though it says on the live scores cross is 101 but on gameday live he is 97, this goes for a few players, im confused

 

[54Dogs]

Apparently ive lost the eliminator by 1 point, even though it says on the live scores cross is 101 but on gameday live he is 97, this goes for a few players, im confused

Now THAT is a bad beat.

 

[Teh_Nub]

A tackle is a tackle and they should count one as such.

 

[lifelike_]

Not a tackle, but Hill took a mark from a kick off the ground in the first term, which was paid by the ump but didn't come up on the live stats.

 

[Kennyrocks]

Post in here all the robbed tackle points you've accumulated over the years.

Pav should've had 1 if not 2 more tackles than he's currently being credited for.

And just quietly I'm waiting for a tackle from McLean to count against Brisbane this year and one from Bowden a few years back.

Grr! That would win me my league game!
Any chance of him getting them retrospectively between now and DT opening again?

 

[Mr Hard Ball Get]

i was just going to make a thread similar to this but about a specific player....robert murphy, some guy at champion data must love this guy, all he has to do is touch someone to get 4 points whilst ibbotson clearly tackled about 30 seconds earlier and brought the ball into dispute and got plus 0

 

[cryptor]

Grr! That would win me my league game!
Any chance of him getting them retrospectively between now and DT opening again?

Funnily enough, me too! I lost one of my league matches by 5 points. If during the verification of the scores it's found Pav did have 2 tackles that haven't been accounted for (and no one elses score is stuffed) I should end up winning that match. Here's hoping.

 

[Kennyrocks]

Funnily enough, me too! I lost one of my league matches by 5 points. If during the verification of the scores it's found Pav did have 2 tackles that haven't been accounted for (and no one elses score is stuffed) I should end up winning that match. Here's hoping.

Yeah here's hoping, I really don't think it will happen though

 

[jaxx]

Just to clarify ... tackle only counts if it stops play, ball goes into dispute or disposal goes to the opposition (in this case even just a tug of the jumper counts). If the tackle is clear but ball goes directly to teammate, it isn't counted.

Good to know, thanks

 

[Kennyrocks]

Just to clarify ... tackle only counts if it stops play, ball goes into dispute or disposal goes to the opposition (in this case even just a tug of the jumper counts). If the tackle is clear but ball goes directly to teammate, it isn't counted.

Aker pinned someone for holding the ball in the first qtr of the last match (can't be any more obvious a tackle) and he still didn't have a tackle on the stats page in the first half. He finished with 2 but have know idea if it was added later on.

Yeah, thanks Benno. That does seem a little strange to me, because if someone lays a beautiful tackle but the guy handballs it to a team-mate, surely that should be counted as a tackle?

 

[huggy_b]

I have given up trying to ascertain whether or not a player has tackled someone or not. I've watched Judd play and not seen him tackle much at all, only to see 8 tackles in his stats. What they do and don't constitute as a tackle baffles me.

 

[Benno_900]

I have given up trying to ascertain whether or not a player has tackled someone or not. I've watched Judd play and not seen him tackle much at all, only to see 8 tackles in his stats. What they do and don't constitute as a tackle baffles me.

I think even making clear contact with the player which helps make their disposal ineffective is actually counted as a tackle.

Remember Bones a few weeks ago just pushing an opponent over the boundary line (not even grabbing them) and he was credited with a tackle.

 

[potatomasher]

Yeah, thanks Benno. That does seem a little strange to me, because if someone lays a beautiful tackle but the guy handballs it to a team-mate, surely that should be counted as a tackle?

It's not that good a tackle if the player handballs it to a teammate.

 

[Big_Tazz]

tough luck, u win some u lose some, same thing happened to me last yr round 9... Rosa

got i think 95 and i swear to everyone he got 2 hard tackles in the last moments of play

which should have got him 103, but i didnt, and lost my lg match, and they were 100%

proper tackles...