Remove this Banner Ad

Mega Thread The Next AFC Coach?

Who do you think will be the next coach

  • Stuart Dew

    Votes: 73 17.0%
  • Leigh Tudor

    Votes: 17 4.0%
  • Scott Burns

    Votes: 5 1.2%
  • Peter Sumich

    Votes: 14 3.3%
  • Nathan Bassett

    Votes: 145 33.7%
  • John Blakey

    Votes: 7 1.6%
  • Brendon Bolton

    Votes: 47 10.9%
  • Alastair Clarkson

    Votes: 85 19.8%
  • Brett Kirk

    Votes: 7 1.6%
  • OTHER

    Votes: 30 7.0%

  • Total voters
    430

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I think Bassett will be a very good senior coach one day.

Ideally though he'd spend several more years in the AFL system, perhaps experience a different role, different club or different senior coach, and then step into a senior role.

It's only because our job is available that he's being mentioned this early in his career. If it was Gold Coast instead of us who had the coaching vacancy no one would be mentioning Bassett.

Still, sometimes planets don't align. It might be a fraction early for Bassett in an ideal world but you can't always get exactly what you want.

No matter who coaches us Camporeale, Clarke and Bickley cannot be part of the coaching team. Regardless of whether they are any good, they have been there a long time, we have had minimal success during their time and we need some fresh voices and ideas.

Agree with what you've said here, basically the same thoughts that are running through my head.

Its probably a touch early for Bassett, my ideal would be a coach >40 years old who has had experience at multiple clubs along with success at junior grades.

However, beyond perhaps Clarkson and Longmire, who probably aren't really available anyway, there's not many in the field that particularly excite me and when I look at Bassett, I love what he was able to do at Norwood.

He has essentially turned a club from a basket case, to one primed for success well into the future over the space of 3-4 years. What he has also done though is show a real capacity to get the absolute best out of his players, he has turned average SANFL footballers, into gun SANFL players and decent AFL footballers. It would be interesting to see what he could do with players with a higher level of talent.

One thing that I think defines the absolute best coaches, is they can make average footballers look like A-Graders and if Bass could translate what he did at SANFL level to AFL level he will make for an extremely good coach and perhaps he is the best option, with some senior heads around him.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

We don't need another rookie coach. That would be a backward step considering our recent appointments. If we want to stop the pattern of player exodus we have to appoint quality. Unfortunately there are not many of that calibre available so will be a tough ask but let's see if our new boss has some tricks up his sleeve.
The only trick he needs up his sleeve is a huge wad of money.
 
Agree with what you've said here, basically the same thoughts that are running through my head.

Its probably a touch early for Bassett, my ideal would be a coach >40 years old who has had experience at multiple clubs along with success at junior grades.

However, beyond perhaps Clarkson and Longmire, who probably aren't really available anyway, there's not many in the field that particularly excite me and when I look at Bassett, I love what he was able to do at Norwood.

He has essentially turned a club from a basket case, to one primed for success well into the future over the space of 3-4 years. What he has also done though is show a real capacity to get the absolute best out of his players, he has turned average SANFL footballers, into gun SANFL players and decent AFL footballers. It would be interesting to see what he could do with players with a higher level of talent.

One thing that I think defines the absolute best coaches, is they can make average footballers look like A-Graders and if Bass could translate what he did at SANFL level to AFL level he will make for an extremely good coach and perhaps he is the best option, with some senior heads around him.
It wasn't 3-4 years, it was 1 year. In his first year he took Norwood to 2nd, a kick and a broken jaw to Phillips away from winning the flag from the juggernaut Centrals.

Yes there is romance from Norwood supporters but that's because we've witnessed first hand what he is capable of. Our club right now needs hope and a coach that will inspire supporters. Clarkson has that in spades but he's not coming. Bassett is capable of bringing that. I don't buy into only 1 year in the AFL system. He had a long AFL career as a player. He coached a club for 4 years and has now had another year in the AFL as a coach.

He's a strong individual who could handle the load.

But alas I doubt we will pick him. If we go with the safe option of a Ratten then that will be disappointing, he will be a good choice but not great.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I don't consider Dew as the right fit for the AFC, but that's from my distant view. As Mike Smyth said this appointment is so important. We just cannot have sacked Sando and cast our fate to the winds! Bassett put Norwood back together where other coaches over many years had failed. He has the runs on the board. I fail to see how the unproven Dew, even with a couple of extra years at assistant AFL level, (and excluding the calibre of his girlfriends) can be compared with Bassett.
 
If we think Bass is "maybe 12-24 months off ready" we'll miss out on him.

Even better than Clarko now would be to land the next Clarko.

We want a 10-year coach to build a dynasty. Bass is the man, and build around him all he needs. Get the off-field employees elite & stable, and increasingly players will see that we're an exciting destination.

But even if we get Clarkson (ha!), how long would we have him?

We should not settle for a spike, we want to build an Everest!
 
Last edited:
I've still got crows supporters saying that clarko will be out next coach but that is wishful thinking. I reckon it'll be one of these

Nathan Bassett
Stuart dew
Brett ratten
Leigh Tudor
In saying that I would not want Brett ratten but the others could be alright heard a lot of good things about Leigh Tudor although he is bad with the media apparently.
 
I don't consider Dew as the right fit for the AFC, but that's from my distant view. As Mike Smyth said this appointment is so important. We just cannot have sacked Sando and cast our fate to the winds! Bassett put Norwood back together where other coaches over many years had failed. He has the runs on the board. I fail to see how the unproven Dew, even with a couple of extra years at assistant AFL level, (and excluding the calibre of his girlfriends) can be compared with Bassett.
So true, but really the AFC has shocked everyone by being so decisive and unforgiving in it's sacking of sando, drawing vitriol from journos and Football identities all over Australia.

To act that way, then promise drastic change - a revolution as this board is calling it, and say we will get the best of the best people in the right places to take the club towards a premiership, and then to appoint Bassett, an untried AFL senior coach - an ex-player no less who will be seen as more of the same and a new boys club member, will take amateurism to a level never before thought attainable. I hope the AFC is better prepared than that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top