Wakelin v Wakelin

[samthemanlonergan]

Who has been better over their respective careers?

Very similar players (obviously). But I would vote Darryl (just) because he has been better at taking the contested marks.

And yes I am being serious.

 

[HBK619]

They have both been as good as each other, don't know why the Saints ever game them away, thought that they might have struggled as the game got faster and still they managed to keep going.

 

[Falchoon]

Darryl easily, Shane's caught up recently but Darryl was the better footballer early. A much better mark.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Darryl's a better mark, Shane's a better kick - Nothing between them.

 

[J-Ro-20]

darryl because of a premiership. they are nearly the exact same player...

 

[mdc]

Daryl for mine - Shane's form has fluctuated a lot during the time he's been at the club - but doing very nicely recently

 

[Lightning_Rod]

would have been funny if the saints had kept them, i cant see how they both would have played in the same eam considering the basically play the same position, darryl for me, bias aside i think darrel is a very consistent player where as shane has been up and down, also i think for pure one on one darryl kills shane.