Who has the better Forward-Line?

[Sainters08]

St.Kilda or Hawthorn?

Who is better now. not in 5 years time.

Please Post a reply to the thread after or before you have voted, so we can see its not just the teams supporters voting for their team. The vote will not count if you dont do this.

St.Kilda's Main Forward-Line:

Riewoldt
Koschitzke
Gehrig
Milne
Schneider

Hawthorn's Main Forward-Line:

Franklin
Roughead
Boyle
Rioli
Williams


who's is better?

my vote goes to St.Kilda's

 

[makethat2]

Hawthorn for me. Saints kicked 6 last week and so did Buddy

 

[Upgrayedd]

Hawthorn, St Kilda's would be better if they didnt have Milne

 

[Burzum]

Hawthorn.

 

[Divado]

St Kilda just. Next year when the G Train is retired Hawthorn.

 

[lamaros]

Saints easy.

 

[TigerGlory]

I think the Hawks is better, but i know that in five years time it will get even better.

Hawks forward line of Roughead, Boyle, Franklin, Williams and Rioli. As well as having a resting Hodge or Stuart Dew is very good.

 

[G5don]

At the moment St.Kilda's. In 09 Hawthorn's.

 

[lfctorres9]

saints

 

[NGHAWK]

I don't rate StKilda's at all!!
Gehrig is a musclehead has-been, Riewoldt the fairy is soooo over-rated it's not funny, not to mention he's falling to bits. Rioli has oozed a heap more class and genuine tallent in one game than Milne has....ever, and maybe i just don't respect milne because he cheats on his wife every second night.
Koschitzke is the dumbest peanut brain in the sport and wouldn't make the top 50 forwards in anyones book.
Schnider's alright but doesn't rate against any forward on Hawthorns list.

 

[Sainters08]

I don't rate StKilda's at all!!
Gehrig is a musclehead has-been, Riewoldt the fairy is soooo over-rated it's not funny, not to mention he's falling to bits. Rioli has oozed a heap more class and genuine tallent in one game than Milne has....ever, and maybe i just don't respect milne because he cheats on his wife every second night.
Koschitzke is the dumbest peanut brain in the sport and wouldn't make the top 50 forwards in anyones book.
Schnider's alright but doesn't rate against any forward on Hawthorns list.

ohh dear...

another one of the dawks stupid supporters.

Gehrig >>> Roughead
Riewoldt >>> Franklin
Milne >> Rioli (how can u say Rioli is better than Milne after one match? didnt u see him kick 11.0 against brisbane a couple of years ago?)
Schnieder = Williams
Koschitzke >>>>>>>>>>> Boyle

Roughead has the worst haircut ever. Pretty average footballer to, Franklin is the most over-rated player in the AFL, Rioli had a couple of handy touches in his debut. could be a star. Williams cant even get on the field, so how can u compare him to schneider? Boyle is the biggest Spud.


your just a bit sour coz you know our forward-line is better than yours

 

[burto]

ohh dear...

another one of the dawks stupid supporters.

Gehrig >>> Roughead
Riewoldt >>> Franklin
Milne >> Rioli (how can u say Rioli is better than Milne after one match? didnt u see him kick 11.0 against brisbane a couple of years ago?)
Schnieder = Williams
Koschitzke >>>>>>>>>>> Boyle

Roughead has the worst haircut ever. Pretty average footballer to, Franklin is the most over-rated player in the AFL, Rioli had a couple of handy touches in his debut. could be a star. Williams cant even get on the field, so how can u compare him to schneider? Boyle is the biggest Spud.


your just a bit sour coz you know our forward-line is better than yours

umm no

Hawthorn's is better.
We don't really get to see St Kilda's forward line in full flight because the ball is rarely down there.

 

[NGHAWK]

ohh dear...

another one of the dawks stupid supporters.

Gehrig >>> Roughead
Riewoldt >>> Franklin
Milne >> Rioli (how can u say Rioli is better than Milne after one match? didnt u see him kick 11.0 against brisbane a couple of years ago?)
Schnieder = Williams
Koschitzke >>>>>>>>>>> Boyle

Roughead has the worst haircut ever. Pretty average footballer to, Franklin is the most over-rated player in the AFL, Rioli had a couple of handy touches in his debut. could be a star. Williams cant even get on the field, so how can u compare him to schneider? Boyle is the biggest Spud.


your just a bit sour coz you know our forward-line is better than yours[/quote


Bwaahahahahahaha!!
Now who's a stupid supporter.
Adding a heap of arrows and bagging Roughy's haircut is the weakest comeback i've ever recieved!
Even if Franklin was over-rated, he's still a squillion times better than Riewoldt.
Oooo, Milne kicked 11 a couple of years ago! He's done jackshit since. Reject!
Mark Williams has played 23 less games than Schnider and has kicked 80 more goals. So the stats speak fo themselfes.
Boyle played his first proper season last year and has emerged as a classy genuine forward and has gained more respect than Kosi has. StKilda would take him in a split second.

 

[Sainters08]

ohh dear...

another one of the dawks stupid supporters.

