List Mgmt. 2015 LIST Discussion - trades, free agency etc

[SurreyBlue]

Great relief this morning regarding the Carlisle news! As said previously - did not want.
Let's now concentrate on getting the GWS KP kids over!!! This will be the win!!!
Tomlinson & Plowman to go with Weitering & Weideman/Curnow(?) = start of KP rebuild!!!
Add Jaksch and you get talented youth.

 

[Giant Pete]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

 

[Crippa#9]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

Not over Weitering.

 

[Aphrodite]

If Treloar was available in the PSD at pick 1 would you take him?

Yes!

 

[alfo]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

Would be an interesting scenario, don't think we would though. $$ being the big factor and our need for some more KPP.

 

[blue healer]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

Doubt it, particularly if Casboult goes as well. We need height because without them and little coming in we would be under average height for the under 14's.

 

[slashin_velvet]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

Why would he do that, when it would weaken our overall drafting strategy, and he could get to us in the PSD anyway?

If he doesnt want to come to Carlton, he's more than welcome to facilitate a trade with another club

 

[HBF]

Wasn't that what I said?

Pretty much.
We're a good team....

 

[blue healer]

Am I the only person whose stance on doping doesn't change depending on whose involved?

Are we all so happy to look the other way if it would hurt us to acknowledge it?

Tongue was planted firmly in my cheek during that post as I'm firmly in the camp that believes the players have been put through the wringer over the last 3 years and have suffered enough.

Happy that Hird's gone but I think there's a lot of books that still should be thrown at the EFC.

 

[Carl Tone]

Just out of interest to see where everyone stands, if you could choose from Treloar or Carlisle for the PSD who would you prefer?

With Carlisle* quite possibly being rubbed out for 2 years, and being a bit of a sook, I'd lean toward Treloar now that the Pies deal is stumbling. And would think that if a few of his mates were heading to Carlton already, joining Jaksch and Whiley, that might be enough to get him to think about going into the PSD... SOS's cunning plan all along?

 

[Dramoth]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

And if Weitering wasnt there... hell yeah.

But seeing as Weitering is there and we need a general in defense, **** no... but I would be working every angle to get pick 2 off Brisvegas so we could get Treloar at pick 2

 

[P_Crippy]

Just out of interest to see where everyone stands, if you could choose from Treloar or Carlisle for the PSD who would you prefer?

With Carlisle* quite possibly being rubbed out for 2 years, and being a bit of a sook, I'd lean toward Treloar now that the Pies deal is stumbling. And would think that if a few of his mates were heading to Carlton already, joining Jaksch and Whiley, that might be enough to get him to think about going into the PSD... SOS's cunning plan all along?

Treloar

 

[Sin City]

Just out of interest to see where everyone stands, if you could choose from Treloar or Carlisle for the PSD who would you prefer?

Treloar and it's not even close. Treloar is the best young midfielder in the game, Carlisle is a good player.

 

[Aphrodite]

Just out of interest to see where everyone stands, if you could choose from Treloar or Carlisle for the PSD who would you prefer?

With Carlisle* quite possibly being rubbed out for 2 years, and being a bit of a sook, I'd lean toward Treloar now that the Pies deal is stumbling. And would think that if a few of his mates were heading to Carlton already, joining Jaksch and Whiley, that might be enough to get him to think about going into the PSD... SOS's cunning plan all along?

Treloar!




#nobrainer

 

[Dramoth]

Just out of interest to see where everyone stands, if you could choose from Treloar or Carlisle for the PSD who would you prefer?

With Carlisle* quite possibly being rubbed out for 2 years, and being a bit of a sook, I'd lean toward Treloar now that the Pies deal is stumbling. And would think that if a few of his mates were heading to Carlton already, joining Jaksch and Whiley, that might be enough to get him to think about going into the PSD... SOS's cunning plan all along?

If it's between Treloar or Carlisle... Treloar without a doubt. He would be an immediate Judd replacement and would push Murphy to the forward line.

 

[GordonBlue]

If Treloar was available in the ND at pick 1 would you take him?

Simply... No.

 

[zeeCFC]

Treloar and it's not even close. Treloar is the best young midfielder in the game, Carlisle is a good player.

Big call Sin. O'Meara, Shiel, Bont, Crouch, Cripps?

 

[Sin City]

Big call Sin. O'Meara, Shiel, Bont, Crouch, Cripps?

He's better than them at this stage.

 

[zeeCFC]

He's better than them at this stage.

I'd have him on par with Jaegar and Shiel.

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Treloar and it's not even close. Treloar is the best young midfielder in the game, Carlisle is a good player.

Personally I think Angus Brayshaw is or will be, but its horses for courses. Also I am fairly sure that unlike Dangerfield, Treloar can't nominate for the National Draft, would have to put himself in the PSD.

Its all academic though, a deal between the Pies and GWS will get done, trade week hasn't started yet.

 

[goreds]

Re. Carlisle? Nothing's over the line until it's over the line.................best forgotten for now............but..............

Plowman & Tomlinson should look good in Navy Blue though.

Saints have to cough up their 1st pick to trade with the bombers... Good luck with that!!

Heaps of names floating around, some not declared yet!!

 

[Dramoth]

Saints have to cough up their 1st pick to trade with the bombers... Good luck with that!!

Heaps of names floating around, some not declared yet!!

The Aint's need their first round pick for another mobile forward

 

[zeeCFC]

Maybe we could do:

Casboult and Pick 9 to St Kilda
Pick 9 to Essendon, Pick 5 to Carlton
Carlisle to St Kilda

 

[footyfan098]

This is what i can imagine happening if the rumoured trades eventuate:

Henderson, 20 and 56 for 9, 46 and walker

bell and casboult for pick 19

yarran for pick 18 from hawks (or yaz and 19 for pick 12 and 32 from tigs)

18 for tomlinson and lamb

19 for plowman sumner and phillips

Go to draft with: 1 (weitering) 9 (matheison/weideman type) 38 (rice) 46 (SOSOS)

2016 lineup:

Buckley Jamison Tuohey
Docherty weitering Plowman
Simpson Gibbs Boekhorst
Daisy Tomlinson Menzel
Everitt Walker Jaksh
Kruezer Murphy Cripps
Graham Curnow Sumner walker

Emergencies: pick 9 White lamb rowe whiley etc


Not a bad looking lineup really? simpson jamison and andrew walker are the ageing types that need replacing soon, with likely types being brought in to cover for them in the future

 

[LanceRomance]

Pick 5 for Carlisle is doing my head in