List Mgmt. Trade Targets 2016

[Forzaport]

Conca is 6 years in and has barely played any footy in the past 2 years. Form is well down. His value would be at rock bottom, I can't see Richmond wrangling a pick 20 or a Jonas for him.

 

[FallingLiefs]

i'd trade both Broady and Youngy but hey we can get nankervis cheaper. we're trading for overs this post-season we hold all the cards and i'm not trading a best 22 player for a fat undersized ruckman who can't get a game at a side who was struggling for ruckmen at one point.

 

[Papa G]

Forgive my ignorance (haven't seen a whole lot of Nankervis)

But why would give up either for him, looking at his stats in afl and neafl, games played and age, he doesn't seem to be that quality of a player that we would trade that much for?

I thought he played pretty well against us (Although we were toilet) and in the Prelim of the NEAFL last week he had 24 disposals, 20 hitouts, 6 marks and 2 goals. He's only 22 years old. I think a direct swap for Broadbent is a good trade.

 

[RossFC]

I thought he played pretty well against us (Although we were toilet) and in the Prelim of the NEAFL last week he had 24 disposals, 20 hitouts, 6 marks and 2 goals. He's only 22 years old. I think a direct swap for Broadbent is a good trade.

I feel we'd be over paying by doing that.

 

[Killer Power]

Gun to your head. Who do you trade for Nankervis. Young or Broadbent?

Broady. We have plenty of half back coverage. Less so with defensive goal kicking forwards.

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

Maybe I am overrating our own players but I think we can get a better deal for Broadbent than that

 

[Powerstufff]

Jonas is a hard-nosed defender I do not want to lose. period

Hombsch, Clurey, Pittard, DBJ there already. Krak there if he gets re-signed. Impey if we keep using him there. Howard with probably more potential and less tribunaliness*. Time to let go if he has any currency..

* trademarked to 'Powerstufff'

 

[RossFC]

Maybe I am overrating our own players but I think we can get a better deal for Broadbent than that

I rate Broadbent as a 2nd rounder and O'Shea as a 3rd. Lobbe somewhere in between.

 

[It Just Is]

Sorry for the intrusion however i posted this on our board and the lions as something i had heard and thought i would guage the interest here. The trade i heard was being discussed was as follows:

Port: Lose Jonas, Gain Conca
Lions: Lose 2nd Round Pick (20 or so), gain Jonas
Tigers: Lose Conca, gain pick 20

Thoughts?

I'd rather Shane Edwards...

 

[Alberton Proud]

If we trade out 3 or 4 players, on top on the half dozen already delisted / retired together with Gus and Paddy back, we potentially have a starting 22 that is over 50% different to that from this year

Surely that would buy Kenny some breathing space beyond next year's results, which is why I think we WILL trade heavily

 

[Papa G]

I feel we'd be over paying by doing that.

Really? I reckon a decent young backup ruckman with reasonable upside is worth a shit load more than a decent dime a dozen half back flanker with zero upside.

 

[RossFC]

Really? I reckon a decent young backup ruckman with reasonable upside is worth a shit load more than a decent dime a dozen half back flanker with zero upside.

Based off what I read on the trade boards, Sydney fans are willing to give him away for only a 3rd rounder. Which makes it an even better deal than trading Broadbent.

We can trade Broadbent and get more value in a different trade.

 

[bomberclifford]

Why didn't you guys tell me that hamish was on such a monster contract the other day?!

That changes everything!
No way any club- including gws and gc will go near him with a 2.4-2.8 million dollar price tag attached!

Poor hamish must have just offered himself up as trade bait because he feels guilty!
You guys cant put any decent new players around him because he's maxing out your cap.

Geez, forget trading him- your best offer will be a 2nd or 3rd rounder unless you agree to pay half his contract at his new club.

Your best bet is using his guilt to get him to voluntarily renegotiate his contract down 200k p/a

Oh god, here they come.

 

[Steve Dore]

Based off what I read on the trade boards, Sydney fans are willing to give him away for only 3rd rounder. .......

If only random people posting on an interweb forum were in charge of the Swan's list management.

 

[Kingfish73]

Gun to your head. Who do you trade for Nankervis. Young or Broadbent?

Broadbent then daylight....

 

[RossFC]

If only random people posting on an interweb forum were in charge of the Swan's list management.

The main reason they say only a 3rd rounder is because they say swans are good traders and wouldn't get in the way of Nankervis getting more game time at another club.

 

[FallingLiefs]

IMO:
Hartlett: 8
Young: 21
Broadbent: 23
Jonas: 28 (uncontracted)
Lobbe: 32
SGray: 32
O'Shea: 39 (uncontracted)
Ah Chee: 45 (uncontracted)

 

[RossFC]

IMO:
Hartlett: 8
Young: 21
Broadbent: 23
Lobbe: 32
SGray: 32
O'Shea: 39
Ah Chee: 45

I'd swap Arch and O'Shea

 

[port_adelaide_1870]

IMO:
Hartlett: 8
Young: 21
Broadbent: 23
Lobbe: 32
SGray: 32
O'Shea: 39
Ah Chee: 45

Agree with most but O'Shea would be worth pick 59 at this stage imo

 

[FallingLiefs]

i think O'Shea would hold more currency in the AFL community and then factor in his height and position too. Ah Chee is less likely to attract deals IMO. forgot to add in Jonas too.

 

[Lagooner]

Oh god, here they come.

Like an army of White Walkers advancing on The Wall.

It won't be long now until Whispers is coming either. Best get out of the way of that impending snowball.

 

[Papa G]

Probably a unfashionable opinion, but I'd rather keep O'Shea over Broadbent. Think he offers more/gives us more options. Just needs a healthy dose of confidence. I don't hate Broady by the way, but he is probably the most easily replaceable guy in our team.

 

[Adz2332]

IMO:
Hartlett: 8
Young: 21
Broadbent: 23
Jonas: 28 (uncontracted)
Lobbe: 32
SGray: 32
O'Shea: 39 (uncontracted)
Ah Chee: 45 (uncontracted)

even if we let go of half with our delistings and retirements we better have some mature players coming in!

 

[Coobk001]

IMO:
Hartlett: 8
Young: 21
Broadbent: 23
Jonas: 28 (uncontracted)
Lobbe: 32
SGray: 32
O'Shea: 39 (uncontracted)
Ah Chee: 45 (uncontracted)

Geez people are under rating Broady massively.

Broadbent is worth a late first rounder and significantly more than Young at this stage.

IMO:
Hartlett: 6-8
Broadbent: 15-20
Young: 25-30
Lobbe: 25-30
Jonas: 35-40
O'Shea: 35-40
SGray: 50-55
Ah Chee: 75+

 

[RossFC]

SGray: 50-55
Ah Chee: 75+

?