Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[joop]

Tom Lee, 50% for St Kilda too.

Didn't draft him. Next.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

You couldn't possibly be so deluded.

It's changed everything. There drafting for one. Ryder would have fetched Essendon much more if the scandal didn't happen. Explain what's deluded about that?

I'm not having a go at the club, but it has changed the way their club is. It's sad.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

It's changed everything. There drafting for one. Ryder would have fetched Essendon much more if the scandal didn't happen. Explain what's deluded about that?

I'm not having a go at the club, but it has changed the way their club is. It's sad.

Only because he was contracted.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Only because he was contracted.

I'd suggest a team would have given Essendon a top 10 pick easily

 

[MightyDons4]

Didn't draft him. Next.

"A key forward who is a reliable shot for goal, Lee was selected with pick 12 in the 2012 National Draft after an impressive two years at Claremont in the WAFL." Taken directly of you clubs website.

Tom Lynch and Spencer White are a couple from recent memory that haven't done anything to justify you picking them.

 

[YEMOC NAYR]

I'd suggest a team would have given Essendon a top 10 pick easily

GWS offered pick 4, but he refused to deal with them. Only had eyes set on port

 

[HereComesJuddy]

GWS offered pick 4, but he refused to deal with them. Only had eyes set on port

Makes it tough when a player only chooses the one club. It sucks for the club the player leaves, not so much the players choice of club.

 

[Ian Dunross]

"A key forward who is a reliable shot for goal, Lee was selected with pick 12 in the 2012 National Draft after an impressive two years at Claremont in the WAFL." Taken directly of you clubs website.

Tom Lynch and Spencer White are a couple from recent memory that haven't done anything to justify you picking them.

Tom Lynch is a starter in one of the best forward lines in the league. Not sure where you're going with that.

Spencer White was taken at pick 25. Shame if he doesn't make it. No huge bust though.

Kristian Jaksch was taken with pick 12 in the 2012 draft by GWS.

Tom Lee was traded from the GWS pre-selection list for pick 12, in return for Lee, plus picks 24 and 25.

 

[MightyDons4]

Tom Lynch is a starter in one of the best forward lines in the league. Not sure where you're going with that.

Spencer White was taken at pick 25. Shame if he doesn't make it. No huge bust though.

Kristian Jaksch was taken with pick 12 in the 2012 draft by GWS.

Tom Lee was traded from the GWS pre-selection list for pick 12, in return for Lee, plus picks 24 and 25.

Tom Lynch was a waste of a pick from St Kilda's perspective

White was a waste of a pick

I just got my info off your clubs website. The point still stands, you gave up pick 12 for a bust.

St Kilda have done some excellent drafting in recent years, just pointing out to your other poster that quality KPP prospects are hard to come by and St Kilda isn't immune to drafting duds.

 

[Bunk Moreland]

Absolutely.

And if he chooses StKilda, it will be for say your Pick 25.....and maybe Hickey if you are feeling generous. And EFC would have to accept it, or let him walk...and they WON'T let him walk...and StKilda know that.

St Kilda will screw Essendon... unless they're feeling generous, then they won't.

More compelling insight from the Carlton crew

 

[Ian Dunross]

Tom Lynch was a waste of a pick from St Kilda's perspective

White was a waste of a pick

I just got my info off your clubs website. The point still stands, you gave up pick 12 for a bust.

St Kilda have done some excellent drafting in recent years, just pointing out to your other poster that quality KPP prospects are hard to come by and St Kilda isn't immune to drafting duds.

I don't see how Lynch was a waste of a pick. We traded Lynch for Jack Newnes who's played 50 games as a 4th year player.

We gave up pick 12 for Lee, Wright and White. The alternative was pick Kristian Jaksch. I'd rather take the three Saints players than Jaksch. None of those 4 are guaranteed to make it. Better to have a 3/4 shot.

I agree with your last sentence. But it all depends on the draft year.

 

[joop]

"A key forward who is a reliable shot for goal, Lee was selected with pick 12 in the 2012 National Draft after an impressive two years at Claremont in the WAFL." Taken directly of you clubs website.

Tom Lynch and Spencer White are a couple from recent memory that haven't done anything to justify you picking them.

You're embarrassing yourself.

 

[Red Bull]

St Kilda will screw Essendon... unless they're feeling generous, then they won't.

