Mega Thread Trade/Draft SuperMegaUltraThread - 2015 trade period edition

[Max zero]

IMO:

Pick + Jetta for Sinclair = Very good
Jetta for Sinclair = Good
Jetta for Sinclair + pick = Below break even

Haven't we already knocked back a straight swap?

Hopefully Vozzo has stuck to his guns and squeezed some extra value.

If he has gotten Jetta plus a pick or a pick upgrade I will take back some of the bad things I have said about him.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

If I was a betting man, which I am I think we are asking for pick 33 as well.

And give them the Selwood compo?

 

[Biggie]

Hope we get a pick as well.

Sinclair is contracted and Sydney want him.

Has to have something other a than straight swap. Has to. :|

 

[Suma Magic]

Upgrades from 37 to 33, and 55 to 52.

That would be reasonable.

 

[pantskyle]

And give them the Selwood compo?

How important is pick 33 to the Swans?

Is 14 enough to get Mills?

I don't think they are getting Dunkley as it looks like he doesn't want to move.

 

[Forget the Stats]

Mystery box! Mystery box!!

Might be Mcdougal coming out of retirement and coming to you. Former pick 4 I think he was.

 

[FatPizza]

We've re-signed Mcginnity just so has more value at the trade table. We've then thrown him in with Sinclair to get Jetta + 14.

Totally feasible.

 

[bungwahl]

Might be Mcdougal coming out of retirement and coming to you. Former pick 4 I think he was.

Hmm... is the red hat still an option?

 

[Hap Hapablap]

Dale Miller ‏@miller_dj 13m13 minutes ago
Love him or hate him, Pat McGinnity looks like being at West Coast in 2016. One year contract extension beckons

****en bullshit.

 

[beatlesmith]

You could never blame Sinclair for leaving.

Here he's on pittance (relatively speaking), and is one strong Lycett pre-season away from an indefinite period in the magoos.

Sydney seem to be doubling or tripling his money in a deal that should last to near the end of his career. I suspect he'll have more guarantees regarding playing time and will still be playing for a very good team.

Lycett having a poor and injury ruined season has probably ended up more than doubling Sinclair's career earnings.

 

[WCErevival]

Is there something official about mcginnity?

 

[Max zero]

We've re-signed Mcginnity just so has more value at the trade table. We've then thrown him in with Sinclair to get Jetta + 14.

Totally feasible.

We are tight as hell for list spots and we resign Mcginnity before Tunbridge? Sometimes I wonder...

 

[mad_eagle]

C'mon Crazy Voz, work your magic son!!!

 

[DickDunn]

I was expecting a picture of ducks crossing the road tbh...

 

[Max zero]

You could never blame Sinclair for leaving.

Here he's on pittance (relatively speaking), and is one strong Lycett pre-season away from an indefinite period in the magoos.

Sydney seem to be doubling or tripling his money in a deal that should last to near the end of his career. I suspect he'll have more guarantees regarding playing time and will still be playing for a very good team.

Lycett having a poor and injury ruined season has probably ended up more than doubling Sinclair's career earnings.

The guy was desperate to play AFL, took a big gamble and it looks to have payed off.

Can't really blame the guy for taking his opportunity.

A year ago he was nobody now he is on 400k and a starting ruck for a flag contender.

 

[DanWCE]

McGinnity is the pits, but if we are going to have a red hot crack at the flag then a bloke who understands the system (but poorly executes it) may be of some/little value to us over, say, a kid we recruit in the 3rd round who needs to learn the system and wont play a game anyway. In that instance McGinnity represents the last tether of "depth".

I am glad we are bringing in other first 22 to fatten up the depth but Selwood out Redden in hasnt increased depth head count wise, it has just been an upgrade of quality. Noone else will take Patrick so its in our interests to let him run around in the Magoos and if the worst case happens and we get bulk mid injuries, he understands the game plan and can (maybe) play a role (hopefully).

 

[Max zero]

McGinnity is the pits, but if we are going to have a red hot crack at the flag then a bloke who understands the system (but poorly executes it) may be of some/little value to us over, say, a kid we recruit in the 3rd round who needs to learn the system and wont play a game anyway. In that instance McGinnity represents the last tether of "depth".

I am glad we are bringing in other first 22 to fatten up the depth but Selwood out Redden in hasnt increased depth head count wise, it has just been an upgrade of quality. Noone else will take Patrick so its in our interests to let him run around in the Magoos and if the worst case happens and we get bulk mid injuries, he understands the game plan and can (maybe) play a role (hopefully).

In a way it sort of has increased depth because Selwood was just unplayable this year. I mean when your having to choose between bringing in a Selwood or a Mcginnity to cover an out its a bit of an empty choice.

Redden and Jetta are both playable. Add a fit Duggan and things are really looking up.

 

[DanWCE]

In a way it sort of has increased depth because Selwood was just unplayable this year. I mean when your having to choose between bringing in a Selwood or a Mcginnity to cover an out its a bit of an empty choice.

Redden and Jetta are both playable. Add a fit Duggan and things are really looking up.

Yea talent wise it has. Head count wise it has not. Should your mildly talented or highly talented mid get injured, you are still down a man on rotations. In this instance Patrick represents the last choice depth who may show an ounce of value in dire circumstances.

Keeping him as insurance when going for a flag is not an outright crazy idea in my mind. If we were rebuilding he would be goneski.

 

[PRANKSTER666]

Looks like Masten has been traded to Geelong and started his pre-season...

 

[ROC1969]

Colledge for Lennon - see what Richmond think. At the moment they may get zero for him if he goes to Carlton in the pre-season draft.

 

[Max zero]

Colledge for Lennon - see what Richmond think. At the moment they may get zero for him if he goes to Carlton in the pre-season draft.

That's almost crazy enough to work. Depends on how they rate Colledge and how tight their list is.

With the resigning of McGinnity our own list space needs to be accounted for as well.

 

[AsterixTheGaul]

In a way it sort of has increased depth because Selwood was just unplayable this year. I mean when your having to choose between bringing in a Selwood or a Mcginnity to cover an out its a bit of an empty choice.

Redden and Jetta are both playable. Add a fit Duggan and things are really looking up.

Selwood fit meant there was pressure to include in side at the expense of the likes of Nelson, Newman and hopefully a recovered Waterman in 2016.

I suspect we will have a bigger clean out at the end of next year with the draft depth in 2016 more like that of 2014. So Tunbridge and McSpud for another year on the list makes sense. I would personally like both of these to be delisted and rookied but not holding my breath

 

[new breed]

We are tight as hell for list spots and we resign Mcginnity before Tunbridge? Sometimes I wonder...

WCE also gave Tunbridge another year on the main list if not the rookie list !

 

[Johnno22]

How important is pick 33 to the Swans?

Is 14 enough to get Mills?

I don't think they are getting Dunkley as it looks like he doesn't want to move.

Swans will need both picks to get Mills.

 

[SurfnTurf]

C'mon Crazy Voz, work your magic son!!!

Crazy like a fox...