Judd on Riewoldt?

[thylacine60]

Are you saying I shouldn't be doing this ? Only warm meal i get some weeks..

Come home now, Audas. Your time is up. No seriously.................

 

[PeeKay]

]well judd can do anything[/quote]
I think the comment was correct.
Judd will be on Riewoldt
Judd will be on Gehrig
Judd will be on Gram
Judd will be on Montagna
Judd will be on Sal Santo
Judd will be on King
Judd will be on Harvey
Judd will be on Ball
Judd will be on Koschitzke
I think during the half time break he also selling pies in the outer and serving mass at St patricks Cathedral in the City.
Don't worry he will be back in time to do address the players and make all the significent move for the second half.

 

[PeeKay]

Well, not entirely. But it might be worth a punt, just to try something different.

Joel Bowden always did reasonably as a defender playing on Fevola; and I'd suggest the size difference there was more magnified by Fev staying closer to goal. If Judd was fully fit then maybe. Going half-pace, as he is at the moment, its stupid. But then, nothing Ratten has done as coach has impressed me yet...

We might do a "Pagan" and have Fev at full back on Gehrig.
Wouldn't be so silly. It might keep Fev "interested" all night???

 

[PeeKay]

Well, not entirely. But it might be worth a punt, just to try something different.

Joel Bowden always did reasonably as a defender playing on Fevola; and I'd suggest the size difference there was more magnified by Fev staying closer to goal. If Judd was fully fit then maybe. Going half-pace, as he is at the moment, its stupid. But then, nothing Ratten has done as coach has impressed me yet...

We might do a "Pagan" and have Fev at full back on Gehrig.
Wouldn't be so silly. It might keep Fev "interested" all night???

 

[mediumsizered]

Why?

King will be judged on his performance and what we've got to replace him with.

If we miss finals it will probably be Ross Lyon being delisted.

IMO, King was recruited by St Kilda for much the same reason that Sydney recruited Jason Ball a few years ago. They have identified the lack of proven ruckmen as being the difference between challenging for a premiership or coming up short again.

Given King's injury history, he is no longer capable of producing the form that saw him achieve AA status in 2000. In addition he turns 30 this year & although some players have 3-4 years left in them at this age, King's injury history will curtail his AFL career sooner rather than later. That is not to say that King can't be an important part of a premiership push by St Kilda this year or next, because he does have something to offer a team that is strong in other facets of the game. It is more a case that if St Kilda were to miss the finals again this year, that would point towards them not being ready to push for a premiership & therefore King would hold no value to St Kilda moving forward after this year.

 

[parrot]

...
Carlton wouldn't have taken him because of his age. Same with Gardiner....

JD, you've actually got something right! I'm impressed.

 

[disconorman]

Are you saying I shouldn't be doing this ? Only warm meal i get some weeks..

...reminds me of porridge.

 

[Silvagnis]

It might work if Judd tunnels.

 

[Brighton_Diggins]

It might work if Judd tunnels.

Give him a miners light and a pick.
That'll do the job.