Remove this Banner Ad

Tippett's Gone - READ RULES BEFORE POSTING

  • Thread starter Thread starter doodle48
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Which AFC deserter were/are you most salty towards?


  • Total voters
    33
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
LOL, love the Swannies...

So one of our premier key players decides to go with you and you start swirling the cognac glass prevaricating over tradesthat may wet your whistle.
 
Fair swap then, white 2 picks in the 20s and dennis lane

White has zero value to us.

No troll, who is Dennis Lane?

Two picks in the 20s wouldn't do it.

Terry Wallace has tweeted his value is 2 first round picks; he's a knob, but he's right.

I'd say a top 10 and a pick in the Teens is what we should be chasing.

I'd have no qualms about the PSD either; enough of this bullshit.
 
Where are the crows biggest needs, you seem to have some good mid depth already for one

Fast, outside midfielders. We have quite a few great extractors on the books, but not a lot of linebreaking, precise kicking players for them to give the ball to. That above all else is our primary need.

We also may have a shortage in the KPD area once again, even more so if Luke Thompson (who still hasn't signed) leaves for more opportunities in Melbourne.

Slight weakness in the ruck, but fully expect us to draft a new ruckman rather than recycle, and no established ruckman with half a brain cell is going to come here to rot in the SANFL behind Jacobs.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

No troll, who is Dennis Lane?
This physical specimen
Trent+Dennis+Lane+AFL+Rd+22+Lions+v+Swans+4tatSlreWJHl.jpg


Ladies, single file please.
 
White has zero value to us.

No troll, who is Dennis Lane?

Two picks in the 20s wouldn't do it.

Terry Wallace has tweeted his value is 2 first round picks; he's a knob, but he's right.

I'd say a top 10 and a pick in the Teens is what we should be chasing.

I'd have no qualms about the PSD either; enough of this bullshit.

Luke Jeriko mark II
 
Love how Sydney is talked up like this Oasis and anonymous playground.

Gosh, Kurt people will still recognize your 6ft 9 frame and ask you for an autograph.

Sorry Sydney, im not interested in your half eaten ham sandwich as compensation.
 
White has zero value to us.

No troll, who is Dennis Lane?

Two picks in the 20s wouldn't do it.

Terry Wallace has tweeted his value is 2 first round picks; he's a knob, but he's right.

I'd say a top 10 and a pick in the Teens is what we should be chasing.

I'd have no qualms about the PSD either; enough of this bullshit.


I wasnt serious sorry.
 
Love how Sydney is talked up like this Oasis and anonymous playground.

Gosh, Kurt people will still recognize your 6ft 9 frame and ask you for an autograph.

Especially at the 'establishments' he wants to frequent!

First person to recognise him would be that Bob Downe 'bloke' and he wouldn't want his autograph!
 
I think the deal the crows want, unless they actually decide they cannot let him go to the psd has to involve another club.

I dont think there is a direct swap that makes either team happy with current players or current picks
 
To be fair many of us would have said the same thing about Shaw last year...if we even knew who he was.
Shaw had spent 2 years on the injury list (2010-11) and was given a 12-month contract (2012) as a last chance to prove himself. The jury is still out on Shaw's longevity. Gumblton has been in the system for 5 years now.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

From Sydney only having to give up a late first round draft pick to them not having any extra players of surplus to make the deal happen to Karma coming back and biting us to us receiving a extra player from Geelong and a low first round draft pick to make this happen.

Yep, no troll there.
If you have a problem with something they've posted report it. Taking the law into your own hands and resorting to personal abuse will only see you wearing yellow & red cards of your own.
 
What did port get for Burgoyne? 2 first rd picks, one in the top ten. They got that by getting on the front foot and demanding it. We have to be tough on this, no Mr Nice Guy. We get an awesome trade or he walks. Pick 22 is a piece of crap.

Grow some balls and mungrel Adelaide.
 
I think the deal the crows want, unless they actually decide they cannot let him go to the psd has to involve another club.

I dont think there is a direct swap that makes either team happy with current players or current picks

i dont think theres a deal that will make both supporter groups happy, but the actual clubs may take a different view.

an example being your supporters seem to want Grundy dropped/no big loss being suspended etc etc, but then he finished top 10 in your B&F.

we're more emotional than the clubs about our players.
 
i dont think theres a deal that will make both supporter groups happy, but the actual clubs may take a different view.

an example being your supporters seem to want Grundy dropped/no big loss being suspended etc etc, but then he finished top 10 in your B&F.

we're more emotional than the clubs about our players.


Agreed, its going to be a long few weeks if this deal isnt done quickly hey
 
Given that Kennedy has yet to sign - and he is a player of roughly equivalent value to Tippett - I'm thinking we're probably looking at a 3-way trade.
Kennedy -> Team X
Tippett -> Sydney
???? -> Adelaide

???? = Roughead and X = Hawthorn makes a lot of sense, but it's only one possibility.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

White has zero value to us.

No troll, who is Dennis Lane?

Two picks in the 20s wouldn't do it.

Terry Wallace has tweeted his value is 2 first round picks; he's a knob, but he's right.

I'd say a top 10 and a pick in the Teens is what we should be chasing.

I'd have no qualms about the PSD either; enough of this bullshit.

Amen, your kingship. :thumbsu:

Wallace has it right at 2 first round picks, and I don't mean 21 and 22. They are first round picks in name only and effectively only second round picks.

The combinations could vary, but I'm happy to use your example of pick 10 and a pick in the teens as reasonable and fair recompense.

Pick 10 and a first 22 player that suits our needs would do it too.

No way should we settle for anything less.
 
Pick 22 for Tippett is so embarrassing.

Real trades or Sydney groupies can piss off.

How much do you pay for a key forward? really, its full on under pick 10 stuff or go back to finding Disneyland movies at Blockbuster for $4.95.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom