List Mgmt. Trade Week 2016 - Live Thread

[Keys]

Heard nothing about Marsh, have to assume he's staying put. Would be great if we could swap him for Mackenzie imo.

Not sure if srs

If so give yourself an uppercut

inb4 we get reamed next year when Emac leaves through free agency after spending the year in the wafl again

Will get a 2nd round compo pick if he does which may well be better than anything we were offered this trade period

And there's a chance he returns to close to his best form giving us great flexibility with our talls and maintains our depth which should never be under rated

 

[new breed]

Aaron Black for 92 , Geelong had a nett win of 29 draft spots .when compared to Kersten ....Black has talent just gone bad the last two years , new environment in Geelong might help Black who is from Eaton / Bunbury should like Geelong more then Melbourne .

 

[Quinz]

Aaron Black for pick 92? Win for North.

This has been one very active deadline day. Loving all the shifts.

Proves that no matter how long it goes, everything gets done right at the end.

 

[Chris_6678]

Patrick Keane ‏@AFL_PKeane 22s22 seconds ago


Trade Paperwork Lodged: GWS Giants exchange Will Hoskin-Elliott to Collingwood for its 2017 Future Round Two Selection.

 

[Forward Press]

Not sure if srs

If so give yourself an uppercut

Should've added with a decent draft pick coming the other way (eg Pies 2nd rounder), but yes serious.

I think the game has gone by him and won't be the same for us. Controversial opinion I know.

 

[pantskyle]

GWS sending everyone away for nothing.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

GWS sending everyone away for nothing.

Dropping blokes off the bottom end and keep topping up the top end.

Their academy zones are ridiculously generous

 

[new breed]

So many future picks disappearing .

 

[ChampRevesby]

Should've added with a decent draft pick coming the other way (eg Pies 2nd rounder), but yes serious.

I think the game has gone by him and won't be the same for us. Controversial opinion I know.

If he finds himself at EP most of next year then its curtains.

 

[06Premiers]

Surprised we got Vardy for so cheap. Hopefully he gets his wrist injury sorted.

 

[SpaceClef]

Patrick Keane ‏@AFL_PKeane 22s22 seconds ago


Trade Paperwork Lodged: GWS Giants exchange Will Hoskin-Elliott to Collingwood for its 2017 Future Round Two Selection.

Mate...GWS have burned so many top 10 draft picks over the past fortnight.

 

[paran]

I was expecting this

Go classy ppl!

 

[SpaceClef]

Surprised we got Vardy for so cheap. Hopefully he gets his wrist injury sorted.

 

[avishka5]

The pic of Vardy on our FB looks legit and must have been taken last week when he did his medical. Funny how it took till today to get the deal done.


Would like to see us pinch another second rounder

 

[RookiePick]

Go classy ppl!

Tom Boyd has let himself go by the looks of things.

 

[Agent93]

How you can view these players as ‘list cloggers’ and the trades as not wins for Freo is mind boggling.

I'm not doubting their potential. All of the players that Freo have traded for could be brilliant. But that is just it: 'could'. What I am doubting is the perception of low risk, and that the three mentioned all come with a degree of risk. Dangerfield was a low risk trade - limited injury history, high performance. Likewise Jonathon Giles was also low risk (albeit low reward). Both players came to their respective clubs as advertised.

But with Bennell, Kersten and McCarthy there is lot of unknowns circling them, and that right there, the unknowns, the calf injuries, the drug history, the limited time dealing with the best defenders in the country, the lack of impact whilst playing in a top side, that's all risk. I'd argue Kersten is probably the lowest risk, but he was also the cheapest, and likely the lowest reward, much like our Vardy trade.

 

[lmach]

Pathetic...

FFS why don't we just piss our picks away. Injury prone Ruck to cover injury prone ****ing Rucks.

FMD

 

[lmach]

Nathan Vardy's having a party bring your vodka and a charlie

 

[Chris_6678]

Tom Browne ‏@TomBrowne7 1m1 minute ago


Marley Williams, on the outer with bucks, has been given a career lifeline. Pick 105! @NMFCOfficial @CollingwoodFC


Wow not that is a massssssive bargin.

 

[greatwhiteshark]

Pity we couldn't get another quality mid but it's a solid trade period.

Agree, would of been nice to get another one but they are hard to get.
Mitchell hopefully will help a lot and then after a year feed Simpson the news that we need more quality mids, we all know it but clearly the club now and over the last 6 years has been reluctant to do much about it.

 

[amazingjoshy]

I reckon North have done quite well

 

[The Falcon Strike]

Tom Browne ‏@TomBrowne7 1m1 minute ago


Marley Williams, on the outer with bucks, has been given a career lifeline. Pick 105! @NMFCOfficial @CollingwoodFC


Wow not that is a massssssive bargin.

In terms of list position - they've traded out Black for Williams. Reckon Williams has much more talent - good speculative selection I reckon

 

[Nev57]

Yep.

Conner's also confirming Emac will not be leaving WCE.

I happy with that hopeffully he gets back to near aa form which will give depth and a few options now a small crummer that is ready to go and another midfielder
Plough has just given west coast an A for thier trade period

On GT-I9505 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[2006_Eagles]

"Hey guys does anyone want to give me a second round pick real quick for Jaeger?

Guys?

UH GUYS???????????"

 

[paran]

The problem with the Suns is Cochrane has shown Gold Coast is willing and able to trade both picks and players. It's nothing more than success driven jealousy and personal emotion interfering with this move which some people may consider a complete lack of professionalism on Cochrane's behalf. Mind you, that all changes if Gold Coast accepts a considerably better deal elsewhere and then Cochrane looks like a genius.

Not sure about that. How many of their key guys (guys they wanted to keep) have they traded away for unders? The got the price they wanted for Bennell and Prestia, hence them standing firm on JOM.