Trade hypotheticals

[Defacto]

joel platfull to sydney is on the cards apparently. looks like a replacement for malcheski

 

[Artax]

joel platfull to sydney is on the cards apparently. looks like a replacement for malcheski

Any idea for what ??

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Any idea for what ??

$600k per year for 8 years

 

[bungwahl]

$600k per year for 8 years

Can't see us being that short sighted. 10 years min.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Can't see us being that short sighted. 10 years min.

He's also changing his name to Joel Hatfull

 

[slowedawg]

McDonald could be replaced by Gwilt or Frost etc.

And Frawley was a forward for us.

Gwilt/Frost neither who are as good as TMac, and Frawley played as a swingman. Toby Greene's worth more than McDonald anyway. Shouldn't be cutting off our nose to spite our face in regards to getting mids.

 

[Defacto]

hawthorn should just straight swap JOR for Shitmakers if they get frawley. Maybe swap picks if they need to
could be a win/win. GWS get another KPD given the injury to Mohr and the loss of Frost. Hawthorn get another mid they can try get right

 

[Defacto]

Any idea for what ??

nah mate, he's contracted so cost will be a bit higher

 

[bungwahl]

nah mate, he's contracted so cost will be a bit higher

Can't see the Swans going out of their way to get him

 

[Defacto]

Can't see the Swans going out of their way to get him

neither, would have to be one of these trades thats an absolute win/win and low hanging fruit

EDIT: WOW sounds like its GWS as opposed to Sydney

 

[Nintendo Jones]

neither, would have to be one of these trades thats an absolute win/win and low hanging fruit

EDIT: WOW sounds like its GWS as opposed to Sydney

Heard this today. Patfull said happy to stay until the end of his deal if no suitable trade is found, but wants to go to Sydney... a 2nd rounder would get it done from GWS I reckon

 

[Defacto]

Heard this today. Patfull said happy to stay until the end of his deal if no suitable trade is found, but wants to go to Sydney... a 2nd rounder would get it done from GWS I reckon

GWS need some tallish defenders. would be good for both parties

 

[Nintendo Jones]

GWS need some tallish defenders. would be good for both parties

Yeah, the extra 2nd rounder goes nicely with Pick 4 towards the Beams trade too. Collingwood could get a better return, GWS get a defender and Lions get Beams... seems to work

 

[zb14]

Lumumba to Melb
Clark to Geel
T Hunt to Coll

 

[fabulousfill]

How about:
Giles to BL
Leuenburger to GWS

 

[hendo8888]

How about:
Giles to BL
Leuenburger to GWS

Straight swap? Really?

 

[fabulousfill]

Straight swap? Really?

Well I was thinking Giles to Port actually but they seem primed to get Ryder, and Giles apparently wants out of GWS. Wasn't intended as a straight swap maybe a second round pick also. so "updated" trade would be: Giles and 2nd Rnd pick to BL ----> Leuenburger to GWS

 

[Scully2Folau]

How about:
Giles to BL
Leuenburger to GWS

Straight swap? Really?

Well I was thinking Giles to Port actually but they seem primed to get Ryder, and Giles apparently wants out of GWS. Wasn't intended as a straight swap maybe a second round pick also. so "updated" trade would be: Giles and 2nd Rnd pick to BL ----> Leuenburger to GWS

How much money is Leuey on or would he want?

Likely wouldn't be playing 1sts, Giles wants to go elsewhere for playing time because we went with Mumford as the sole ruckman despite Giles being able to play forward. So a 2nd round pick and decent money is probably something we wouldn't give up for a backup ruckman.

 

[Dom PC]

Beams >> Brisbane
Pick 4, pick 23 (GWS pick) and Jaksch >> Collingwood
Patfull and pick 28 >> GWS

GWS get Patfull for Jaksch and a small 2nd pick downgrade. They might want a bit more but personally I don't think that is too bad.

 

[Godogs247]

I am on a roll

Beams picked it
Frawley will go to Hawthorn
Ryder Port picked it
Jones to I said Fremantle dam its Carlton
Clarke to Geelong right again
Still think Essendon will loose a few??
Higgins to North right again
Sydney will pull a suprise they need a ruckman ..Minson Belchambers???

