Jack Ziebell vs Dustin Martin

[Dazb86]

If he hasn't done it by now what chance can he do it though?

Along with Cunnington. Bit of a worry with the interchange cap coming in.

 

[Dan]

Martin's more consistent.

 

[Ozil]

Martin is the player I'd want Ziebell to be if I was a North fan.

 

[Elite Master]

Martin is the player I'd want Ziebell to be if I was a North fan.

I agree with this, but just as a player, not as a leader.

 

[Ozil]

I agree with this, but just as a player, not as a leader.

Yeah, can't argue with that.

 

[HolyWars]

Love the way Martin plays. Martin for me.

 

[DontArgue4]

Martin is the superior player IMO, but in saying that i think Ziebell is very underrated, really like the way he plays.

 

[eth-dog]

The biggest question for me is why Ziebell has 1 vote, let alone 9?

 

[Likedagreen]

like both players but I take ziebell more consistent and is a real handful when he plays forward.

 

[juss]

like both players but I take ziebell more consistent and is a real handful when he plays forward.

I think you've got them the wrong way around. Martin's kicked 141 career goals to Ziebell's 72. From only 7 more games. Martin hits the scoreboard each week.

 

[Super Hans]

Martin by so much it isn't funny. Ziebell isn't much.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Martin a beast when standing over or holding the ball.

 

[Jade]

Ziebell is better in a lot of the ways that don't actually involve kicking a ball. He's a much better leader, clubman and representative.

But Martin is a better player IMO.

 

[Masqualero]

like both players but I take ziebell more consistent and is a real handful when he plays forward.

Ummmm... Wot m8?

 

[Lorne Malvo]

I agree with this, but just as a player, not as a leader.

Not fair! Martin will be Pres of the Castlemaine Rebels chapter one day.

 

[DesertRoo]

Reckon Martin should add some chopsticks to his tattoo collection... Very very visible for the new season.

 

[Roo Beauty]

Martin the superior player, JZ the superior leader.

If Jack could become more consistent then he'd be a star, but Martin is clearly the better player.

 

[lionshine]

Dustin Martin. Seriously good footballer. Martin will be much better when he is 26-29 as he matures as a person and enters his prime as a footballer.

 

[detox]

Martin. Easily.

You never worry about Ziebell when you play North. I worry about Martin every time.

Easily the most damaging player for Richmond.

 

[Sando22]

Dustin Martin in a heartbeat

 

[Masqualero]

Martin, it's not close and Ziebell isn't being underrated at all. End poll.

 

[Frank Thring]

With the improvement in Zeibell's performance in 2016, is the comparison closer or are people still thinking that Martin is still superior?

 

[Jade]

With the improvement in Zeibell's performance in 2016, is the comparison closer or are people still thinking that Martin is still superior?

Martin has been down this year, and Ziebell has gotten better. If it stayed that way, I'd go Ziebell; but we need more than a 5-6 game sample size to make that call - Martin has been very good for some time.

 

[Frank Thring]

Martin has been down this year, and Ziebell has gotten better. If it stayed that way, I'd go Ziebell; but we need more than a 5-6 game sample size to make that call - Martin has been very good for some time.

Yeah i guess it was more that if Zeibell kept up this level of performance would he be compared more favourably to Dusty? No doubt that Dusty has been impacted with his dad's situation this year as his performances have been down on previous years.

 

[juss]

Dusty should be given time off at the moment to be honest. He is apparantly flying to and fr NZ each week. Give the kid a month off to go and work through the difficulty hes facing and Im sure hel come back strong.