Drugs Are Bad Mackay?
Moderator
- Joined
- May 24, 2006
- Posts
- 87,376
- Reaction score
- 182,727
- Location
- Car 55
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Redbacks, Sturt, Liverpool, Arizona
- Staff
- #51
Loved the crowd today. 31,000 real fans. The 15,000 no-shows are the swinging voters. Meaningless, substanceless fans whose commitment to the club extends as far as a Crows bumper sticker. That’s why the atmosphere was still good even though the crowd was 25% down on normal. How many people left early today? I counted zero. Give us a sunny day against a Big Four club when we’re flying and the no-shows will be there with bells on (at least until the 20 minute mark of the last quarter anyway), decked out in the finest garments the Crows Merchandise Shop can provide (price tags still on).
Another opinion-dividing game from Myke Cook. I like him but worry that he will be squeezed out for Symes this week. He started well today and took a courageous mark in front of Leuenberger but fell out of it after that. He still doesn’t seem to trust himself at this level. Each time he does take a risk – like that run and bounce in the first quarter – he stuffs it up and plays things safe after that. The club has been pretty patient with him and I’m sure it is because they are waiting for that “penny to drop” moment where a couple of his flair-tinged bits of play come off, he grows in confidence and he starts to blossom as a player. We aren’t there yet but I hope we hang on for a few more weeks.
Great game from Richard Douglas. Others have summed it up well. It is a very tough gig “starting cold” in a game as a small forward. It’s a completely different ball game being involved in the play as a midfielder to warm up and then going forward. As a permanent small forward he is ok… just ok. But as a midfielder pushing forward occasionally… well he could be a player.
It seems that the Armstrong Mystery has been solved. Tyson Edwards is going to be given a back pocket lifeline. Not the worst idea. Other veteran midfielders have played out their days in the backlines. Marcus Aschcroft and Andrew Bews spring to mind. Would we like Edwards lining up on Milne or Schneider next week though? Shudder. McQualter maybe. Still reckon it is a four-way race between Edwards, Doughty, Burton and Hentschel for mid-season retirement honours.
Simon Goodwin played a good game. Had enough of the footy and was hard around the contests. Like Edwards though, has lost kicking penetration. Old man’s disease… we should expect a calf injury soon.
Taylor Walker struggled in the first half for some intensity, especially at ground level. Has a high centre of gravity and got eased off the ball easily by Adcock and then Power which would have had the coaching box fuming. Clearly the time in the SANFL has had no impact on him whatsoever. You get what you pay for though. Yes, you pay the price for a couple of questionable efforts in the first quarter but then you cash in when you need it in the last quarter. With one point the difference he lands a bomb from 65m and follows it up with a left foot kick from fifty off one step. Amazing stuff. Game, set, match Adelaide. There are no other players on our list who could have kicked either of those goals. Maybe Knights the first one but definitely no one on their non-preferred from fifty. This is why he MUST play.
There are times in games when you absolutely NEED a goal, and you can only rely on certain types of players to deliver them. These players aren’t necessarily the ones who are the best at shepherds and smothers either.
Ben Rutten did fine on Fevola when the ball was in the air but a defender’s game doesn’t start and finish with the aerial contest. Fev was brilliant at ground level, opportunistic, slipped forward a couple of times… an outstanding game from a clearly injured player to still impact a game of footy. Too many smarts for Rutten, real poacher’s instincts. I love Fev. A forward’s forward. Rutten got two of the softest frees ever too which saved goals. Could have been very ugly for him. The high praise on here for Rutten’s game is ridiculous.
Still on the umpires, despite Nicholls best efforts to the contrary, that was the best arm chair ride I can ever remember us having from the umpires. Brisbane fans must have been beside themselves. Oh well, tough t***ies.
