MVP The Didaka Medal - 2011 BigFooty Magpies MVP

[robertg22]

Results from the voting are in folks, the 2011 award will be known as The Didaka Medal.

Please continue to provide votes in a 5,4,3,2,1 basis weekly, I'll tally up the votes generally on a Tuesday night (no point voting afterwards as once I've tallied them up, I don't add any more).

Response has been great so far, keep them coming.

Results thus far:

Round 1 vs Port:

5. Johnson
4. Swan
3. Dawes
2. Pendlebury
1. Shaw

Round 2 vs North:

5. Pendlebury
4. Swan
3. Dawes
2. Cloke
1. Beams

Overall:

8. Swan
7. Pendlebury
6. Dawes
5. Johnson
2. Cloke
1. Beams, Shaw

 

[half_back_flank]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Nice work, looks like we have been pretty accurate so far.

 

[Quicky]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

This thread is stuck. Keep the votes coming people. We all know it is more accurate than any umpire or media award out there.

 

[handy point]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Just so long as we can get Briedis to present this one as well.

 

[Gibbsy]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Would be interesting to see how many votes the top five players polled in the thread, rather than just only being ordered from one to five. e.g. 5. Johnson (78 votes or whatever it may be)

A great effort though so far, keep up the good work.

 

[shawthing09]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Would be interesting to see how many votes the top five players polled in the thread, rather than just only being ordered from one to five. e.g. 5. Johnson (78 votes or whatever it may be)

A great effort though so far, keep up the good work.

That would make the results inaccurate because you would have more responses in some weeks than others meaning a best on ground vs a lowly Brisbane in a game we romp them could be worth 200 votes and a best on ground in a slog vs Hawthorn only worth 150.

Working in the system means anyone can vote on any week whilst the voting remains fair and consistant.

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

I think what he wants is to just show me who got how many votes for that particular round, it's not going to change the outcome but shows who was close to getting votes etc? If that's the case I can do & will post those results from now on in, easy enough.
If it's the other then no, the voting system itself won't change.

 

[Gibbsy]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

I think what he wants is to just show me who got how many votes for that particular round, it's not going to change the outcome but shows who was close to getting votes etc? If that's the case I can do & will post those results from now on in, easy enough.
If it's the other then no, the voting system itself won't change.

I mean the former. Obviously a popular game would garner more votes and then skew the results, that's not what I was after. I really only wanted to see the amount of votes so you could sort of tell how much a certain player was best on ground by. Just gives more of a gauge of the overall performances whilst still keeping the 5-4-3-2-1 format.

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Done, will have that along with this week's votes and moving forward.

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Round 3 vs Carlton

5. Blair
4. Shaw
3. Cloke
2. Reid
1. Swan

Overall:

9 - Swan
7 - Pendlebury
6 - Dawes
5 - Cloke, Shaw, Johnson, Blair
2 - Reid
1 - Beams


This week's votes in total:


Blair 195
Shaw 191
Cloke 91
Reid 49
Swan 38
Johnson 36
O'Brien 24
Beams 14
Thomas 6
Krakouer 6
Ball 5
Dawes 5
Jolly 4
Pendlebury 3
Sidebottom 3
Toovey 1

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Round 4 vs Richmond:

5. Swan
4. Thomas
3. Cloke
2. Sidebottom
1. Pendlebury

Overall:

14 - Swan
8 - Pendlebury, Cloke
6 - Dawes
5 - Shaw, Johnson, Blair
4 - Thomas
2 - Reid, Sidebottom
1 - Beams

This week's votes in total:


Swan 167
Thomas 135
Cloke 82
Sidebottom 42
Pendlebury 31
Ball 18
Tarrant 12
Shaw 10
Blair 6
O'Brien 4
Beams 2
Dawes 1

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Round 5 vs Essendon:
5 - Pendlebury
4 - Cloke
3 - Davis
2 - Shaw
1 - Toovey

Overall:
14 - Swan
13 - Pendlebury
12 - Cloke
7 - Shaw
6 - Dawes
5 - Johnson, Blair
4 - Thomas
3 - Davis
2 - Reid, Sidebottom
1 - Beams, Toovey

This week's votes in total:

