List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016

Matt_352 · May 10, 2016

matt_hillier said:
Don't right us off re Hibberd coming to the Pies. Could be more of a reality than you realise.

Watch this space

What do you know

gtrain23 · May 10, 2016

campbell023 said:
Think it would be easier to go after Hibberd, he will come a lot cheaper. I can't see Wilson moving, he just signed a deal to 2018 and he has a big family around him down there.

Can someone twll me who hibberd is?

Matt_352 · May 10, 2016

gtrain23 said:
Can someone twll me who hibberd is?

Essendon one I presume we talking about. North one still very raw

gtrain23 · May 10, 2016

Matt_352 said:
View attachment 245474

Essendon one I presume we talking about. North one still very raw

Yeh was assuming that just wanted to make sure.
Wouldn't be a bad pick up if true but these rumours never happen

Matt_352 · May 10, 2016

gtrain23 said:
Yeh was assuming that just wanted to make sure.
Wouldn't be a bad pick up if true but these rumours never happen

Not never

Dynamics · May 10, 2016

JOELY said:
And will probably not play again this year because of it.

Bargain!

Quicky · May 10, 2016

gtrain23 said:
Goldstein

How would you make it happen? He'd be close to untouchable you'd think.

Quicky · May 10, 2016

I was keen on the Hibberd idea until my brother (an Essendon supporter. Don't ask!) said his real knock is his ball use. That is something we don't need is an underwhelming ball user out of the back half. It surprised me because I never noticed it in the past, but I watch far less Essendon than he does.

SApies · May 10, 2016

Stoods said:
Jenkins has put contract talks on hold, interesting.

I think Saad would be a great fit in our list

Please no.

Ketchup · May 10, 2016

SApies said:
Please no.

I could see Jenkins coming to us. We have good track record of giving players big deals of the back one good season. Even more so in their contract year.

On a more Jenkins orientated side. Good on him. He's 27/8 been an average player at best his entire career. Good player management decision to put off contract talks this is his deal of a life time to set him up for the future.

TradeDraft · May 10, 2016

SApies said:
Please no.

Why Not he Looks bloody good at the Crows

Stoods · May 10, 2016

Ketchup said:
I could see Jenkins coming to us. We have good track record of giving players big deals of the back one good season. Even more so in their contract year.

On a more Jenkins orientated side. Good on him. He's 27/8 been an average player at best his entire career. Good player management decision to put off contract talks this is his deal of a life time to set him up for the future.

He has been pretty decent for a few years now.

2014: 40 goals from 20 games (average of 2 goals per game)
2015: 46 goals from 19 games (average of 2.4 goals per game)
2016: 23 goals from 7 games so far (average of 3.2 goals per game)

I reckon a 2-3 goal per game player would be handy. Would take the pressure of Moore and even possibly Cloke? He can also pinch hit in the ruck as well, imo if we got him we would definitely look at trading Witts.

Kappa · May 11, 2016

gtrain23 said:
Goldstein

Maybe we can snag Nic Natanui while we're at it...

Kappa · May 11, 2016

Stoods said:
He has been pretty decent for a few years now.

2014: 40 goals from 20 games (average of 2 goals per game)
2015: 46 goals from 19 games (average of 2.4 goals per game)
2016: 23 goals from 7 games so far (average of 3.2 goals per game)

I reckon a 2-3 goal per game player would be handy. Would take the pressure of Moore and even possibly Cloke? He can also pinch hit in the ruck as well, imo if we got him we would definitely look at trading Witts.

He's simply too old to fit in with our next premiership assault.

I wouldn't consider anyone over 25 unless we're getting an insanely good deal or they're dirt cheap and bring leadership

Matt_352 · May 11, 2016

Ruck/Tall Fwd Mix of Grundy, Cox, Moore, Jenkins would be reasonably solid imo.

Stoods · May 11, 2016

Kappa said:
He's simply too old to fit in with our next premiership assault.

I wouldn't consider anyone over 25 unless we're getting an insanely good deal or they're dirt cheap and bring leadership

that's the thing though, i believe we have a very good crop of young talent under 24 years old, i think its the top end talent that we don't have enough of, he is pushing on the age limit of what i would be happy with though, i'm not saying go out and recruit a few 29/30 year olds, id say 26-27 year olds would be good.

Matt_352 · May 11, 2016

Kappa said:
He's simply too old to fit in with our next premiership assault.

I wouldn't consider anyone over 25 unless we're getting an insanely good deal or they're dirt cheap and bring leadership

Stoods said:
that's the thing though, i believe we have a very good crop of young talent under 24 years old, i think its the top end talent that we don't have enough of, he is pushing on the age limit of what i would be happy with though, i'm not saying go out and recruit a few 29/30 year olds, id say 26-27 year olds would be good.

We should be targeting 21-24 year olds. But I think an exception could be made occasionally for a 25-26 year old certainly no older then 26.

Kappa · May 11, 2016

Stoods said:
that's the thing though, i believe we have a very good crop of young talent under 24 years old, i think its the top end talent that we don't have enough of, he is pushing on the age limit of what i would be happy with though, i'm not saying go out and recruit a few 29/30 year olds, id say 26-27 year olds would be good.

Most players careers are done at 30, it's very rare that players keep producing good football after 30... By the time Jenkins is winding up his career we will just be starting to push for top 4.. it's just a poor list fit.

Matt_352 · May 11, 2016

Kappa said:
Most players careers are done at 30, it's very rare that players keep producing good football after 30... By the time Jenkins is winding up his career we will just be starting to push for top 4.. it's just a poor list fit.

Shame he isn't a couple years younger

Matt_352 · May 11, 2016

Jake Lloyd anyone?

SApies · May 11, 2016

Ketchup said:
I could see Jenkins coming to us. We have good track record of giving players big deals of the back one good season. Even more so in their contract year.

On a more Jenkins orientated side. Good on him. He's 27/8 been an average player at best his entire career. Good player management decision to put off contract talks this is his deal of a life time to set him up for the future.

Yeah I have no problem with Jenkins himself, he's having a great year! Just not sure he's the right fit with us, at the moment anyway.
Thinking either Essendon or Freo if he doesn't stay put. Not sure why he wouldn't, Crows are well ahead of us, Freo and Bombers.

SApies · May 11, 2016

TradeDraft said:
Why Not he Looks bloody good at the Crows

Yeh hes playing great footy because Crows have the personnel to more the ball from defensive 50 to attacking 50 with basically 1 kick with Seedsman and Brodie Smith. He'd get Swamped ala Cloke with us.

mike123 · May 11, 2016

I wouldn't look at Jenkins, I think Cox, Cloke and Moore are a fine trio and we should just develop another tall forward.

TradeDraft · May 11, 2016

mike123 said:
I wouldn't look at Jenkins, I think Cox, Cloke and Moore are a fine trio and we should just develop another tall forward.

If we actually Pick a Tall

Matt_352 · May 11, 2016

TradeDraft said:
If we actually Pick a Tall

And Cloke gets back into form

Log In or Create New Account

List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Brownlow Medallist

Cancelled

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Cancelled

Post-Human

Norm Smith Medallist

Hall of Famer

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Norm Smith Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Hall of Famer

Brownlow Medallist

Brownlow Medallist

Club Legend

Club Legend

Cancelled

Post-Human

Brownlow Medallist

Similar threads