Traded Jake Carlisle [traded w/ #23 and #44 for #5, #24 and Craig Bird]

[2006_Eagles]

Port Adelaide trade 10 and future 1st Round to St Kilda for Pick 5

St Kilda trade 10 to Essendon for Jake Carlisle

Port Adelaide trade 5 to Gold Coast for Charlie Dixon and Pick 35

PA give up too much for mine

 

[gillo94]

relied on essendon and GC giving up more

That's BS

Essendon and Suns just receive picks. They give up nothing

Port want Dixon anyway

 

[fishardansin]

In what world is Dixon worth more than Carlisle?

Anyway Saints fans. If the choice for you is trading pick 5 or completely missing out on Carlisle, what is your choice?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

 

[gillo94]

PA give up too much for mine

Port should get 19 back from Suns if giving them 5 for Dixon

 

[foj1]

looks like the GC Port trade is dead in the water

latest is Sydney getting involved. would take something like
STK Lose: Pick 5, Pick 24
STK Gain: Carlisle, Pick 14
ESS Lose: Carlisle, Pick 25
ESS Gain: Pick 5
SYD Lose: Pick 14
SYD Gain: Pick 24 and 25

but sadly dodoro wont move on pick 25, so it looks like we get him for free in the PSD

This deal is fair
If dodo doesn't take it then shame on him
I have been critical of st Kilda but if dodo knocks this back tomorrow then this will be the last week in the job for him. It may be anyway!!!!
Hopefully this goes thru tomorrow.
Everyone wins here
Essendon get pick 5
Stkilda get Carlisle and a first round selection
Sydney get mills and Dunkley

 

[Defacto]

In what world is Dixon worth more than Carlisle?

Anyway Saints fans. If the choice for you is trading pick 5 or completely missing out on Carlisle, what is your choice?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

the part where we get him for free

 

[gillo94]

In what world is Dixon worth more than Carlisle?

Anyway Saints fans. If the choice for you is trading pick 5 or completely missing out on Carlisle, what is your choice?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

Dixon kicks more goals as a perminant forward

 

[aussierulesrules]

Are you feeling Ok ?

You said we win big because we could still have pick 23 & 25, these picks belong to us legitimately one via a trade the other as allocated by the AFL.

It really shits me how saints fans want to package picks to get something back, its simple you want the player you pay if both clubs agree on his value then pay up and if you don't have pick 10 then pay pick 5. Stiff Shit

Let me predict the response PSD ? Pffftt

Is it really that hard to work out what I was saying there? You clearly haven't understood one bit of it and then you've gone on a rant! Well done.

What I was saying is that if that trade went through (Carlisle for pick 10) you would still have 23 and 25 left, which you may then be able to package up and trade to say GWS for pick 8, which would mean you finish up with picks 4, 8 and 10, a fantastic result.

On the other hand, if you reject this deal and keep on insisting on getting pick 5 off us, you will almost certainly have to give up one of those two early 20's picks, as well as Carlisle, in order for us to be willing to trade pick 5. That then most likely eliminates the option of trading for GWS's pick 8 and leaves you with only one of 23 or 25, meaning you end up with 4, 5 and 23/25, rather than 4, 8 and 10, which is what you might be able to leave with if you accept the deal that was suggested earlier today.

Surely that's not that hard to comprehend?

 

[Verdun]

Are you feeling Ok ?

You said we win big because we could still have pick 23 & 25, these picks belong to us legitimately one via a trade the other as allocated by the AFL.

It really shits me how saints fans want to package picks to get something back, its simple you want the player you pay if both clubs agree on his value then pay up and if you don't have pick 10 then pay pick 5. Stiff Shit

Let me predict the response PSD ? Pffftt

Are you serious - again your bloke leaking that he is knocking back 10 and you are ok with that?? He dismissed 3rd involvement from day 1 as a badge of honour and then played it out via the media.

Guess what pick 5 belongs to the Saints legitimately, settle mate

 

[2006_Eagles]

but sadly dodoro wont move on pick 25, so it looks like we get him for free in the PSD

 

[RoundCubic]

So assuming JC is in a Saints jumper next year and has a good run with injury where will he finish in the B&F ?

Well probably behind this years winner who was pick 42

 

[bird_man]

In what world is Dixon worth more than Carlisle?

Anyway Saints fans. If the choice for you is trading pick 5 or completely missing out on Carlisle, what is your choice?

Sent from my Nexus 5 using Tapatalk

Missing out. Happy to do it if we get a second rounder back though.

 

[Bomberboy2013]

Hawks cap open for Carlisle capture
HAWTHORN would be prepared to restructure its player payments to fit in Jake Carlisle as Essendon stands firm on its trade demands.

 

[Falchoon]

In what world is Dixon worth more than Carlisle?

Anyway Saints fans. If the choice for you is trading pick 5 or completely missing out on Carlisle, what is your choice?

Prefer to keep 5 & try for the hail mary of Carlisle in the PSD

 

[MightySaint]

Hawks cap open for Carlisle capture
HAWTHORN would be prepared to restructure its player payments to fit in Jake Carlisle as Essendon stands firm on its trade demands.

I think it might head that way. If i'm the dons I offer to pay part of Jake's contract to make it easier for the hawks and convince him to go there.

 

[MightySaint]

Prefer to keep 5 & try for the hail mary of Carlisle in the PSD

Agreed. He isn't worth it at pick 5. If that is the trade we should pass to the PSD and hope.

 

[Defacto]

Hawks cap open for Carlisle capture
HAWTHORN would be prepared to restructure its player payments to fit in Jake Carlisle as Essendon stands firm on its trade demands.

let me guess the herald sun hahahaha

 

[Bomberboy2013]

I think it might head that way. If i'm the dons I offer to pay part of Jake's contract to make it easier for the hawks and convince him to go there.

Dont think we will pay a dime, Saints fans call for PSD that equals JC accepting the Hawks offer

 

[Defacto]

I think it might head that way. If i'm the dons I offer to pay part of Jake's contract to make it easier for the hawks and convince him to go there.

you cant do that. hawthorn will have to pay 100% of it

 

[Big Carl]

I think it might head that way. If i'm the dons I offer to pay part of Jake's contract to make it easier for the hawks and convince him to go there.

U can only pay part of the contract is he is CONTRACTED...FFS how hard is it to understand?

 

[RoundCubic]

I think it might head that way. If i'm the dons I offer to pay part of Jake's contract to make it easier for the hawks and convince him to go there.

can't do that for an out of contract player

 

[MightySaint]

U can only pay part of the contract is he is CONTRACTED...FFS how hard is it to understand?

Apologies, I haven't read all 589 pages. Why you mad anyway?

 

[Falchoon]

I think it might head that way. If i'm the dons I offer to pay part of Jake's contract to make it easier for the hawks and convince him to go there.

can only pay part of an existing contract

 

[Goats]

Can Essendon pay part of Carlisle's contract next year?

 

[Atavistic]

looks like the GC Port trade is dead in the water

latest is Sydney getting involved. would take something like
STK Lose: Pick 5, Pick 24
STK Gain: Carlisle, Pick 14
ESS Lose: Carlisle, Pick 25
ESS Gain: Pick 5
SYD Lose: Pick 14
SYD Gain: Pick 24 and 25

but sadly dodoro wont move on pick 25, so it looks like we get him for free in the PSD

He won't? Carlisle + whipping boy Melksham for pick 5 seems like a good outcome.