They don't and never really have. Outside of the Storm, league in Vic in non-existent and the concept of some kind of 'local feeder path' is bordering on fantasy.Just some thoughts on Blue Pulse 's commentary on academies
AFL is a game for smaller bodied faster runner or tall KPP types who are fast runners - it has stopped being a game for all body types. The typical AFL teen in NSW isnt big enough, strong enough to play rugby code and isnt skilled enough to have a chance to make it in soccer. There are no schoolboy heroes playing AFL. The best comparison that can be made is Melbourne Storm - where are they going to source local talented kids in Melb?
So the academies are a brilliant initiative in trying to make a space for kids interested in AFL a place where they can focus on what it takes to make it as a potential AFL player. There is no 'magic' in the occassioonal excellent draftee from academies - it is just law of large numbers in operaration and a lot of hard work from young boys and whatever assistance they can get from AFL enthiusiasts volunteering to coach.
Once selected into AFL - there is no doubt that Sydney is one of the better development Clubs. They have invested in their youth and insist on standards of physical and skills development in line with best practise.
Carlton has just got its own reserves Club in 2021 we as a CLub ceded development of youth to affiliated Club(s) who always had their own agendas which was fair enough too - this has always been the biggest issue behind inability to develop young players - and the #1 issue why Carlton has not become a sustainable finals team in AFL. How many people on this forum have stated that Carlton VFL is a negative space for talented kids to develop?
I want people to understand what giving away 20 years of proper development control actually means for where Carlton is coming from - essentially handing competitive and strategic advantage over to most of our AFL competitors at best a limp wristed wave of the arm regarding investing in youth and getting the most out of young draftees.
That is where the Board and management has failed Carlton the most.
We will only begin to get the real benefit of our reserves team over the medium term - and only if proper investment in good coaches and staff is also made there. Bothers me to read that young draftees are pizzed orf with the lack of support they get versus their peers in other Clubs - this has to be fixed now and to read that the CLub is only now spending 200k to do a 'benchmarking test' on best practise for developing youth- - now that is just pathetic.
Looking in from the outside - we are over invested in administration and under invested in hands on development - and trying to play catch up at a time when the AFL has madated less development budgets - forcing a reduction in paid professional development staff. This means that as a starting player in proper development - without any real systems or IP or prcoess that have been proven in place we will continue to be in a disadvantaged position until at lest we have the same overall framework in place that the better teams do. If we want to know when the Club is actually doiung well - look at the performance of the VFL team versus its competitors in AFL.
The Rebels do ok out of it now, there's a reasonable local rugby comp here and the kids are making their way up into the Rebels/Super Rugby/Wallabies. Jordan Uelese, Rob Leota, Trevor Hosea, big Pone Fa’amausili, Rob Valentini who moved to the Brumbies, etc. They used to have to move away to other states to make it (Matt Toomua, Christian Leali'ifano, Digby Ioane, Rocky Elsom, etc) but now come through their local development and feeder system. The keep an eye on them and work with them from an early age and try and steer them through the pathway.
With our reserves, I think you're right in that it's a medium term prospect to reach a point of significant change. However I think it's also going to be pretty much instantaneous to start seeing some benefit. Being able to share tactics/structure/gameplan (provided we sort out what we're doing in the seniors...) and selecting our AFL listed players in their position, rather than more senior VFL-only players getting ahead of them, means our boys in the twos can actually work on their game. Stocker, Carroll, Philp playing mid, Durden small forward, Cottrell and O'Brien on the wings, etc.





