Injury Injuries 2014 : The state of No Play

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Simmofreo said:
Really ?? Webber only released his injury report a couple if hours before Ross went to air. The worst part about that is that I thought Macca was a better chance to get up than Dawson :( may not have either against ports skilled forward line :(
Click to expand...

It might mean that we end up playing a highly defensive game against Port, locking it down at every opportunity. Personally I think that is one of our best chances of winning.

It's definitely not ideal but I'm not going to be the one to say we can't still get over the line.
 
We
Wigarus said:
It might mean that we end up playing a highly defensive game against Port, locking it down at every opportunity. Personally I think that is one of our best chances of winning.

It's definitely not ideal but I'm not going to be the one to say we can't still get over the line.
Click to expand...
we certainly can, especially with our midfield and if the forward line fires a bit better like it did on Sunday. Pav didn't even kick one did he. If Clarke plays well again and Pav gets into the game coupled with our top notch midfield, we are every chance. But against Port every defender we lose will hurt. PrY that Zac gets up
 
has anyone got a link/video?

It seems really weird the club would list him as a test yet ross suggest hes out? .....Games? Just weird...?
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Ragtooth said:
has anyone got a link/video?

It seems really weird the club would list him as a test yet ross suggest hes out? .....Games? Just weird...?
Click to expand...


Freo will put up Ross's cross with Basil tomorrow. The Health update injury video with Jason Weber said they would try and get them up for a test. So not exactly too far out of sync with each other.
 
This concerns me greatly. Quads are never a good thing in terms of recovery, and with Ports and Cats forwards really need McPharlin playing. Zac was on crutches so also expect him to miss.
 
more_of_bito said:
This concerns me greatly. Quads are never a good thing in terms of recovery, and with Ports and Cats forwards really need McPharlin playing. Zac was on crutches so also expect him to miss.
Click to expand...
Pretty sure the footage was from yesterday (he wasn't in Freo gear) and the club doctors would have told him to be on crutches straight away until they get the scan back just for precaution.

I'm not saying he won't miss but the fact he was on crutches isn't evidence that he will.
 
McPharlin quoted in the media as saying he has a "knick"in the quad. Whatever that means.
 
Straawberry said:
Will 100% miss. Damn, that's our 2 key defenders out. We could see Keplar back in the side this week and playing in defence. Silvagni has to be guaranteed a spot. I think the only other available tall option in defence could be A.Pearce. Not good. Our injuries are going to wreck us this year.

C'mon lad let see how we perform this weekend.
I'm confident of a victory this weekend,our midfield will get the job done.
Click to expand...
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

This game is up to Freo's midfield now. Really need a four quarter effort from them. The rest will follow.
 
Freeeoo said:
Will almost certainly miss, too valuable to risk.
Click to expand...

Being a quad etc., then that would be the ideal thing (rest for week), but I don't think it will happen.

Especially if Dawson doesn't make it, they're going to be desperate to play Elvis even if he's half baked. Depending on the nature of the thing, he might be able to run around reasonably well, but then not be able to kick properly for example. Being such a player, they might be tempted to put him out there in that state anyway to help keep the back half in order.

So yeah, probably ideally would miss, but my fear is that the players themselves/staff will fudge one or both through the KPI's like they did with Mayne and play them half-baked. Such a big game, history shows that clubs tend to buckle to the temptation to play them - it's then just a matter of just how bad they are during the game.

We'll see, could pan out completely differently too.

EDIT: Just catching up with the news, seems like the noise is that McPharlin will almost certainly miss. Well that's probably the best thing in the long term anyway. Now we just have to see how Dawson goes I guess.
 
Last edited:
Simmofreo said:
We

we certainly can, especially with our midfield and if the forward line fires a bit better like it did on Sunday. Pav didn't even kick one did he. If Clarke plays well again and Pav gets into the game coupled with our top notch midfield, we are every chance. But against Port every defender we lose will hurt. PrY that Zac gets up
Click to expand...

Pav doesn't mind showing off in front of the Adelaide crowds.

Lock him in for a handful.
 
Danny Cullen said:
Pav doesn't mind showing off in front of the Adelaide crowds.

Lock him in for a handful.
Click to expand...
It is Pav's old home ground, so you could be right.
 
PapaJ said:
Being a quad etc., then that would be the ideal thing (rest for week), but I don't think it will happen.

Especially if Dawson doesn't make it, they're going to be desperate to play Elvis even if he's half baked. Depending on the nature of the thing, he might be able to run around reasonably well, but then not be able to kick properly for example. Being such a player, they might be tempted to put him out there in that state anyway to help keep the back half in order.
Click to expand...

My experience with quad injuries is that you can move around ok but you can't sprint. Obviously there's different degrees of injury but most of the ones I've had/seen haven't prevented anyone from suiting up in C grade ammos. AFL might be slightly more intense :D
 
Updated injury list:
INJURY LIST
PlayerInjuryDuration
Zac DawsonAnkletest
Sam MenegolaKneetest
Michael ApenessAdductortest
Stephen HillHamstringtest
Luke McPharlinQuad1 week
Alex PearceShin1 week
Tanner SmithHamstring4 weeks
Max DuffyShoulder4-5 weeks
Scott GumbletonHamstring4-6 weeks
Michael WaltersAnkle13-15 weeks

Notes: McPharlin from test to 1 week :( The rest is the same
 
Squad Summary

Fremantle XXII (22): Ballantyne, Barlow, Clarke, Crowley, Crozier, de Boer, Duffield, Fyfe, Hill, Johnson, Mayne, Mundy, Mzungu, Neale, Pavlich, C. Pearce, D. Pearce, Sandilands, Silvagni, Spurr, Suban, Sutcliffe

Emergencies (3): Hannath, Ibbotson, Sheridan

Peel XXII (12): Apeness, Ballard, Bradley, Grey, Griffin, Menegola, Moller, Morabito, A. Pearce, Simpson, Sylvia, Taberner

Peel Reserves (2): Vandeleur, Wood

Injured (6): Dawson (1 week), McPharlin (1 week), Smith (4 weeks), Duffy (4-5 weeks), Gumbleton (4-6 weeks), Walters (13-15 weeks)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

Lach72
Injury 2024 Injury Thread
38 39 40 41 42
Replies
1K
Views
67K
Big Flappy
Big Flappy
freo1997
  • Poll
Analysis What position does JOM play in 2024?
2
Replies
39
Views
2K
FreoGirl
FreoGirl
vidwhal
Preview Battle of the No Win Clubs.....no wait....North beat the Toast?!?!.....
Replies
5
Views
527
Purple Jesus
Purple Jesus
J
  • Poll
Prediction Which 2023 new player will have the best career
2
Replies
39
Views
3K
FreoGirl
FreoGirl
Lore
  • Locked
List Mgmt. 2023 List Management thread - Pt2 Now With Added Wailing & Gnashing of Teeth
304 305 306 307 308
Replies
8K
Views
312K
Snuffaluphagus
Snuffaluphagus
Van_Dyke
Review Freo storm home against North
11 12 13 14 15
Replies
361
Views
14K
mattis117
mattis117
Van_Dyke
MVP Round 2 v North (A)
2
Replies
44
Views
1K
Fred Ziffel
Fred Ziffel

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top