I’m reading some criticism on here for Chris Schmidt shirking a contest. I must have missed it. Very steady. Schmidt could develop into that Jason Torney-type player in the back half. Unspectacular, unassuming, low maintenance, consistent… the player who just does the right thing all the time. You of course need the fast runners and creative types behind the ball too, but you also need to have a guy to throw at the Milnes, Riolis and Monfries of the world. There’s a niche there for Schmidt to fill if he keeps his form up. It’s rare for anyone to waste a draft pick on a competent small defender type. Key position players and midfielders are of course the ones in high demand… so there’s not going to be a heck of a lot of opposition for his role.
I love when Phil Davis does the kick outs. Is comfortably our best at taking them. Chooses good options and can hit a target outside fifty, making him a unique player on the Crows list. Edwards’ eyes must light up whenever Truck takes one… chip to the back pocket for an easy stat guaranteed.
Dangerfield, van Berlo… both excellent. High level of impact from our two budding leaders. Thompson very patchy early. Got better as it went on. Mackay on the other hand looked short of a run as you’d expect, started well but then fell away. Nathan Bock will never have an easier game on Jonathan Brown.
Scott Stevens… geez you’d think he’d be pocketing 3 Brownlow votes given the reviews on here. He was given no responsibility forward or back as usual and was serviceable. Easiest gig in the Crows team… either takes the 3rd best key defender or sits back as the loose man in defence. Does it fine but let’s not be fooled into thinking he is anything better than the 18th guy picked. An absolute minimum standard output game from him.
Jared Petrenko - as others have said looks a bit better spending some time in the middle of the ground. Like Cook I am a fan but I worry that he hasn’t done enough to stitch up his spot. A spell in the SANFL looms unless he can nail a 20 possession game soon.
Will Norman Gunston be our next addition to the One Game Then Dropped Club? Porplyzia and Tippett both quiet and we won which is a good sign. Ivan Maric looks exhausted. Can see James Sellar getting a game this week which of course would give the match committee an opportunity to jettison Gunston with criticism immunity.
Brent Reilly was solid. And I mean actually solid, not Burton solid. Had a good game.
Michael Doughty’s defensive efforts were good again, some excellent spoils/smothers and I didn’t spot one backwards kick or handball. Hallelujah! That said, he is barely hanging on. Looked sore a couple of times and hobbled off once but returned. Spoke to someone during the week who knows him well and (no surprises) said he has really been struggling physically this season to stay out on the park, perhaps more than we realise, and has already decided that this will be his last year.
Oh yeah, is Andrew McLeod getting younger?
Another opinion-dividing game from Myke Cook. I like him but worry that he will be squeezed out for Symes this week. He started well today and took a courageous mark in front of Leuenberger but fell out of it after that. He still doesn’t seem to trust himself at this level. Each time he does take a risk – like that run and bounce in the first quarter – he stuffs it up and plays things safe after that. The club has been pretty patient with him and I’m sure it is because they are waiting for that “penny to drop” moment where a couple of his flair-tinged bits of play come off, he grows in confidence and he starts to blossom as a player. We aren’t there yet but I hope we hang on for a few more weeks.
Great game from Richard Douglas. Others have summed it up well. It is a very tough gig “starting cold” in a game as a small forward. It’s a completely different ball game being involved in the play as a midfielder to warm up and then going forward. As a permanent small forward he is ok… just ok. But as a midfielder pushing forward occasionally… well he could be a player.
It seems that the Armstrong Mystery has been solved. Tyson Edwards is going to be given a back pocket lifeline. Not the worst idea. Other veteran midfielders have played out their days in the backlines. Marcus Aschcroft and Andrew Bews spring to mind. Would we like Edwards lining up on Milne or Schneider next week though? Shudder. McQualter maybe. Still reckon it is a four-way race between Edwards, Doughty, Burton and Hentschel for mid-season retirement honours.
Simon Goodwin played a good game. Had enough of the footy and was hard around the contests. Like Edwards though, has lost kicking penetration. Old man’s disease… we should expect a calf injury soon.