More compelling insight from the Carlton crew

Here's the news Bunk ...

efc screwed themselves royally !!

Just grit your teeth and take what's coming ...

 

[joop]

Tom Lynch was a waste of a pick from St Kilda's perspective

White was a waste of a pick

I just got my info off your clubs website. The point still stands, you gave up pick 12 for a bust.

St Kilda have done some excellent drafting in recent years, just pointing out to your other poster that quality KPP prospects are hard to come by and St Kilda isn't immune to drafting duds.

Tom lynch = Jack newnes. Hardly a bust.
We traded pick 12 for 3 players in a terrible draft who as a collective have shown more than the player taken at pick 12. Hardly a bust.

Quality KPP are definitely hard to come by, but you don't have to trade a top 5 pick for an out of contracted player to get one.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Here's the news Bunk ...

efc screwed themselves royally !!

Just grit your teeth and take what's coming ...

Settle down Red. I'm sure he knows your management...
Everything he now writes, he can't help but have a dip at Carlton. It's now beyond sad.

 

[MightyDons4]

I don't see how Lynch was a waste of a pick. We traded Lynch for Jack Newnes who's played 50 games as a 4th year player.

We gave up pick 12 for Lee, Wright and White. The alternative was pick Kristian Jaksch. I'd rather take the three Saints players than Jaksch. None of those 4 are guaranteed to make it. Better to have a 3/4 shot.

I agree with your last sentence. But it all depends on the draft year.

Jack Newnes is a very good player, didn't realise he came from the Lynch pick

None of the three listed players look like they'll make it, so that trade was a massive bust.

Tom lynch = Jack newnes. Hardly a bust.
We traded pick 12 for 3 players in a terrible draft who as a collective have shown more than the player taken at pick 12. Hardly a bust.

Quality KPP are definitely hard to come by, but you don't have to trade a top 5 pick for an out of contracted player to get one.

You basically copied what the poster above said, good job

 

[joop]

Jack Newnes is a very good player, didn't realise he came from the Lynch pick

None of the three listed players look like they'll make it, so that trade was a massive bust.

You basically copied what the poster above said, good job

Actually I just wrote fact, which you seem to be to stupid to comprehend. Do some research before making yourself look like an idiot. Chin up kid, I know it's been a rough couple of years.

 

[MightyDons4]

Actually I just wrote fact, which you seem to be to stupid to comprehend. Do some research before making yourself look like an idiot. Chin up kid, I know it's been a rough couple of years.

Seems like I touched a nerve there

 

[joop]

Seems like I touched a nerve there

Not at all, I just have little patience for people who have no idea what they're talking about.

 

[Defacto]

Would be funny if we got beej as steak knives as well

 

[MightyDons4]

Not at all, I just have little patience for people who have no idea what they're talking about.

Didn't realise you were the resident expert around here

 

[Bunk Moreland]

Here's the news Bunk ...

efc screwed themselves royally !!

Just grit your teeth and take what's coming ...

Three years now... no teeth left!

 

[TerryWallet]

St Kilda will screw Essendon... unless they're feeling generous, then they won't.

More compelling insight from the Carlton crew

gday Bunky, how's your sanity holding up lately?

Where in my post do StKilda NOT screw Essendon?

If Carlisle picks StKilda, StKilda offer Pick 25 and maybe Hickey.

Essendon either accept that deal....or send him to the PSD.

Whichever club Carlisle picks, that club has Essendon over a barrel because they know that Essendon won't let Carlisle walk for nothing...especially to Carlton for nothing.

You'll get unders, a reasonable trade, but unders....no matter which club Jake chooses.

 

[Taylor]

"A key forward who is a reliable shot for goal, Lee was selected with pick 12 in the 2012 National Draft after an impressive two years at Claremont in the WAFL." Taken directly of you clubs website.

Tom Lynch and Spencer White are a couple from recent memory that haven't done anything to justify you picking them.

I thought St kilda traded that pick to an expansion club to get him as a previously listed player, like Krakoer to Collingwood

 

[Ian Dunross]

Jack Newnes is a very good player, didn't realise he came from the Lynch pick

None of the three listed players look like they'll make it, so that trade was a massive bust.

Jaksch doesn't look like he'll make it. So it was a busted flush no matter what happened.