Opinion Sacrifice the AFL for a VFL Flag (poll added)?

[TradeDraft]

With 1 Game to go in the AFL vs Hawks. Which most Likely we get Smashed in.

Be no point bring Cloke up for 1 Games and that stops him playing VFL Finals.

Play Cox instead because he be just as good as Cloke and He does NOT Qualify for VFL Finals.

IF White gets a Holiday bring in Gault. Get better Option in Close for the VFL Game

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Nope but what shocks me more is the poll is 50-50.

 

[Mkcaptain]

I'd play Cloke in the seniors. Who knows if he'd even want to play VFL finals.

 

[left at home]

cloke will get the call up to replace darcy

 

[Greening Magic]

If Cloke's VFL eligibility is even a discussion at match committee we're stuffed.

 

[eddiebankbalance]

we can win this, cloke will do it

 

[CFC2010]

If Cloke's VFL eligibility is even a discussion at match committee we're stuffed.

You know he has been dropped three times this year?

 

[Greening Magic]

You know he has been dropped three times this year?

I doubt it was to qualify him for the VFL finals (which is what I was getting at).

 

[CFC2010]

I doubt it was to qualify him for the VFL finals (which is what I was getting at).

Sorry misunderstood....his time at the Pies is done no point playing him in the Seniors.

Play Cox next week we are going to get spanked anyway.

 

[TradeDraft]

I doubt it was to qualify him for the VFL finals (which is what I was getting at).

Williams played 5 Minutes in the VFL on Saturday so he Qualified for VFL Finals

 

[TradeDraft]

Sorry misunderstood....his time at the Pies is done no point playing him in the Seniors.

Play Cox next week we are going to get spanked anyway.

Agree. Cloke is Gone. So Play Cox ahead of him is the Obvious reason.

Cloke was not even named in the Best and I have seen him play better in the VFL

 

[Greening Magic]

Williams played 5 Minutes in the VFL on Saturday so he Qualified for VFL Finals

Or was that because they found out Goldsack was a withdrawal for Sat night so pulled Williams off?
Genuine question.

 

[PicaBoo]

Williams played 5 Minutes in the VFL on Saturday so he Qualified for VFL Finals

Should do the same with Cloke . Name him in the VFL squad, pull him out after 5 minute.

 

[TradeDraft]

Should do the same with Cloke . Name him in the VFL squad, pull him out after 5 minute.

But IF Cloke plays AFL he has played too many AFL Gamers to Qualify for the VFL Finals

 

[TradeDraft]

Or was that because they found out Goldsack was a withdrawal for Sat night so pulled Williams off?
Genuine question.

Well Goldsack was at the VFL. So I doubt he did a Fitness Test there

 

[Maggie5]

Or was that because they found out Goldsack was a withdrawal for Sat night so pulled Williams off?
Genuine question.

Think I read that they played him for 5 mins to qualify him for the VFL and was then taken off due to Goldsack's illness as he would be needed for the seniors.

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Yes I know some might not like this View.

With only 2 games in the AFL Season to go. I would keep Cloke in the VFL so he can Play Finals and Maybe bring a few back to make sure we finish top 2 and get a Home QF.

Your Thoughts?

Hell no. The AFL is what matters. I care a lot more about him getting a farewell game (given that there is a spot that he is the best candidate to fill) than the VFL team.

 

[iGNITER]

Play him in the AFL.
Darcy out, Cloke is the perfect replacement.

 

[PicaBoo]

Well Goldsack was at the VFL. So I doubt he did a Fitness Test there

Totally forgot it is either one of them. Hmmm. I still say VFL. Rather have him delivering the VFL cup rather then trying to knock off Hawthorn with a depleted team.

 

[Greening Magic]

If they play Trav in the 2's purely to qualify for the finals it sends an awful message to the 22 that will run out against the Hawks.
What would an Adam Treloar think if they sent out a team they considered sub standard for him to play alongside.
Why bust your arse if they are more concerned with the VFL?
The clubs responsibility is to field what they consider the teams best 22 each week.

Off the top of your head, who won the 1999 VFL GF? Answer: Who f*&%ing cares (unless your a relative ).

 

[TradeDraft]

Hell no. The AFL is what matters. I care a lot more about him getting a farewell game (given that there is a spot that he is the best candidate to fill) than the VFL team.

Cloke Leaving is at this Moment not a 100% Sure thing.

Want a Farewell game. Then play Caff

 

[TradeDraft]

Totally forgot it is either one of them. Hmmm. I still say VFL. Rather have him delivering the VFL cup rather then trying to knock off Hawthorn with a depleted team.

Hawks will Thumps us With or Without Cloke

 

[TradeDraft]

If they play Trav in the 2's purely to qualify for the finals it sends an awful message to the 22 that will run out against the Hawks.
What would an Adam Treloar think if they sent out a team they considered sub standard for him to play alongside.
Why bust your arse if they are more concerned with the VFL?
The clubs responsibility is to field what they consider the teams best 22 each week.

Off the top of your head, who won the 1999 VFL GF? Answer: Who f*&%ing cares (unless your a relative ).

I hope the Players in the VFL Don't think you don't give a Flying F**k about them

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Cloke Leaving is at this Moment not a 100% Sure thing.

Want a Farewell game. Then play Caff

No, but its a 90% thing, so that's good enough for me.

 

[Greening Magic]

Think I read that they played him for 5 mins to qualify him for the VFL and was then taken off due to Goldsack's illness as he would be needed for the seniors.

OK thanks, what they didn't do was keep him out of the AFL purely to bolster the VFL. If they had of replaced Sack with Tim Golds so Marley wasn't ineligible then I'd have a problem.