Create a 'Best 18' using one player from each club.

[Grockadoc]

B: J. Patful, E. McKenzie, C. Hooker
HB: P. Hanley, H. Taylor, B. Gibbs
C: J. Macrae, P. Dangerfield, D. Prestia
HF: N. Fyfe, N. Riewoldt, B. Deledio
F: L. Breust, K. Tippett, J. Howe
R: T. Goldstein, Pendlebury, R. Gray

Adelaide: P. Dangerfield
Brisbane: P. Hanley
Carlton: B. Gibbs
Collingwood: S. Pendlebury
Essendon: C. Hooker
Fremantle: N. Fyfe
Geelong: H. Taylor
Gold Coast: D. Prestia
GWS: J. Patful
Hawthorn: L. Breust
Melbourne: J. Howe
North Melbourne: T. Goldstein
Port Adelaide: R. Gray
Richmond: B. Deledio
St. Kilda: N. Riewoldt
Sydney: K. Tippett
West Coast: E. McKenzie
Western Bulldogs: J. Macrae

Gone for some players from sides who aren't the best from the side, but fill a need.

 

[Collins-Langford-Ayres]

FF: Zorko (Bri) - Walker (Ade) - Gray (PA)
HF: Fyfe (Fre) - Riewoldt (StK) - Cameron (GWS)
Ce: Hanners (Syd) - Jones (Mel) - Simpson (Car)
HB: Heppell (Ess) - Taylor (Gee) - Murphy (WB)
FB: Hurn (WCE) - Rance (Ric) - Gibson (Haw)

Ru: Goldy (NM)
RR: Pendles (Pies)
Ro: GAblett (GCS)

 

[Docker82]

F. Bruest (Haw) Franklin (Syd) Dahlhaus (WB)
HF. Fyfe (Frem) Riewoldt (StK) Gray (Port)
C. Harvey (NM) Ablett (GC) Dangerfield (Ade)
HB. Hanley (Bris) Taylor (Gee) Hurn (WC)
B. Simpson (Carl) Hooker (Ess) Rance (Rich)
R. Mumford (GWS) Pendlebury (Coll) Jones (Melb)

 

[theasian]

B S Morris (Rich) E Mckenzie (WC) J Platful (GWS)
HB A Walker (Carl) C Hooker (Ess) P Hanley (Bris)
C P Dangerfield(Adel) J Selwood (Geel) J Steven (Saints)
HF C Wingard (Port )L Franklin (Syd) N Fyfe (Freo)
F J Howe (Melb) J Roughead (Haw) L Dalhaus (WB)
R T Goldstein (NM) S Pendlebury (Coll) G Ablett (GC)

 

[AFDogs]

B - S Thompson (NM), E McKenzie (WC), C Hooker (Ess)
HB - D Talia (Adel), Harry Taylor (Geel), C Yarran (Carl)
C - C Ward (GWS), D Beams (Bris), S Pendlebury (Coll)
HF - M Bontempelli (WB), L Franklin (Syd), J Gunston (Haw)
F - J Riewoldt (Rich), Nick Riewoldt (STK), H Ballantyne (Freo)
R - P Ryder (Port), Gary Ablett (GC), N Jones (Melb)

Thought about chemistry/combinations. Having both Riewoldts up forward would be insane. Also went through each team and essentially picked the best player apart from some back/forward choices. I feel like I've come up with a strong team here with a mixture of everything.

 

[MightyDons4]

B - S Thompson (NM), E McKenzie (WC), C Hooker (Ess)
HB - D Talia (Adel), Harry Taylor (Geel), C Yarran (Carl)
C - C Ward (GWS), D Beams (Bris), S Pendlebury (Coll)
HF - M Bontempelli (WB), L Franklin (Syd), J Gunston (Haw)
F - J Riewoldt (Rich), Nick Riewoldt (STK), H Ballantyne (Freo)
R - P Ryder (Port), Gary Ablett (GC), N Jones (Melb)

Thought about chemistry/combinations. Having both Riewoldts up forward would be insane. Also went through each team and essentially picked the best player apart from some back/forward choices. I feel like I've come up with a strong team here with a mixture of everything.

Holy mother of height!

 

[PieLebo87]

Love doing these!

Davis, Thompson, Taylor
Gibbs, Rance, Jones
Dangerfield, Watson, Beams
Franklin, Roughead, Fyfe
Wingard, St Nick, NicNat
Minson, Ablett, Pendlebury

NicNat as the second ruckman, up forward.