Pendlebury 231
Cloke 112
Davis 105
Shaw 104
Toovey 62
Ball 32
Jolly 23
Wellingham 16
Reid 16
Tarrant 12
Thomas 4
O'Brien 2

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Emblebury Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Round 6 vs Bulldogs:

5 - Sidebottom
4 - Shaw
3 - L Brown
2 - Krakouer
1 - Ball

Overall:

14 - Swan
13 - Pendlebury
12 - Cloke
11 - Shaw
7 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes
5 - Johnson, Blair
4 - Thomas
3 - L Brown, Davis
2 - Reid, Krakouer
1 - Beams, Ball, Toovey

This week's votes in total:

Sidebottom 118
Shaw 104
L Brown 91
Krakouer 68
Ball 20
Pendlebury 14
Davis 11
Wellingham 6
Reid 6
Thomas 4
Wood 2
Swan 1
Blair 1

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Didaka Memorial Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Round 7 vs Geelong:

5 - Thomas
4 - Shaw
3 - Buckley
2 - Davis
1 - Swan

Overall:

15 - Swan, Shaw
13 - Pendlebury
12 - Cloke
9 - Thomas
7 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes
5 - Johnson, Blair, Davis
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Reid, Krakouer
1 - Beams, Ball, Toovey

This week's votes in total:

Thomas 121
Shaw 97
Buckley 49
Davis 45
Swan 18
Reid 16
Sidebottom 14
Tarrant 6
Toovey 5
Wellingham 2
Dawes 2

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Didaka Memorial Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Getting tight at the top, the race for the MVP this year is wide open!

Round 9 vs Adelaide:
5 - Thomas
4 - Ball
3 - Reid
2 - Pendlebury
1 - Wellingham

Overall:

15 - Swan, Shaw, Pendlebury
14 - Thomas
12 - Cloke
7 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes
5 - Johnson, Blair, Davis, Reid, Ball
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer
1 - Beams, Toovey, Wellingham

This week's votes in total:

Thomas 157
Ball 109
Reid 57
Pendlebury 41
Wellingham 29
Tarrant 28
Davis 23
Sidebottom 17
Krakouer 9
Beams 8

 

[The Get Up Kid]

Re: The Didaka Memorial Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

In reference to the overall tally:

Think the voting goes to show how close our B & F would be at the moment.

Thomas, Pendlebury, Shaw & Swan would just about be on the same votes!

 

[Swooop]

Re: The Didaka Memorial Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Round 10 vs West Coast Eagles:

5 - Thomas
4 - Pendlebury
3 - Ball
2 - Reid
1 - O'Brien

Overall:

19 - Thomas, Pendlebury
15 - Swan, Shaw,
12 - Cloke
8 - Ball
7 - Sidebottom, Reid
6 - Dawes
5 - Johnson, Blair, Davis,
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer
1 - Beams, Toovey, Wellingham, O'Brien

This week's votes in total:

Thomas 184
Pendlebury 121
Ball 92
Reid 84
O'Brien 42
Davis 35
Toovey 3
Beams 2
Shaw 1
Tarrant 1

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Didaka Memorial Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Daisy & Pendles stretching away.

Votes vs St Kilda:
5 - Pendlebury
4 - Cloke
3 - Thomas
2 - Davis
1 - Reid

Overall:
24 - Pendlebury
22 - Thomas
16 - Cloke
15 - Swan, Shaw
8 - Ball, Reid
7 - Sidebottom, Davis
6 - Dawes
5 - Johnson, Blair
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer
1 - Beams, Toovey, Wellingham, O'Brien



St Kilda votes in total:
Pendlebury 155
Cloke 127
Thomas 93
Davis 71
Reid 42
Shaw 9
Swan 5
Ball 3
Beams 2
Wellingham 2
Maxwell 1

 

[robertg22]

Re: The Didaka Memorial Medal - 2011 Bigfooty Magpies MVP

Votes vs Melbourne:
5 - Wellingham
4 - Cloke
3 - Davis
2 - Ball
1 - Reid

Overall:

24 - Pendlebury
22 - Thomas
20 - Cloke
15 - Swan, Shaw
10 - Ball, Davis
9 - Reid
7 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes, Wellingham
5 - Johnson, Blair
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer
1 - Beams, Toovey, O'Brien

Total votes vs Melbourne:

Wellingham 195
Cloke 171
Davis 94
Ball 67
Tarrant 28
Reid 28
Pendlebury 20
Wood 5
O'Brien 4
Blair 2
Didak 1

**EDIT: Reid receives the 1 vote on countback over Tarrant (Reid had one '4' vote & Tarrant had none)
Updated the leaderboard to reflect this.