 

[go_the_dockers]

I am on a roll

Beams picked it
Frawley will go to Hawthorn
Ryder Port picked it
Jones to I said Fremantle dam its Carlton
Clarke to Geelong right again
Still think Essendon will loose a few??
Higgins to North right again
Sydney will pull a suprise they need a ruckman ..Minson Belchambers???

Clark to Geelong, Clarke staying at Freo

 

[Andre the Giant]

How about:
Giles to BL
Leuenburger to GWS

Where do we sign up for this?? can we have Aish as well??

 

[coxy149]

Food for thought
Lions trade Merrett to north for grima and second or third round pick?

4 team trade
Western Bulldogs
Trade- Liam Jones and Shaun Higgins to Carlton
1st round pick to Sydney
Sydney
Trade- Lewis Jetta to west coast
Sam reid and Tom Mitchell to bulldogs
West coast
Trade- Sharrod wellingham, Josh hill and callum Sinclair to Sydney
Mitch Brown to Carlton.
Carlton
Trade- Jeff garlett and Zach tuohy to Sydney
Lachie Henderson and 3rd round pick to west coast

(Why would teams do this)
Doggies get a forward they so desperately need and another tough inside midfielder. Both players are young and are more valuable than their first rounder.

Sydney get salary cap space from Tom Mitchell and send reid to a club that is still a couple years away from competing. They lose jetta but gain wellingham who can play inside and on the wing, Josh hill can play medium forward and push up the ground, garlett offers small forward crumbing, tuohy is insurance for malceski and shaw while Sinclair adds depth to ruck stocks. And gain a first rounder.

Carlton get a solid player in Higgins which allows flexibility, Jones can have a chance up forward and mitch brown can slot straight into the backline.

West coast gets outside run in jetta and Henderson can play either forward or back. Playing him forward could allow darling more time up the ground.

 

[Nintendo Jones]

Food for thought
Lions trade Merrett to north for grima and second or third round pick?

4 team trade
Western Bulldogs
Trade- Liam Jones and Shaun Higgins to Carlton
1st round pick to Sydney
Sydney
Trade- Lewis Jetta to west coast
Sam reid and Tom Mitchell to bulldogs
West coast
Trade- Sharrod wellingham, Josh hill and callum Sinclair to Sydney
Mitch Brown to Carlton.
Carlton
Trade- Jeff garlett and Zach tuohy to Sydney
Lachie Henderson and 3rd round pick to west coast

(Why would teams do this)
Doggies get a forward they so desperately need and another tough inside midfielder. Both players are young and are more valuable than their first rounder.

Sydney get salary cap space from Tom Mitchell and send reid to a club that is still a couple years away from competing. They lose jetta but gain wellingham who can play inside and on the wing, Josh hill can play medium forward and push up the ground, garlett offers small forward crumbing, tuohy is insurance for malceski and shaw while Sinclair adds depth to ruck stocks. And gain a first rounder.

Carlton get a solid player in Higgins which allows flexibility, Jones can have a chance up forward and mitch brown can slot straight into the backline.

West coast gets outside run in jetta and Henderson can play either forward or back. Playing him forward could allow darling more time up the ground.

13 players agree to switching teams?

 

[woofles]

Food for thought
Lions trade Merrett to north for grima and second or third round pick?

4 team trade
Western Bulldogs
Trade- Liam Jones and Shaun Higgins to Carlton
1st round pick to Sydney
Sydney
Trade- Lewis Jetta to west coast
Sam reid and Tom Mitchell to bulldogs
West coast
Trade- Sharrod wellingham, Josh hill and callum Sinclair to Sydney
Mitch Brown to Carlton.
Carlton
Trade- Jeff garlett and Zach tuohy to Sydney
Lachie Henderson and 3rd round pick to west coast

(Why would teams do this)
Doggies get a forward they so desperately need and another tough inside midfielder. Both players are young and are more valuable than their first rounder.

Sydney get salary cap space from Tom Mitchell and send reid to a club that is still a couple years away from competing. They lose jetta but gain wellingham who can play inside and on the wing, Josh hill can play medium forward and push up the ground, garlett offers small forward crumbing, tuohy is insurance for malceski and shaw while Sinclair adds depth to ruck stocks. And gain a first rounder.

Carlton get a solid player in Higgins which allows flexibility, Jones can have a chance up forward and mitch brown can slot straight into the backline.

West coast gets outside run in jetta and Henderson can play either forward or back. Playing him forward could allow darling more time up the ground.

...you need some sleep