List Mgmt. Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2016 edition?

[Carbine Chaos]

Mason Shaw 0 goals in 3 games against Subiaco this season.

Good that we can put a line through his name at least.

 

[avishka5]

Le Cras likes this.

yes lecras lacks defensive pressure but at least he average over 3 tackles a game in the last few years. ryan averages just around 2 tackles.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

yes lecras lacks defensive pressure but at least he average over 3 tackles a game in the last few years. ryan averages just around 2 tackles.

He's young with huge potential. Le Cras is pretty much done. Time for change.

 

[avishka5]

t

I have this feeling that David Swallow will be wearing our colours next season. West Coast have probably given him an offer after all the turmoil that's come out of GC.

Future 1st + 2nd for David Swallow and one of GC's second rounders?

north are keen on him and he probably has intentions of joining his bro.

 

[avishka5]

He's young with huge potential. Le Cras is pretty much done. Time for change.

i agree with change but my point was that he wont play round one unless his defensive game improves. I hope lecras retires and hill never gets a go.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

north are keen on him and he probably has intentions of joining his bro.

His bro who is about to lose the captaincy to Ziebell (surely) and is surely going to be phased out sooner rather than later?

 

[the harry]

yes lecras lacks defensive pressure but at least he average over 3 tackles a game in the last few years. ryan averages just around 2 tackles.

I vaguely remember someone saying there is less tackles recorded at WAFL level for a verity of reasons.

 

[Keys]

I vaguely remember someone saying there is less tackles recorded at WAFL level for a verity of reasons.

Because there's less tackles perhaps?

 

[avishka5]

His bro who is about to lose the captaincy to Ziebell (surely) and is surely going to be phased out sooner rather than later?

well north a still keen on him and they won't get rid of him with him still in the frame.

 

[eagles rule]

Drew Petrie
Hayden Ballantyne
Chris Mayne
Majak Daw
Brent Harvey
Clem Smith
A midfielder to turn into a small forward
Another baseballer to screw around

Too easy.

 

[bUCKET__]

Can see why rebuilding North offer unders for Wells. Either they get him cheap-ish, or force him to take a decent offer elsewhere and get compensation. It's win-win for a rebuilding team, they have no reason to fight for his signature. The downside of them losing him in rebuild mode is pretty slim. Wonder if AFL would be pretty happy to incentivize middling teams to rebuild.

I love watching Wells as much as Carbine Chaos loves the untapped potential of Adamson. Would be so rad to see him in the wings. Just thinking about it I can't even ughhhh

 

[Carbine Chaos]

View attachment 287618

Very well.

Drew Petrie
Hayden Ballantyne
Chris Mayne
Majak Daw
Brent Harvey
Clem Smith
A midfielder to turn into a small forward
Another baseballer to screw around

Too easy.

 

[Quinz]

Surprised and a little disapointed by the Adamson delisting. Not sure what he's does wrong, they surely were expecting him to take a few years.

Seems like he did everything right and still got turfed.

I'd almost go so far as to call it absolute trash.

 

[eagles rule]

Very well.

Drew Petrie
Hayden Ballantyne
Chris Mayne
Majak Daw
Brent Harvey
Clem Smith
A midfielder to turn into a small forward
Another baseballer to screw around

Too easy.

 

[CM9000]

well north a still keen on him and they won't get rid of him with him still in the frame.

I think we have a bit of an advantage over Norf. David gets to go home, would probably get a better deal with the list space we have, and would be playing in a premiership next year.

Norf have his brother.

I think we have a pretty good chance.

 

[avishka5]

to

I think we have a bit of an advantage over Norf. David gets to go home, would probably get a better deal with the list space we have, and would be playing in a premiership next year.

Norf have his brother.

I think we have a pretty good chance.

TBH im not keen to part ways with our first pick for another injury riddle player. Unless suns want mackenzie, im not willing to part ways with it. Like i have said before, we need to have one eye on the future. From now on we should only use our first pick for genuine A graders who are healthy.

 

[CM9000]

to

TBH im not keen to part ways with our first pick for another injury riddle player. Unless suns want mackenzie, im not willing to part ways with it. Like i have said before, we need to have one eye on the future. From now on we should only use our first pick for genuine A graders who are healthy.

I thought he was aiming for a comeback in the final game of this year. If so, then he would probably be alright come round 1 next season.

 

[avishka5]

I thought he was aiming for a comeback in the final game of this year. If so, then he would probably be alright come round 1 next season.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-08-20/hardluck-sun-swallow-injures-hamstring-in-neafl. To injury riddled to give up a top pick IMO. This years draft is good and its also deep and next years is rumoured to have a lot of high end talent.

 

[bUCKET__]

Whilst I'm drunk and ranting - yes, I have now drank everything in the house since Thursday, thanks for asking - I find the hesitation on picking up Wells simply staggering.

What, do we have a bunch of up-and-comers who will be demanding a significant payrise soon after a breakout year, should we save any remaining TPP for this? It might be the scotch talking, but can't imagine any of our players are underpaid right now. Apart from Nicnat, JK, Gaff, Shue, gov, wtf else are we spending our coin on? If we can't afford to splash out on a free agent, it's not because it's a poor investment: it's because our list managment team have invested so heavily in potato that they should potato-sacked. If we can afford Wells we have to go for it.

Is it dangerous to take the free hit on taking a free agent going to fill the main-list spot with an injury-ridden player, a move that deprives some young hopeful the chance of fulfilling their AFL career? Putting aside the empty spot on the main list we had with 2016, that promissory spot open for any of our exciting rookie crew *cough*, it is hard to see how an entire 2017-2018 seasons of a fourth or fifth round draft pick this year will be worth more than what Wells could bring if he's fit enough to play 50% of games in that time.

Roll the ****ing dice Vozzo, give me something better than another dropped Darling mark to jack off to plz

 

[the harry]

Because there's less tackles perhaps?

Even that would explain the difference if the brand of football was a little different. I'm not sure if they had a harsher definition of what constituted a tackle or what, but I wouldn't think it was a fair comparison to make or to pay too much attention to.

 

[Keys]

Even that would explain the difference if the brand of football was a little different. I'm not sure if they had a harsher definition of what constituted a tackle or what, but I wouldn't think it was a fair comparison to make or to pay too much attention to.

I was being a bit of a smart arse but I do have a faint recollection that the definition of a tackle was slightly different in some way

Also like you alluded to, the brand of football in WAFL is different - less congestion and contests mean less tackles

 

[Smeg Head]

McGinnity gone? This is Australian sports darkest day.

 

[Keys]

McGinnity gone? This is Australian sports darkest day.

The players code is no more

 

[avishka5]

McGinnity gone? This is Australian sports darkest day.

i know you're sarcastic but this triggers me LOL.

 

[CM9000]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2016-08-20/hardluck-sun-swallow-injures-hamstring-in-neafl. To injury riddled to give up a top pick IMO. This years draft is good and its also deep and next years is rumoured to have a lot of high end talent.

We have to make sacrifices if we want to reach a flag in 2017. In this case, I feel sacrificing next years draft would be the best possible way to become a certain top 4 team next season.