List Mgmt. 2015 Trade & Free Agency Hellscape Discussion Thread (PG546: Anderson PG732: Bastinac)

[Roo Beauty]

Not on recent form.

Nor in the showers.

 

[ozzyoslo]

He is better than Nahas.

Correct.

Not on recent form.

Also correct.

 

[ozzyoslo]

Nor in the showers.

Bada bom tsh !!

 

[ozzyoslo]

Really? Swallows a shitman. Cant run or kick can tackle in close if that's important. also not a great decision maker but does look good in underwear apparently. Would be happy if we moved him on and to me that would be the start of us climbing back to being relevant.

Im very open to this idea only due to the fact that he is the weakest ( skill wise ) of our midfield.......BUT he is Our Captain and the effects it will have on the rest of the team are what scare me. No club could navigate around that sought of minefield.

 

[naturally north]

Im very open to this idea only due to the fact that he is the weakest ( skill wise ) of our midfield.......BUT he is Our Captain and the effects it will have on the rest of the team are what scare me. No club could navigate around that sought of minefield.

Yeah fair point, I doubt our club would move him on anyway. Just with our current list and where we're at, it would be IMO beneficial. Will be an interesting off season no doubt.

 

[lockheed]

Wouldn't mind him, he could be a handy sub or (depending on what possy he plays) a silky outside mid to replace Wells. Is he out of contract?

I think that this is the last year of Hampton's current contract.

 

[scooby1279]

Sam maclure mentioned on 3aw treloer he is as close to going to Collingwood as you can get.

 

[naturally north]

Sam maclure mentioned on 3aw treloer he is as close to going to Collingwood as you can get.

Awesome, probably paying 'overs' like Greenwood, so we've dodged another bullet .

 

[roos_fanatic08]

Sam maclure mentioned on 3aw treloer he is as close to going to Collingwood as you can get.

Sam McClure is always wrong.

 

[scooby1279]

Awesome, probably paying 'overs' like Greenwood, so we've dodged another bullet .

Nah the money will be very similar to North and Richmond.

 

[osaka mick]

If we had a choice of Trealor or Aish, who would you take. I would guestimate that Trelor would cost 6yrs (as reported) at 5-600, whereas, Aish would be far less.

In the long term I think Aish would be equally as valuable, and a better prostpect for the money.
Thoughts....

 

[Shermanator]

If we had a choice of Trealor or Aish, who would you take. I would guestimate that Trelor would cost 6yrs (as reported) at 5-600, whereas, Aish would be far less.

In the long term I think Aish would be equally as valuable, and a better prostpect for the money.
Thoughts....

Mate I reckon he would thrive at our place but I'm an ordinary judge.

 

[Higgins2Waite]

Both.jpeg

 

[ArjenTheGreat]

If we had a choice of Trealor or Aish, who would you take. I would guestimate that Trelor would cost 6yrs (as reported) at 5-600, whereas, Aish would be far less.

In the long term I think Aish would be equally as valuable, and a better prostpect for the money.
Thoughts....

Agree Mick.

 

[SpearPass]

People complain about Greenhead betraying us and then carry on about trading our club captain, lol.

Many here also seem to underestimate Andrew's work in the middle. He is an absolute bulldog there.

 

[The Nostradamus]

If we had a choice of Trealor or Aish, who would you take. I would guestimate that Trelor would cost 6yrs (as reported) at 5-600, whereas, Aish would be far less.

In the long term I think Aish would be equally as valuable, and a better prostpect for the money.
Thoughts....

Whichever wants to come to us.
I'd be happy with both Treloar or Aish so hopefully one of them nominates us

 

[Egga]

If we had a choice of Trealor or Aish, who would you take. I would guestimate that Trelor would cost 6yrs (as reported) at 5-600, whereas, Aish would be far less.

In the long term I think Aish would be equally as valuable, and a better prostpect for the money.
Thoughts....

Aish will be very good. Treloar will be great.

 

[deano28]

Jay Clark on MMM just said that if we miss out on Treloar then we will go all out to get Motlop and he believes the Cats won't fight that hard to keep him .

 

[TooUglyForFugly]

People complain about Greenhead betraying us and then carry on about trading our club captain, lol.

Many here also seem to underestimate Andrew's work in the middle. He is an absolute bulldog there.

Sometimes I wonder about those people ...

 

[naturally north]

Jay Clark on MMM just said that if we miss out on Treloar then we will go all out to get Motlop and he believes the Cats won't fight that hard to keep him .

Think he could be a good addition ,but would also like an Aish as well. Thought Motlop was older than 24, right age group.

Sometimes I wonder about those people ...

I like people that have opinions and enjoy those with the ability to counter those with well thought out succinct replies. But as the Rolling Stones sang-you can't always get what you want....

 

[GremlinCRHF]

I wonder if it's worth going after Sydney players? Right now would be s good time to put doubt in their minds, it would have to be a big trade but if we can get the player asking for it, it certainly helps. A Hannerberry, or Parker?

 

[Roo Beauty]

I wonder if it's worth going after Sydney players? Right now would be s good time to put doubt in their minds, it would have to be a big trade but if we can get the player asking for it, it certainly helps. A Hannerberry, or Parker?

We offered something like 6 years and $700k but he just re-signed.

 

[nelroo]

Jay Clark on MMM just said that if we miss out on Treloar then we will go all out to get Motlop and he believes the Cats won't fight that hard to keep him .

I dont know if Motlop would be worth what we would have to give up. He is flakey as hell! We already have too many like this.
Motlop is not what we need. Good on his day but he is not an A grader and never will be.

 

[year of the roo]

I wonder if it's worth going after Sydney players? Right now would be s good time to put doubt in their minds, it would have to be a big trade but if we can get the player asking for it, it certainly helps. A Hannerberry, or Parker?

Nick Smith for mine.

 

[kangaspurs]

Motlop would compliment Cunners, Ziebell, Basti, Dumont etc very nicely in coming years.