List Mgmt. Trade Week 2016 - Live Thread

[ChampRevesby]

So Melbourne the city not necessarily Melbourne the club - that's how o took that interview to mean

Yeah probably. I heard "preference is Melb" but it could be just any of the clubs. I don't think there is much interest anyway?

 

[DickDunn]

What if we trade 12, 34 and next years 2nd rounder for Brisbane 16 and 19?

Makes no sense for Brisbane. They've said repeatedly they're looking to load up on first round picks in this year's draft

 

[Altum Volantes]

Anyone know much about Goldstein?

Huge upside - apparently attempting to emulate the likes of Carey, Warne and possibly Delonte West.

 

[DickDunn]

Makes sense. Don't think there overly stocked with KPDs

Where you hear/read this?

Oscar McDonald, Tom McDonald, Frost, Pedersen - they're reasonably well stocked. Would have thought Collingwood is the best bet

 

[Galileo9]

Shit isn't happening. Did all these guys genuinely have weekend off or something?

 

[Chris_6678]

Shit isn't happening. Did all these guys genuinely have weekend off or something?

Once the Omera & Prestia any maybe Gibbs trade happens nothing to exciting will occur.

 

[SpaceClef]

Once the Omera & Prestia any maybe Gibbs trade happens nothing to exciting will occur.

Haven't traded Darling yet Dark Sharks

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Get in the ear of O'Meara and bring the lad home.

Trade our first and Schofield and bring eMac back into the best 22.

Make it happen - a fit O'Meara is exactly what we need.

 

[oak79]

Once the Omera & Prestia any maybe Gibbs trade happens nothing to exciting will occur.

Don't forget Ballantyne. If Mitchell is worth 88, surely the WCE will give up 12 for Ballas

 

[WCE_Phill]

What happening with David Swallow?

Is he still on the move?

 

[nameless]

What happening with David Swallow?

Is he still on the move?

Was thinking the same thing - very quiet there. Assume he's staying...

 

[Dark Sharks]

Haven't traded Darling yet Dark Sharks

3 days left son.

I think Logue projects as the next Bont. That's why I want him - for those attributes.

Wot? I thought Logue is a KPD. If anyone is Bont JNR it's Scrimshaw. That's why i want HIM.

 

[JackOutback]

Get in the ear of O'Meara and bring the lad home.

Trade our first and Schofield and bring eMac back into the best 22.

Make it happen - a fit O'Meara is exactly what we need.

At worst, make Hawthorn overpay.

 

[KamakazeSalami]

Isn't it always though?

Not really. I've thought the club has been pretty good with being transparent about who they are and aren't interested in. They've said they'd be interested in Adams, would look at all of Minson, Petrie, Vardy, Collins etc. Said they'd been in contact with Hogan and his manager. Said we'd be interested in Ballantyne, but had other priorities. They've also come out and said definite no to Goldstein. Club has a pretty good track record on sticking to their word. They don't really play silly buggers. Particularly, I can't recall any trade where we've said we're not interested in a player and then flipped over and traded them in.

 

[matt_bas]

Bailey Banfield is Drew Banfields son.

Bayok is a potential academy pick for us.

No he's not. Different Bailey Banfield

 

[Chad in Vegas]

Was thinking the same thing - very quiet there. Assume he's staying...

David will be staying and word is Andrew will be joining him this trade period. Goldstein to stay at NM as a result.

 

[Avalor]

3 days left son.


Wot? I thought Logue is a KPD. If anyone is Bont JNR it's Scrimshaw. That's why i want HIM.

logue is very versatile, can play defense, and did so for most of 2016, but towards the end of the season, was run through the middle and did very well.

 

[KamakazeSalami]

What happening with David Swallow?

Is he still on the move?

I had wondered about this too. Thought he'd definitely be on the move to Norf. I'm sure I read somewhere early in the piece that he'd had a medical over there and the doctors were confident they could have him sorted out quick smart.

I'd be keen on him if there was any chance we could convince him.

 

[WCErevival]

logue is very versatile, can play defense, and did so for most of 2016, but towards the end of the season, was run through the middle and did very well.

Do we want to risk another player that is only potential for the midfield instead of getting a genuine midfielder?

 

[The Falcon Strike]

I had wondered about this too. Thought he'd definitely be on the move to Norf. I'm sure I read somewhere early in the piece that he'd had a medical over there and the doctors were confident they could have him sorted out quick smart.

I'd be keen on him if there was any chance we could convince him.

Swallow?

Good ball hunter, but average pace and sub-par disposal. Add to that his injury history - he'd be a pass for me.

 

[amazingjoshy]

At worst, make Hawthorn overpay.

They don't need our help for that it seems

 

[Keys]

How the **** have we ended up with a WCE_phil and a WCE_Phill posting on here

 

[The Falcon Strike]

How the **** have we ended up with a WCE_phil and a WCE_Phill posting on here

Blloody Hel !!

 

[ziad]

How the **** have we ended up with a WCE_phil and a WCE_Phill posting on here

dyslexia ??

 

[avishka5]

How the **** have we ended up with a WCE_phil and a WCE_Phill posting on here

I thought they were the same person lol.