Which Team

[rizzo]

What team would you choose??

What one would you choose


Rules:
• Must use proper positions
• Must be 26 & under
• 2004/ 2005 form only


Please Mark on:
* Youth
* Current Ability
* Potential
* Structure (I.E: Spine)
* Overall


Jims Team
B: Adam McPhee - Mathew Scarlett – Joel Bowden
HB: Daniel Giansiracusa - Chad Cornes – Jude Bolton
C: Chad Fletcher - Chris Judd – Lenny Hayes
HF: Nick Reiwoldt - Jonathan Brown - Gary Ablett JNR
F: Mark Williams - Brendan Fevola - Chris Tarrant
R Justin Longmuir: - Cameron Ling - Kane Cornes
INT: James Bartel – Daniel Wells – Brad Green – Brad Ottens
EMG: Daniel Kerr - Trent Croad – Daniel Cross




Rizzos Team

B: Joel Corey - Darren Glass - Jess Sinclair
HB :Luke Hodge - Adam Goodes - Lindsay Gilbee
C: Nick Dal Santo - Mark Coughlan – Paul Haselby
HF: Robert Murphy - Warren Tredrea – Ben Cousins
F: Andrew Embley - Mathew Pavlich
– Cameron Bruce
R: Dean Cox - Luke Ball – Sam Mitchell
INT: Luke Power - Simon Black – Nick Stevens – Brian Harris
EMG: Paul Chapman - Josh Carr – David Wirrapunda

 

[melbournemartin]

Jims team has way mroe goalkicking power so that team would be my pick. pavlich aint a renknown huge goalkicker.

also where is Travis Johnstone?!?!?

 

[jod23]

I had to go with Jims team. Buts its close, if Longmuir and Ottens can win any ruck taps against Cox then the forward line should do the rest but if Cox dominates to those midfielders!! Then Tredrea will kick 18.

Jim's team
Pros
* great forward line which will stretch any defence and kick lots of goals.
* fantastic spine

Cons
* absolutely woeful rucking department. Longmuir??? and Ottens??
* injure someone and get Kerr in the 22. You midfield lacks a bit of grunt and Kerr is perfect.

Rizzo's team
Pros
* great first ruck in Cox. Will thrash Longmuir.
* dominant midfield with Cuz, Coughlan, Dal Santo, Stevens, Black, Hase, Power and even Hodge, Embers and Bruce running through there.

Cons
* no second ruck?
* Goodes at CHB?
* injure someone and get Wirrpunda in the 22. So damaging from defence.
* must play Cousins on the ball, wasted on a HHF.

 

[Bulldogs_West]

id go with Rizzos team with foot skills and big bodies in the middle

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

Rizzo's easily, Jims Backline arnt really backmen (other than scarlett) that stick to there man. And the fact Pavlich and Tredrea are in the same team however i'd play Tredrea out of the goalsquare and Pavlich up the feild to take tons of marks and get it in long to Tredrea.