 

[Milanista28]

cant do a whole team, but i'd have Goddard from Essendon, Lockett from Sydney, Gehrig from West Coast, Hamill from Carlton, Dawson from Freo, Ball from Collingwood, Wakelin from Port, Dal Santo from North, Stewart from Richmond, Winmar from the Doggies...

Not Gwilt?

 

[King_Steele]

Not Gwilt?

DFA. Meaning his a spud.

 

[GarnerSmash]

B: Thompson (NM) – Hooker (Ess) – Howe (Mel)
HB: Hanley (Bris) – Jamison (Car) – Murphy (WB)
C: Griffin (GWS) – Selwood (Gee) – Dangerfield (Ade)
HF: Martin (Rich) – Reiwoldt (St.K) – Fyfe (Freo)
F: Gray (PtA) – Roughead (Haw) - Franklin (Syd)
R: Naitanui (WCE) – Ablett (GC) – Pendlebury (Coll)

 

[DV2000]

B: Gibson (Haw), Lonergan (Geel), Simpson (Carl)
HB: Hurn (WC), Rance (Rich), Hanley (Bris)
C: Tyson (Melb), Dangerfield (Adel), Heppell (Ess)
HF: Wingard (Port), Franklin (Syd), Crameri (WB)
FF: D. Smith (GWS), N. Riewoldt (STK) , Ballantyne (Fre)
R: Goldstein (NM), Pendlebury (Coll) , Ablett (GC)

Crameri?! Lonergan?! Surely there are better players to choose from, and they both aren't young

 

[Power Raid]

B: Simpson (Carl) , Rance (Rich), N. Riewoldt (STK),
HB: Tyson (Melb), Taylor (GEE), Hurn (WC),
C: Dangerfield (Adel), Fyfe (Fre), Heppell (Ess)
HF: Hartlett (Port), Franklin (Syd), Crameri (WB)
FF: Jeremy Cameron (GWS) Roughead (HAW), Beams (Bris)
R: Goldstein (NM), Pendlebury (Coll) , Ablett (GC)

 

[12Chill]

B: Simpson (Carl) , Rance (Rich), N. Riewoldt (STK),
HB: Tyson (Melb), Taylor (GEE), Hurn (WC),
C: Dangerfield (Adel), Fyfe (Fre), Heppell (Ess)
HF: Hartlett (Port), Franklin (Syd), Crameri (WB)
FF: Jeremy Cameron (GWS) Roughead (HAW), Beams (Bris)
R: Goldstein (NM), Pendlebury (Coll) , Ablett (GC)

Nick Riewoldt in the back pocket?

wot?

 

[Power Raid]

Nick Riewoldt in the back pocket?

wot?

definitely out of position but good enough to play anywhere

 

[Engimal]

Interesting to see that North's player is nearly always Goldstein or Thompson. What other selection trends are there in this thread?

 

[TN25]

Interesting to see that North's player is nearly always Goldstein or Thompson. What other selection trends are there in this thread?

Mackenzie, Riewoldt and Rance are in pretty much all the teams

 

[MightyDons4]

Interesting to see that North's player is nearly always Goldstein or Thompson. What other selection trends are there in this thread?

Don't understand this, surely I'm not the only one that went with Boomer!

 

[mike123]

Interesting to see that North's player is nearly always Goldstein or Thompson. What other selection trends are there in this thread?

I went with Wells

 

[Power Raid]

Don't understand this, surely I'm not the only one that went with Boomer!

great player but age is the only question

 

[Power Raid]

I went with Wells

oops forgot about him

 

[MightyDons4]

I went with Wells

Seriously considered him, only went for Boomer because I like yelling "Boooooooooomer"

 

[mike123]

Seriously considered him, only went for Boomer because I like yelling "Boooooooooomer"

I went with Wells because it was a wing spot. If it was a half forward flank spot I would have given it to him.

 

[MightyDons4]

great player but age is the only question

He had his best year for a while this year...

 

[MightyDons4]

I went with Wells because it was a wing spot. If it was a half forward flank spot I would have given it to him.

Fair enough

 

[Engimal]

Don't understand this, surely I'm not the only one that went with Boomer!

Boomer's great, but people's selection is based on the team around them too. For example, most people pick Reiwoldt from St Kilda because he's a clear standout in that team. In North's case, Goldstein is a top 3 in his position and, although a lackluster year this year, Thompson is as well.