Gehrig >>> Roughead
Riewoldt >>> Franklin
Milne >> Rioli (how can u say Rioli is better than Milne after one match? didnt u see him kick 11.0 against brisbane a couple of years ago?)
Schnieder = Williams
Koschitzke >>>>>>>>>>> Boyle

Roughead has the worst haircut ever. Pretty average footballer to, Franklin is the most over-rated player in the AFL, Rioli had a couple of handy touches in his debut. could be a star. Williams cant even get on the field, so how can u compare him to schneider? Boyle is the biggest Spud.


your just a bit sour coz you know our forward-line is better than yours[/quote


Bwaahahahahahaha!!
Now who's a stupid supporter.
Adding a heap of arrows and bagging Roughy's haircut is the weakest comeback i've ever recieved!
Even if Franklin was over-rated, he's still a squillion times better than Riewoldt.
Oooo, Milne kicked 11 a couple of years ago! He's done jackshit since. Reject!
Mark Williams has played 23 less games than Schnider and has kicked 80 more goals. So the stats speak fo themselfes.
Boyle played his first proper season last year and has emerged as a classy genuine forward and has gained more respect than Kosi has. StKilda would take him in a split second.

um...that would be u..

haha Franklin is s*** compared to Riewoldt. get over it.
Rioli's done Jacks***, so how can u say he's better than Milne?

all your points are based on potential, wait till they actually achieve something before saying there the best players in the league ffs!

Schneider plays half a game in the midfield u fool.

haha Boyle = Yukkkk Footballer. St.Kilda would never touch him.

are u actually saying Boyle is a better player than Koschitzke?

 

[NGHAWK]

um...that would be u..

haha Franklin is s*** compared to Riewoldt. get over it.
Rioli's done Jacks***, so how can u say he's better than Milne?

all your points are based on potential, wait till they actually achieve something before saying there the best players in the league ffs!

Schneider plays half a game in the midfield u fool.

haha Boyle = Yukkkk Footballer. St.Kilda would never touch him.

are u actually saying Boyle is a better player than Koschitzke?

FYI StFrankston made a play for Boyle last year so suckshit.
If you really want to compare Williams with Schnider then make a poll and you'll be put in your place! You would have never classified him better than Williams before he came to StFrankston.
I won't persue the Rioli debate because it's obviously it's premature but we'll readdress that in a couple if years.

And as for FranklinvRiewoldt, maybe we should address that one in a couple of years aswell just to make the answer a litte more obvious.
But 90% of people would take Buddy over Nick in a heart beat, and even your biast brain can acknowledge that Franklin can potentialy become the greatest thing this sport has ever seen.
I'll remember your name and i'll come to rub your face in it when we play next.
And then again when we get further in the finals.
And again when Franklin wins the Coleman.

 

[lookkg386]

Saints ATM

 

[DapperDon]

Saints easily

Hawks basing there's on the magical "P" word.

Franklin a gun, so is Riewoldt.
Kosi shits on Roughhead
Gump shits on Boyle
Williams easily over Schneider

Milne easily over Rioli, as Rioli has played all of ONE game.

NGHAWK, you need to get laid buddy. So much anger in your pubesent life.

 

[crawf_legend]

Hawthorn.

 

[TigerGlory]

Saints easily

Hawks basing there's on the magical "P" word.

Franklin a gun, so is Riewoldt.
Kosi shits on Roughhead
Gump shits on Boyle
Williams easily over Schneider

Milne easily over Rioli, as Rioli has played all of ONE game.

NGHAWK, you need to get laid buddy. So much anger in your pubesent life.

Hes right, thats why hes yelling at you silly people.

Franklin is a much better player than Riewoldt is or even was. Theres not much explanation needed here.

I dont rate Kosi at all, im sure he had some tremendous talent, but right now hes average at best. Hes had some shocking injuries, but thats life, and you cant keep living on the one or two games Kosi has played. Roughead AND Boyle both have much more upside than Kosi.

Gehrig is a good player, but to old, and dosent look very fit to me. Pulled out of last weeks game, and who knows how many he'll pull out of? Once Gehrig retires, Saints have a very average forward line with only two talls. Hawks have the best of Boyle, Franklin and Roughead to come and still have them all for another 10 years minimum.

Pretty sure NG was not comparing Rioli to Schneider, but actually Williams to Schneider. Williams IS a better player, proven that he can be the main spearhead in both a poor Hawks outfit(2004) and an up and coming side(2005-06) now with a quality forward line, it will be interesting to see how dangerous Williams becomes.

 

[Carn Hawkas]

Hawthorn

 

[horj89]

I like the Saints.

 

[Marc Shmurf 3]

Saints now but Hawks when Roughead gets more consistent they will have the most potent forward line in the comp ala Brown & Lynch.

 

[matty_boy08]

Hawks. cant go past franklin/williams/roughhead & dew.
plus youngsters like rioli.

 

[Paddy_Mac]

I'd prefer the saints forward line-up for now.
Franklin > Riewoldt 10 - 9
Roughead < Koschitzke 6 - 8
Boyle < Gehrig 4 - 7
Rioli < Milne 4 - 5
Williams > Schneider 7 - 5
Dew > C.Gardiner (Surely he's not in your forward line) 5 - 2
Same numbers. But considering that i don't think C.Gardiner is in your top 6 forwards. I think saints just edge them out.

 

[Sainters08]

I'd prefer the saints forward line-up for now.
Franklin > Riewoldt 10 - 9
Roughead < Koschitzke 6 - 8
Boyle < Gehrig 4 - 7
Rioli < Milne 4 - 5
Williams > Schneider 7 - 5
Dew > C.Gardiner (Surely he's not in your forward line) 5 - 2
Same numbers. But considering that i don't think C.Gardiner is in your top 6 forwards. I think saints just edge them out.

i dont think he is either. it would be either X.Clarke or a resting Mid