- Thread starter
- Banned
- #51
So clever.Not at all. I don't think Grundy or Gawn had any impact on Swans making the finals.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 9 - Indigenous Round - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
So clever.Not at all. I don't think Grundy or Gawn had any impact on Swans making the finals.
You reckon Caddy has been the second-most valuable player in the comp this season?My opinion. Cheers.
Yeah but he didn't play more. So...Had he played more, I would say WCE Josh Kennedy. I think more than any other player, the Eagles have felt his absence
Did I say that?You reckon Caddy has been the second-most valuable player in the comp this season?
There’s a lot ‘I don’t like your opinion so I’ll try and make this unpleasant’ from you in this threadThere's a bit of "look at me, I'm so lateral" going on in this thread.
Did I say that?
Is that in no particular order?Overall - Grundy, Caddy, Sidebottom, Breust, Cunnington
I just think you like to be different.There’s a lot ‘I don’t like your opinion so I’ll try and make this unpleasant’ from you in this thread
No it’s not, it’s just a brain dump of players whilst I was cooking up crumbed cutlets for dinner. I think you’ll find everyone is different as we all have differing opinions.Is that in no particular order?
I just think you like to be different.
My initial thought was Grundy, but then that got quickly overtaken by Buddy. (And fair enough - this might be recency bias)
More than anyone else he wins games off his own boot, and is able to bail out his team when others arent performing - and has done so in 2 crucial games in the last 3 weeks that gives a Sydney team, that has been average for much of the season, another finals spot and a chance for a top 4 finish.
I don't think any other individual player has as much of an impact on the W-L record of their team. (Though clearly there are a few guys who you can make valid arguments about)
So who are #1 and #2 in your list of MVPs this season?No it’s not, it’s just a brain dump of players whilst I was cooking up crumbed cutlets for dinner. I think you’ll find everyone is different as we all have differing opinions.
For some reason you picked Caddy out of my list? Maybe that’s you being different.
Why the hell are you being such a campaigner about this? Why are you so offended about who I chose? If you don’t like it, don’t respond and seriously move on.So who are #1 and #2 in your list of MVPs this season?
Maybe do another "brain dump"? That's always a sign of a considered opinion.
I'm not offended. I just think it's weird that you wandered into this thread and then apparently started naming players at random as part of a "brain dump".Why the hell are you being such a campaigner about this? Why are you so offended about who I chose? If you don’t like it, don’t respond and seriously move on.
Sorry I don’t have the time to sit down at my desk and spend a good amount of time considering who might be perfect for this category, it’s BF mate, I am not writing policy for the White House.I'm not offended. I just think it's weird that you wandered into this thread and then apparently started naming players at random as part of a "brain dump".
That's obviously not true.Sorry I don’t have the time to sit down at my desk and spend a good amount of time considering who might be perfect for this category
Well it isThat's obviously not true.
My initial thought was Grundy, but then that got quickly overtaken by Buddy. (And fair enough - this might be recency bias)
More than anyone else he wins games off his own boot, and is able to bail out his team when others arent performing - and has done so in 2 crucial games in the last 3 weeks that gives a Sydney team, that has been average for much of the season, another finals spot and a chance for a top 4 finish.
I don't think any other individual player has as much of an impact on the W-L record of their team. (Though clearly there are a few guys who you can make valid arguments about)