Taylor Walker struggled in the first half for some intensity, especially at ground level. Has a high centre of gravity and got eased off the ball easily by Adcock and then Power which would have had the coaching box fuming. Clearly the time in the SANFL has had no impact on him whatsoever. You get what you pay for though. Yes, you pay the price for a couple of questionable efforts in the first quarter but then you cash in when you need it in the last quarter. With one point the difference he lands a bomb from 65m and follows it up with a left foot kick from fifty off one step. Amazing stuff. Game, set, match Adelaide. There are no other players on our list who could have kicked either of those goals. Maybe Knights the first one but definitely no one on their non-preferred from fifty. This is why he MUST play.
There are times in games when you absolutely NEED a goal, and you can only rely on certain types of players to deliver them. These players aren’t necessarily the ones who are the best at shepherds and smothers either.
Ben Rutten did fine on Fevola when the ball was in the air but a defender’s game doesn’t start and finish with the aerial contest. Fev was brilliant at ground level, opportunistic, slipped forward a couple of times… an outstanding game from a clearly injured player to still impact a game of footy. Too many smarts for Rutten, real poacher’s instincts. I love Fev. A forward’s forward. Rutten got two of the softest frees ever too which saved goals. Could have been very ugly for him. The high praise on here for Rutten’s game is ridiculous.
Still on the umpires, despite Nicholls best efforts to the contrary, that was the best arm chair ride I can ever remember us having from the umpires. Brisbane fans must have been beside themselves. Oh well, tough t***ies.
I’m reading some criticism on here for Chris Schmidt shirking a contest. I must have missed it. Very steady. Schmidt could develop into that Jason Torney-type player in the back half. Unspectacular, unassuming, low maintenance, consistent… the player who just does the right thing all the time. You of course need the fast runners and creative types behind the ball too, but you also need to have a guy to throw at the Milnes, Riolis and Monfries of the world. There’s a niche there for Schmidt to fill if he keeps his form up. It’s rare for anyone to waste a draft pick on a competent small defender type. Key position players and midfielders are of course the ones in high demand… so there’s not going to be a heck of a lot of opposition for his role.
I love when Phil Davis does the kick outs. Is comfortably our best at taking them. Chooses good options and can hit a target outside fifty, making him a unique player on the Crows list. Edwards’ eyes must light up whenever Truck takes one… chip to the back pocket for an easy stat guaranteed.
Dangerfield, van Berlo… both excellent. High level of impact from our two budding leaders. Thompson very patchy early. Got better as it went on. Mackay on the other hand looked short of a run as you’d expect, started well but then fell away. Nathan Bock will never have an easier game on Jonathan Brown.
Scott Stevens… geez you’d think he’d be pocketing 3 Brownlow votes given the reviews on here. He was given no responsibility forward or back as usual and was serviceable. Easiest gig in the Crows team… either takes the 3rd best key defender or sits back as the loose man in defence. Does it fine but let’s not be fooled into thinking he is anything better than the 18th guy picked. An absolute minimum standard output game from him.
Jared Petrenko - as others have said looks a bit better spending some time in the middle of the ground. Like Cook I am a fan but I worry that he hasn’t done enough to stitch up his spot. A spell in the SANFL looms unless he can nail a 20 possession game soon.
Will Norman Gunston be our next addition to the One Game Then Dropped Club? Porplyzia and Tippett both quiet and we won which is a good sign. Ivan Maric looks exhausted. Can see James Sellar getting a game this week which of course would give the match committee an opportunity to jettison Gunston with criticism immunity.
Brent Reilly was solid. And I mean actually solid, not Burton solid. Had a good game.
Michael Doughty’s defensive efforts were good again, some excellent spoils/smothers and I didn’t spot one backwards kick or handball. Hallelujah! That said, he is barely hanging on. Looked sore a couple of times and hobbled off once but returned. Spoke to someone during the week who knows him well and (no surprises) said he has really been struggling physically this season to stay out on the park, perhaps more than we realise, and has already decided that this will be his last year.
Oh yeah, is Andrew McLeod getting younger?




)


.........someone should mention that to the footy callers who raised it regularly today as a stat of significance in quick ball movement


