List Mgmt. Who needs a big year to escape the axe?

[TradeDraft]

Still needs those skills no matter where someone plays.

Yes, Players need a Defensive Side to his game. So do it at VFL Level not AFL Level

 

[Maggie5]

Yes, Players need a Defensive Side to his game. So do it at VFL Level not AFL Level

Do it any any level. First thing you learn in almost all sports.

 

[TradeDraft]

Do it any any level. First thing you learn in almost all sports.

But, Hurting our Chances of Winning is a Good Idea?

 

[Maggie5]

But, Hurting our Chances of Winning is a Good Idea?

One player does not make a team, especially if that player keeps making the same mistake.
Just my opinion and as I said, have no problem if he proves me wrong, just saying he needs a big year, that's all.

 

[THATSGOLD]

22 is still young. And he needs to be fit before he can play seniors.

He actually did well in the seniors at Brisbane, but crazy Vossy had issues with him.

PK shouldn't even be in this convo.

Gone now.

 

[Magpie Girl]

Gone now.

A strange 'bump' TG but actually most of them have now gone

 

[THATSGOLD]

A strange 'bump' TG but actually most of them have now gone

Well only 3 in the poll have gone. Dwyer Armstrong Young..

 

[THATSGOLD]

The thing with Seedsman is he has the edge over Sinclair and Ramsay as he can kick the ball and has the edge over Oxley because he actually played games and has some good performances on the board.

Nope.

 

[Magpie Girl]

Well only 3 in the poll have gone. Dwyer Armstrong Young..

And Thomas

 

[Kappa]

And Thomas

Thomas has been confirmed to be on our list in 2016?

 

[Gone Critical]

However Fas and Patty K entered the system with a rating much closer to each other's. Would also contest that Fas played in a team that made it easy for him. One thing that is difficult for a first year player to do is the break into a reigning premier team that is dominating the next year. Fas did that and immediately solidified to become a near automatic selection immediately. He has remained an automatic selection when fit ever since. Only very talented players can pull something like that off.

I think Fasolo can be best 22 on the form he showed in 2012, but I doubt he will pass that form.. I think Karnezis will play at a higher level than that in 2015 and would have this year if he wasn't cut down by injury

Would love to be proven wrong so future person please don't be afraid to bump this up if Fasolo ever has a season where he plays 20+ games and averages more than 16possesions and 1 goal a game

2012 was 24 games, 15.5 disposals and 1.2 goals so he has been there already more or less. Last season he wasn't injured. So if he is injury free in 2015 I reckon we might be bumping then

Close to a bump. 17 games, 13.9 possessions, 1.6 goals

 

[nahnah]

Close to a bump. 17 games, 13.9 possessions, 1.6 goals

Wait till he actually does it lol (if he does it)
He got 1 of three categories

 

[nahnah]

And yes I was wrong on Karnezis but I still think that's because he didn't want it bad enough rather than talent

 

[Baltimore Jack]

And yes I was wrong on Karnezis but I still think that's because he didn't want it bad enough rather than talent

Isn't desire also a component of talent?

 

[nahnah]

Isn't desire also a component of talent?

I overrated his desire talent

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Isn't desire also a component of talent?

Harder to measure from afar though

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Harder to measure from afar though

true

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Well only 3 in the poll have gone. Dwyer Armstrong Young..

One dIdnt have to be a genius to predict those three.

 

[Gone Critical]

Wait till he actually does it lol (if he does it)
He got 1 of three categories

So close but no cigar

 

[Apex36]

Gone now.

I must have missed the part where he was delisted instead of retiring of his own volition.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I must have missed the part where he was delisted instead of retiring of his own volition.

TG also called for Reid to be delisted.

 

[Apex36]

TG also called for Reid to be delisted.

Lol. It's always good when idiots bump posts to try and look clever, only to end up looking foolish.

 

[Gone Critical]

Ben Reid. Finshed.

Can't have him interrupting the team. Getting injured every time he's ready to come back. We should've traded him while he had value. Not worth $0 Over the past two years.

Yeah you probably went a bit hard there TG. Would you keep him on the list now or do you stand by your call?

 

[THATSGOLD]

Yeah you probably went a bit hard there TG. Would you keep him on the list now or do you stand by your call?

Up in the air with Reid at the moment. He's hardly back.

 

[Gone Critical]

Up in the air with Reid at the moment. He's hardly back.

So do you still believe we should have traded him? Is he finished?