Traded Chris Yarran [to Richmond for Pick 19]

[dean33]

Fine then.

I think you underestimate the extent to which Carlton fans have had a guts full of seeing their exers star for other clubs.

A club simply cannot allow this to keep happening.... therefore a line must be drawn. I hope we do it with Yarran same as I hope Brissy do it with Aish.

If you don't get it you don't get it.

your "exers" as you put it star for other clubs because your club is a basketcase and once they get to another club even if its a club like melbourne they relish the new environment and thrive. what you are doing now is not going to stop players leaving you but just hinder you in the immediate to mid term future.

Good luck on your rebuild with 1 first round pick...

 

[hench]

Richmond fans insulting Carlton fans on Big Footy will not change what is happening with the Yarran trade.

 

[ajb72]

Dont worry we will move on. Then Yarran will sit out next year then we will get him in FA and you wont get anything.
Good start to the rebuild lmao.

I keep reading you and other RFC supporters going on about getting him for nothing in FA.

The problem with that is that he will be a restricted Free Agent. Hence if you offer him a low contract which will net CFC nothing in compensation, CFC should match the offer. Thus you will be required to trade or he goes PSD. Likelihood if he goes PSD is CFC will have an earlier pick than RFC. So even that scenario is not certain.

There really is no scenario where RFC get Yarran for nothing.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Dont worry we will move on.

Oh goodie.... bye bye then.

 

[This Is Anfield]

Phrase whatever question you have in form of a question & I might answer it.

I'll show some pity and attempt to teach you something:

That is not a question.

No need to thank me.

lol. Deflect all you like, the implied question was there even if the ? was missing.
You have no answers, just smartarse deflections.
There would be nothing of value that you could teach me.

 

[Tony Harrison]

Can't speak for Menz. Not sure what's going on there.

btw, is Hammer still on your list?

Yep.

Could ask you if 25+ shit players are still on your list.
Just had a glance, they still are

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Oh so you dont know how trades work. Ok then.

Jeez, you're just struggling now.

I think I have a pretty fair idea on what goes on.... don't worry.

 

[TiggerMan22]

I keep reading you and other RFC supporters going on about getting him for nothing in FA.

The problem with that is that he will be a restricted Free Agent. Hence if you offer him a low contract which will net CFC nothing in compensation, CFC should match the offer. Thus you will be required to trade or he goes PSD. Likelihood if he goes PSD is CFC will have an earlier pick than RFC. So even that scenario is not certain.

There really is no scenario where RFC get Yarran for nothing.

If Yarran sits out the year then you won't be matching his contract and you wont be picking him up in the PSD.

 

[dean33]

Can't speak for Menz. Not sure what's going on there.

btw, is Hammer still on your list?

yes is andy collins? or what about jacobs? josh kennedy? eddie betts? mitch robinson? garlett? have i missed anyone?

 

[TiggerMan22]

Jeez, you're just struggling now.

I think I have a pretty fair idea on what goes on.... don't worry.

Trades are not a one way deal bud. Its not a set price that everyone else has to reach.
Its a negotiation to reach common ground between both clubs.
You dont have a clue, stop thinking you do.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Yep.

Could ask you if 25+ shit players are still on your list.
Just had a glance, they still are

Don't get all uppity. It was a serious question.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

yes is andy collins? or what about jacobs? josh kennedy? eddie betts? mitch robinson? garlett? have i missed anyone?

So Sensitive.

 

[Ti22]

ROFLMAO Port has rejected pick #12 for Lobbe Richmond are just a bunch of tossers.

 

[Beer n Skittles]

lol. Deflect all you like, the implied question was there even if the ? was missing.
You have no answers, just smartarse deflections.
There would be nothing of value that you could teach me.

I saw no implied question, only a petty complaint. Here followed up by more petty complaints.

I have answered your supposed implied question in this thread already, when I was asked directly for my opinion by a more literate Tiger fan. I believe it's on the previous page if you want to go look

 

[Tiger71]

Can't speak for Menz. Not sure what's going on there.

btw, is Hammer still on your list?

yeah he is. Do you know how many are still on your list ? lol

 

[Haggard H]

WOW, that's a great dream you have there especially in this weakish draft.
What should CFC hope for with pick 20 & 21 then a Dangerfield and Boyd maybe?

If your recruiting record was any good then maybe.

Unfortunately though Carlton's last few picks around those numbers have been Boekhorst (19), Bootsma (22) and Watson (18).

Need to go back to 2006 to find a Blues' pick around 20 who is any good .... Shaun Grigg

 

[Tiger71]

ROFLMAO Port has rejected pick #12 for Lobbe Richmond are just a bunch of tossers.

God, you blokes are really stretching lol...link anything from richmond or port saying we have offered 12. C'mon I dare ya haha

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Trades are not a one way deal bud. Its not a set price that everyone else has to reach.
Its a negotiation to reach common ground between both clubs.
You dont have a clue, stop thinking you do.

So what are you gonna do, beg us? No, seriously, if you get down and bark like a dog for us, SOS might be disgusted enough to take 19 lol.

 

[dean33]

So Sensitive.

sensitive? just pointing out a fact that the shambles your club is. How many spoons this decade is it now? Back to back next year

 

[Tiger71]

So what are you gonna do, beg us? No, seriously, if you get down and bark like a dog for us, SOS might be disgusted enough to take 19 lol.

I have been reading your posts, god help me /sighs. You are strong, so strong with the simple minded message that the Blues can dictate the price due to Yarran being contracted, the only simple point, yet you miss it, is that the RFC is your ONLY customer.

 

[Love the Drake]

The problem is that since day 1 of the trade period Carlton believe he's worth a medium first round pick in a weak draft, whereas Richmond think he's worth a late first rounder. The issue is that neither team has budged.

Carlton will continue to refuse if the offer isn't what they want, because Yarran is contracted and can't go anywhere. I don't think many Carlton fans have an issue with Carlton taking a stance re yarran. His petulant behaviour and poor attitude/performances this year won him no fans. His insistence that he goes only to Richmond is his doing. If Richmond can't come up with a suitable deal then so be it. If he sits out, he sits out. The club will become stronger for it.

The thought of him spooking it up and sitting out for a year goes further to his 'reputation'.

 

[Danog]

Can't speak for Menz. Not sure what's going on there.

btw, is Hammer still on your list?

Played more games in past 2 years than Kreuzer the Kripple

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

sensitive? just pointing out a fact that the shambles your club is. How many spoons this decade is it now? Back to back next year

It might be if we don't start getting good trade value.

 

[dumb]

the invective coming from either supporter base is kind of alarming. not a lot of thinking with clear heads, am a bit disturbed by carlton posters happy to see the club get screwed just so richmond don't get what they want.

there's no rush.

 

[SexyBlueGirl]

Played more games in past 2 years than Kreuzer the Kripple

Oh my, you went there.