List Mgmt. 2014 Trade and Free Agency Targets Thread

[LuvtheKangas]

So where did the picks 5, 25 come from and who for?

Really? What do we start with and what do we finish with? The rest (apart from being unworkable) is smoke and mirrors.

Under your scenario, we give up Greenwood, McKenzie and 16 for 5, 25 and 67. Won't happen.

If Collingwood won't take 5 and 25 for Beams, plus they think Greenwood is worth 30, why would they take Greenwood, McKenzie and 16 for Beams?

 

[CarnTheKANGAS]

I'd trade him for a light sabre.....or...or......a hovercar.

make it happen euge.

?

 

[SnowRoo]

OK dont crucify me cos this involves Varcoe, but we are talking to him. Its not too bad borrowed from the Pies board for your consideration.

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood + Pick 35

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 35
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 30

 

[CarnTheKANGAS]

Really? What do we start with and what do we finish with? The rest (apart from being unworkable) is smoke and mirrors.

Under your scenario, we give up Greenwood, McKenzie and 16 for 5, 25 and 67. Won't happen.

If Collingwood won't take 5 and 25 for Beams, plus they think Greenwood is worth 30, why would they take Greenwood, McKenzie and 16 for Beams?

What they think he Is worth and what they are willing to pay for him ,2 diff. things

 

[RobZombie]

Trombone

Gusset.

 

[niko11]

So if Harvey passes to Cooney for goal here comes the booom cooon!

 

[TREMBANYAMA]

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 30

Only problem is the whole receiving of Varcoe. He is just... Awful.

 

[Jay-Z]

Bit surprised to see Petrenko delisted

I heard he was retired rather than desisted

 

[SnowRoo]

Only problem is the whole receiving of Varcoe. He is just... Awful.

I agree but it seems we are talking to him.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

I heard he was retired rather than desisted

Cease and desist. CEASE AND DESIST.

 

[Jay-Z]

OK dont crucify me cos this involves Varcoe, but we are talking to him. Its not too bad borrowed from the Pies board for your consideration.

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood + Pick 35

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 35
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 30

If you rate Varcoe it seems like an ok deal, problem is I don't think anyone here does

 

[LuvtheKangas]

What they think he Is worth and what they are willing to pay for him ,2 diff. things

That's why the deal hasn't been done - they're not willing to pay more than they think he is worth.

And even when you take that out, the trade has no chance of happening. It's less than what Brisbane have offered for Beams, which Collingwood rejected.

 

[R00StaR]

They were talking pick 56 on the AFL site.

2 year deal for Cooney.

So would people take?

Higgins, Waite, Cooney, pick 30 in.

Greenwood, pick 56 out.

Picks 16, 30, 36, 73 draft.

Pick 30 is an insult, if it were me personally i wouldnt reward Collingwood or Greenwood. After all the investment Levi is not giving us any scope to shop a better deal......sorry, id pass on 30 and send him to the PSD.

Looking how tight are list spots are id trade McMahon and pick 73 for Cooney. McMahon could easily get himself up and offer the dogs a few years, they could probably use an experienced head back there too.

For Greenwood, Collingwood can cough up a pick around 25 and upgrade our pick 56 and 30.

In: Higgins, Waite, Cooney, picks 25, 30
Out: McMahon, Greenwood, pick 56

Picks 16, 25, 30, 36

 

[CarnTheKANGAS]

That's why the deal hasn't been done - they're not willing to pay more than they think he is worth.

And even when you take that out, the trade has no chance of happening. It's less than what Brisbane have offered for Beams, which Collingwood rejected.

Id still throw up this deal with a mullet even bastinac (instead of mckenzie). All behind closed doors of course.

 

[Dan]

Greenwood + Bastinac + 16 for Beams.

Even that probably isn't enough. But if a genuine top 10 player of the competition is up for grabs, you gotta at least try.

 

[marklovesbeer]

I just said the same thing in levi thread.
would def. pursue this, even without the incoming pick 30 I think is a good deal.

I thought this was the Levi thread...

 

[King Corey]

OK dont crucify me cos this involves Varcoe, but we are talking to him. Its not too bad borrowed from the Pies board for your consideration.

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood + Pick 35

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 35
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 30

<Gif of me kicking you over a silo>

 

[Horace]

Well here we are one week after the signing of free agents started. And what have we seen achieved in that week?

Next to nothing. A few bit trades that's all and a whole heap of absurd posturing by a few clubs/player managers/internet posters.

And about all that has produced is a lot of hot air, probably adding to the greenhouse gas problem and reducing the worlds life expectancy by a few thousand years.

I feel a bit cheated. I've wasted too much time vainly reading posts and listening to SEN and reading the papers to see if anything meaningful has happened.

That's another week of my life gone and sadly I can't get it back. And neither can any of you. Trouble is I'm running out of weeks. I expect better than this because I can't afford to lose them this way. I'll just be nice and say damn the AFL, damn computers, damn the person or persons who invented the interwebs, damn the TV, damn the papers and damn the wireless.

I want to go back to when the world was a nice uncomplicated place to live in. Back around the turn of the last century when just about the only way you could communicate was by carrier pigeon or smoke signals or by messages carried on horseback.

 

[Deadeyeroo]

Forget it Beams is not coming to our club or any club here in Vic. #Fairytalestuff

 

[boneofshin]

I heard he was retired rather than desisted

That was Porplyzia. Petrenko is only 24, which surprised me a bit because it feels like he's been around for a long time.

 

[SnowRoo]

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 36

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood + 36
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 21 + 30


Im sure something here is lop sided, any objective eyes wanna help me

 

[marklovesbeer]

Greenwood + Bastinac + 16 for Beams.

Even that probably isn't enough. But if a genuine top 10 player of the competition is up for grabs, you gotta at least try.

His father battling cancer lives in Queensland, not North Melbourne...

 

[roos_fanatic08]

OK dont crucify me cos this involves Varcoe, but we are talking to him. Its not too bad borrowed from the Pies board for your

consideration.

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +

Pick 35

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 35
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis
Varcoe + Pick 30

Yuck. DO NOT WANT VARCOE!

If he can't Perform in a team like Geelongs he is going to be playing VFL on 400K if he is on our list!

He is a Tambling clone. No defensive side whatsoever and he has reached his ceiling as a footballer.

 

[SnowRoo]

ok take 2

Collingwood trade: Heritier Lumumba + Pick 30
Collingwood receive: Levi Greenwood +55

Geelong trade: Travis Varcoe + Pick 55+21
Geelong receive: Mitch Clark + Pick 30

Melbourne trade: Mitch Clark
Melbourne receive: Heritier Lumumba

North Melbourne trade: Levi Greenwood
North Melbourne receive: Travis Varcoe + Pick 21

??

 

[boneofshin]

Take out Varcoe as a sweetener.