- Joined
- Aug 30, 2007
- Posts
- 9,004
- Reaction score
- 6,156
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Warney's IPL team!
Calling bullshit on this
On what part....?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

Calling bullshit on this
1. That there is no room for themOn what part....?
You seem to be conflating two things. Of course if he is eating too many calories he won't lose fat, but that doesn't mean there is no room for milk, cheese etc. I guess I better go and tell my pre weight loss/muscle gain self that, obviously I'm never going to get anywhere1. His previous post stated he is struggling to lose a bit of far around the belly, that would suggest is lean and if he isn't losing to weight needs to reduce calories slightly. Of course you can eat those foods, eat any food you like but don't scratch your head thinking why you can't lose weight.
2. Have a look at reduced fat processed foods like yoghurt, milk, cheeses. Compare the reduced fat vs non reduced fat options and the sugar levels are 2-3 times more per serve.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
You seem to be conflating two things. Of course if he is eating too many calories he won't lose fat, but that doesn't mean there is no room for milk, cheese etc. I guess I better go and tell my pre weight loss/muscle gain self that, obviously I'm never going to get anywhere
It completely depends on the food actually
This is a lot of the problem with nutrition advice these days. People try to make blanket statement rules.
This is different to your first post. I wouldn't have disagreed if you'd said this. I took issue with the blanket statement:I completely agree, the thing is what works for me and what works you could be completely different or the same. I don't have any issues with milk, cheese etc. more so with mayo, I may have been nit picking but the poster did say he was having trouble losing that last little bit of weight. A spoon or two of mayo would be the first thing to give up to save room for meat, veggies rice etx. And of course all depends on how much and how often.
All I'm saying from past experience with losing weight, getting the last bit of weight off takes effort and sacrifice. Quite often people doesn't realise how much extra food they are eating that hinders their progress.
If you really want to get rid of that pot belly you don't have room for these type of foods in your diet full stop. Don't opt for reduced fat foods they are full of sugar.
This is different to your first post. I wouldn't have disagreed if you'd said this. I took issue with the blanket statement:
And if reduced fat helps him cut his calories down and leave him less hungry/with less cravings, it's a very useful tool. It needs sustainability
I didn't get it out of the context because of the "no room in your diet full stop". That's why I disagreed with the post.Yeah fair point, should of elaborated some more. But it was on context of my previous reply to him.
Yeah, that's a whole other debate of IIFYM vs. clean eating. Once again, find something that works for you and stick with it. Personally I'm a foot in both camps, steer clean of reduced fat foods, sugars make me hungrier but the full fat foods take away hunger.
I didn't get it out of the context because of the "no room in your diet full stop". That's why I disagreed with the post.
I don't think it has to be a debate between the two. It can be either depending on the person (I wish people in the industry would understand this). I've done both. Got results from both. But found one more enjoyable and sustainable.
Some people crave sugar, some crave fat. If eating a certain thing can be incorporated and reduce those cravings it's much more beneficial
Sure there's obviously a difference, but again doesn't mean there's no room. If that was the case no dedicated trainer would use IIFYM, half my footy club/the club my missus knows at drink/eat bad food at times and are very lean.I will say there is difference between being over weight and trying to lose weight, practailly any restriction in diet will bring results. But trying to lose weight when you are already lean takes more sacrifice hence my "no room full stop" comment.
Sure there's obviously a difference, but again doesn't mean there's no room. If that was the case no dedicated trainer would use IIFYM, half my footy club/the club my missus knows at drink/eat bad food at times and are very lean.
I'm back on IIFYM now and I'm leaner than I have been.
Sorry. It's one of my biggest hates when people make blanket fitness and nutrition statementsGood stuff ...and go Dees!!!
Link?Doing friday as a carb loading day before footy. Tried it for the first time last week (used the swan districts one as a template)
Played the best game of my life, and recovery was almost instant post game. Definitely sticking to that
Was somewhere back in the thread. Don't have it once. Just search swan district in this threadLink?
Wtf is IIFYM?
Currently experimenting with some pretty low calories ~1500 in keto mode
Want to see the effect on
>Weight loss
>Mood
>Brain function
>Cardio vascular performance
>Anaerobic performance
Only 4 days in so haven't had one yet, but usually i do one every 7-10 days depending on how I'm feelingAre you refeeding?
Currently experimenting with some pretty low calories ~1500 in keto mode
Want to see the effect on
>Weight loss
>Mood
>Brain function
>Cardio vascular performance
>Anaerobic performance
Good luck - I think 1500 calories would kill me!Currently experimenting with some pretty low calories ~1500 in keto mode
Want to see the effect on
>Weight loss
>Mood
>Brain function
>Cardio vascular performance
>Anaerobic performance
Why so low?......just out of interest
Good luck - I think 1500 calories would kill me!
My maintenance (estimated) is around 3,100 and I've become a classic hard-gainer over the past few months.
Keep us updated, hope it works for you.

depends on the player, their training and what their goals are...and then different nutritionists/sports science guys will have different approaches to achieving the same thing.Does anyone know what a typical diet of an afl player would like during preseason I understand they vary quite a bit
