MVP Votes Round 20 Carlton def. Brisbane

[Stamos]

5. Carrazzo
4. Gibbs
3. Simpson
2. Kreuzer
1. Murphy

BYP - Casboult

Brockoli, Walker and Scotty(2nd half) were good too.

 

[blblues]

5- Carrazzo
4- Simpson
3- Kreuzer
2- Gibbs
1- Murphy

BYP- Casboult

 

[Aphrodite]

5. Carrazzo
4. Gibbs
3. Murphy
2. Simpson
1. Scotland


BYP: "Rock The Casboult"

 

[Silvagnis]

5: Carrazzo
4: Gibbs
3: Scotland
2: Murphy
1: Simpson

BYP: Andrew McInnes

 

[BlueTouchPaper]

5 - Carrazzo
4 - Simpson
3 - Gibbs
2 - Murphy
1 - Kreuzer

BYP - Casboult

 

[pepalenko]

5 Gibbs
4 Carrazzo
3 Scotland
2 Simpson
1 Kreuzer

BYP- Casbah

 

[Bell Ringer]

5 - Simpson
4 - Gibbs
3 - Walker
2 - Carrazzo
1 - Armfield
BYP - Casboult

 

[AB_Blue]

5. Carrazzo
4. Gibbs
3. Murphy
2. Simpson
1. Scotland


BYP: "Rock The Casboult"

I second that!

 

[goreds]

5. Gibbs
4. Carrazzo
3. Kreuzer
2. Murphy
1. Scotland

 

[blues4flag]

5. Gibbs (best game he's played all season)
4. Walker (so much better as a 3rd tall up forward)
3. Carrazzo (gun)
2. Garlett (relishing the move up the ground)
1. Armfield (lockdown player who consistently scores goals)

BYP: Casboult. If only he had the kicking to match his marking.

Kreuzer, Simpson unlucky.

 

[mediumsizered]

5. Gibbs - this is what he is capable of, start doing it consistently & he will start getting respect in the football community
4. Carrazzo - just continues to find the ball, is now one of the gun midfielders in the game
3. Scotland - the usual Scotland game, perhaps at times was a bit slow to move the ball on
2. Garlett - this is why the kid stayed in the team when struggling for form, because he is too good to be running around in the VFL
1. Kreuzer - his ruckwork in the 3rd quarter was instrumental in breaking the game open & it was good to see him get on the scoreboard as well

BYP - Casboult - you can teach a player how to kick goals (e.g. Loewe, T Cloke) but you can't teach a player how to take contested marks. You either have the ability or you don't & this kid is capable of becoming one of the best contested marks in the competition.

 

[FRUMPY]

5 - Gibbs
4 - Carazzo
3 - Scotland
2 - Kruezer
1 - Armfield (love his role this year. Has gone on in leaps and bounds and now scores goals every week.)

Thought Casboult was good, just needs to kick better. Hope okeefe gets a full game next week.

 

[The old campaigner]

5. Gibbs
4. Scotland
3. Carazzo
2. Walker
1. Murphy

BYP Casboult

 

[The Big Sticks]

5. Gibbs
4. Carrazzo
3. Murphy
2. Armfield
1. Garlett

BYP - Casboult

 

[le dominateur]

5. Gibbs
4. Kreuzer
3. Murphy
2. Armfield
1. Simpson

 

[pumped]

5. Armfield - consistently composed all match. Disposal efficiency excellent.
4.Gibbs - seemed to be much more swithched on than usual.
3.Kreuzer - typicaly lion hearted effort.
2.Carrazzo - agree with comments above about him turning into a class midfielder
1. Scotland - consistently solid

many others who warranted mentions.

 

[T2B_]

5. Gibbs - this is what he is capable of, start doing it consistently & he will start getting respect in the football community
4. Carrazzo - just continues to find the ball, is now one of the gun midfielders in the game
3. Scotland - the usual Scotland game, perhaps at times was a bit slow to move the ball on
2. Garlett - this is why the kid stayed in the team when struggling for form, because he is too good to be running around in the VFL
1. Kreuzer - his ruckwork in the 3rd quarter was instrumental in breaking the game open & it was good to see him get on the scoreboard as well

BYP - Casboult - you can teach a player how to kick goals (e.g. Loewe, T Cloke) but you can't teach a player how to take contested marks. You either have the ability or you don't & this kid is capable of becoming one of the best contested marks in the competition.

^ This.

I'll just add to the Levi bit and say yes hopefully his kicking can be worked on, but he's scored 4 goals 6 behinds in the 4 games he has played... this shows he can get his fair share of opportunities and for someone so young (still 22) to have his body and contested marking is really something to work with, so definitely BYP for mine. We actually had a forward win a contest through pure strength

 

[JustaBattler]

5. Armfield - showing each week how he is well suited to HF role.
4. Kreuzer - kicked goals and got ball out when we needed it
3. Carrazzo - everywhere and kicked goals
2. Waite - draws 2-3 defenders each time giving options for forward entry
1. Levi - keeps on clunking marks - will kick five soon

Honorable mentions Eddie and Jeff