Why not go 4 james walker

[silverphoenix]

Why not offer freo pick 23 for him, hes quick has good skills and is the grandson of gordon coventry!

 

[sabre_ac]

Why not offer freo pick 23 for him, hes quick has good skills and is the grandson of gordon coventry!

Yes I am sure freo would jump at that....
Hand over a player we gave up a top 5 pick for pick 23 in a weak draft.
Did I mention he performs for us week in week out?

 

[bucksisbest]

Because he's a required , contracted player at Freo and they're not interested in trading him.

 

[silverphoenix]

So we seem to value him more here than freo fans do, when i posted on their board they said theyd do it if he wanted to leave but would need a 15-20 otherwise. But what if we put in leon davis?

 

[Lensen]

Would be willing to trade Woewodin or Presti for him, but probably not any other players (other than the ones that Freo won't want at all, O'Bree, McGough etc). Wouldn't do it for Davis or Walker, given that Davis showed a lot IMO in the last few rounds and we need his speed, and Walker will be needed as a backup tall.

 

[carringbush]

I dont care if he is Bob Collingwoods illegitimate love child all he does is run. We need creative playmakers

 

[ImperialPurple]

So we seem to value him more here than freo fans do, when i posted on their board they said theyd do it if he wanted to leave but would need a 15-20 otherwise. But what if we put in leon davis?

This is my response I put on the Freo board:

"James Walker is without doubt THE MOST under-rated guy in our team and one of the most in the league. He has played 120 games, the last 80 odd in succession and does the job week in and week out.
It would have to be a first rounder at least. And we have Jeffrey and Medders... we do not need Leon!'

I also mean he is under-rated by his own club supporters as well as others. Poor Jimmy. One of my very, very favourites at our club and I would not like to see him go. He's been with us since 1997 and genuinely loves our club. Obviously he would have pretty strong ties to the Pies also, given the family history and that he grew up a Collingwood supporter.

If Grandson leaving became part of a deal that lands us a quality player like Josh Carr... well then I could live with it. Just.

 

[Stan.]

Hes a bit soft i reckon.

 

[Lockyer24]

Wouldn't make a fat rats clacker to how good we are.