Who will finish higher, Tambling, Lids

[Bleeding Tiger]

People might think I am crazy and my comments are coming on the back of one game. Tambling has been more consistant than Lids for the majority of the year. He has more upside than that of Lids and will continue to flourish for the remaining of the yr! He is starting to become the player we drafted.

 

[middy]

First vote, nice. For mine, Lids is and always will be the better player. Already a solid contributor with the No.1 tag. Bling has yet to deal with any sort of tag yet and it will be interesting to see how he goes if teams decide to man him up now with his recent form.

 

[Barnzy]

Tambling doesn't have more upside than Lids. Single most ridiculous thing I have ever heard.

 

[RichosGuns]

Tambling doesn't have more upside than Lids. Single most ridiculous thing I have ever heard.

You're right... Bar Richo, Deledio is the most talented player on our lists by the length of the Flemington. Much more talented then Tambling, Cotchin, Cousisn extra. But does he have the gears to reach his talents? Does he want it enough? The way he has been playing recently suggests maybe not

 

[Spluff]

Single most ridiculous thing I have ever heard.

You must live a sheltered life.

 

[Barnzy]

You're right... Bar Richo, Deledio is the most talented player on our lists by the length of the Flemington. Much more talented then Tambling, Cotchin, Cousisn extra. But does he have the gears to reach his talents? Does he want it enough? The way he has been playing recently suggests maybe not

Who knows, sad to say but he doesn't seem as happy as other players out there. From the limited amount of wins this season you see every single player after the game bar Deledio with huge smiles on their faces, belting out the song, etc. He sure does need to work harder because he's got super potential but will always get tagged. If the rumours are true and he does want to go I would be very disappointed but he does have huge market value so we would be duly compensated. Maybe he has just got to the stage at 22 where he thinks, I've been here 5 years and we have played no finals, we are about to go through a massive cleanout again and a new coach.... when will the success come? Probably just weighing up his options.

 

[Rosstickle]

Who knows, sad to say but he doesn't seem as happy as other players out there. From the limited amount of wins this season you see every single player after the game bar Deledio with huge smiles on their faces, belting out the song, etc. He sure does need to work harder because he's got super potential but will always get tagged. If the rumours are true and he does want to go I would be very disappointed but he does have huge market value so we would be duly compensated. Maybe he has just got to the stage at 22 where he thinks, I've been here 5 years and we have played no finals, we are about to go through a massive cleanout again and a new coach.... when will the success come? Probably just weighing up his options.

Watch him in our first win against the Roos and tell me he didn't belt out the song. He was nearly as pumped as Cogs.

 

[Barnzy]

Watch him in our first win against the Roos and tell me he didn't belt out the song. He was nearly as pumped as Cogs.

Yeah, that's the one instance in the year where I thought he was really happy being here. I'm sure he's just unhappy about being tagged at such a young age and the lack of success so far. I will take all these rumours with a grain of salt for now. Forgetting all that though, I'm more worried about losing Cotchin to the GC.

 

[getthefooty]

Cotchin absolutely belted out the song as well now that you mention him Barnzy. Let out a big 'WHOOOOOOOOOO' at the end if I recall.

If we let go of Cotchin I will seriously consider a trip to the Westgate.

 

[folester41]

deledio has more upside then anyone in the afl.

 

[smasha]

I hope we keep Cousins too.

 

[RichosGuns]

deledio has more upside then anyone in the afl.

Nicholas Natuini says hello.

I reckon from what we saw of him on Saturday night he really could be anything

 

[richoatthedisco]

I don't know where anyone gets the idea Lids or Cotch are going anywhere. If I had to, I'd bet both play their careers out at Richmond. It's very rare players of that ilk leave a club, and if they do, more often than not it's to go home. I can't see either of them at the Gold Coast. Lids might have a soft spot for Carlton but it'll be nigh on impossible for him to get there. Cotchin will be Richmond captain in a few short years.

 

[Mario Speedwagon]

Nicholas Natuini says hello.

I reckon from what we saw of him on Saturday night he really could be anything

...or nothing...time will tell...so far he's played one game against a 15th placed side with a fellow debutante as his direct opponent for most of the time...

 

[Bazzar]

This time last year Tuck started his remarkable run home and was clearly in the best 2 or 3 mid fielders in the comp. One extra good game he would have won the B&F. Tambo is also in a similar position. Jacko will have him well and truly covered because he has dominated so far (see the list of scalps tonight on one HD- Wow… AA calling) So im tipping if Tambo keeps it up, and I see no reason he cant, then it will be a well deserver 2nd place in the B&F

 

[tigertiger]

I suspect lids is carrying some sort of injury

 

[coke_zero]

at the moment it is hard to call who is winning out of the 2, but i'll say deldio because he had a few really good games.

and just because he is not playing his best it doesn't mean he is injured everyone goes through a few form slumps.

 

[DerpWerls]

Richo > Deledio > Anybody else at this stage

Deledio is a deadset gun and should be played in the same position (on the wing) every week to develop his talents further.

 

[Themi#9]

Deledio just needs to shake a tag and he will be judd junior

And Tambles off HB with a little confidence! gun!!

 

[mattdwyer]

who else gets the feeling that tambling is going to be something very special very soon ?? .... i dunno why but i just have this massive feeling richie is going to become a very very very GOOD player .. maybe even great ..

 

[Themi#9]

who else gets the feeling that tambling is going to be something very special very soon ?? .... i dunno why but i just have this massive feeling richie is going to become a very very very GOOD player .. maybe even great ..

i agree with all the Franklin crap we have copped!! it looks like hes going to cement his place and become a special player

 

[folester41]

Nicholas Natuini says hello.

I reckon from what we saw of him on Saturday night he really could be anything

brett deledio says learn how to kick

 

[RichosGuns]

who else gets the feeling that tambling is going to be something very special very soon ?? .... i dunno why but i just have this massive feeling richie is going to become a very very very GOOD player .. maybe even great ..

Certainly is alot of posie about him over the last couple of weeks. Very, dare I say it, Mcleod-esk