 

[robertg22]

We have our first unanimous 5 vote performance this season - well done Trav.

Votes vs Sydney:

5 - Cloke
4 - Ball
3 - Swan
2 - Tarrant
1 - Pendlebury

Overall:

25 - Pendlebury, Cloke
22 - Thomas
18 - Swan
15 - Shaw
14 - Ball
10 - Davis
9 - Reid
7 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes, Wellingham
5 - Johnson, Blair
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer, Tarrant
1 - Beams, Toovey, O'Brien

Total votes vs Sydney:

Cloke 165
Ball 115
Swan 66
Tarrant 64
Pendlebury 25
Toovey 20
Davis 14
Reid 11
Maxwell 10
Shaw 5

 

[robertg22]

We have a new outright leader. Would Travis be leading the Copeland at the moment?

Votes vs Hawthorn:

5. Reid
4. Cloke
3. Pendlebury
2. Swan
1. Thomas

Overall:

29 - Cloke
28 - Pendlebury
23 - Thomas
20 - Swan
15 - Shaw
14 - Ball, Reid
10 - Davis
7 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes, Wellingham
5 - Johnson, Blair
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer, Tarrant
1 - Beams, Toovey, O'Brien

This week's votes in total:

Reid 127
Cloke 93
Pendlebury 60
Swan 47
Thomas 33
Tarrant 21
Jolly 15
O'Brien 11
Shaw 10
Toovey 3

 

[mdc]

We have a new outright leader. Would Travis be leading the Copeland at the moment?

Not sure, has had several 4's and 5's but a few really average games too, which will count against him in the Copeland.

Interesting that this week despite the voting being all over the place, the aggregate ended up matching the coaches' votes exactly.

 

[robertg22]

Actually hope Pendles wins his first Copeland and first Brownlow this year, they're about the only awards he doesn't have already!

 

[robertg22]

Votes vs North:

5. Pendlebury
4. Swan
3. Thomas
2. Reid
1. Sidebottom

Overall:

33 - Pendlebury
29 - Cloke
26 - Thomas
24 - Swan
16 - Reid
15 - Shaw
14 - Ball
10 - Davis
8 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes, Wellingham
5 - Johnson, Blair
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer, Tarrant
1 - Beams, Toovey, O'Brien


This week's votes in total:

Pendlebury 93
Swan 83
Thomas 79
Reid 56
Sidebottom 19 *
Blair 19 *
Tarrant 12
Toovey 12
Davis 10
Shaw 5
O'Brien 2

* Sidebottom received the 1 vote overall due to the fact that he had received 1x4 vote and Blair's highest received was a 3 vote.

 

[robertg22]

Votes vs Carlton:

5 - Pendlebury
4 - Ball
3 - Thomas
2 - Davis
1 - Cloke

Overall:

38 - Pendlebury
30 - Cloke
29 - Thomas
24 - Swan
18 - Ball
16 - Reid
15 - Shaw
12 - Davis
8 - Sidebottom
6 - Dawes, Wellingham
5 - Johnson, Blair
3 - L Brown, Buckley
2 - Krakouer, Tarrant
1 - Beams, Toovey, O'Brien

This week's votes in total:
Pendlebury 90
Ball 88
Thomas 75
Davis 56
Cloke 34
Swan 13
Johnson 8
Sidebottom 7
Tarrant 4

Interesting thing to note is that the group of Pendlebury, Cloke, Thomas, Swan, Ball, Reid & Davis have received 110 of a total 120 votes allocated in our last 8 matches. So while it can appear that our performances are quite well spread each week, I think this shows definitively who our in form players are.

In that time, Pendles has received 25 votes (maximum possible was 40) in addition to polling votes in 11 of 15 games, including 5 BOG performances.