- Jun 14, 2010
- 15,265
- 11,505
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
- Other Teams
- Denver, Liverpool
How? Traded massive massive overs for hill. Lost steven for nothing. They were both awful trades.
That’s why you don’t look at single trades children. Derp
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
How? Traded massive massive overs for hill. Lost steven for nothing. They were both awful trades.
Geelong or honestly - Freo. Both improved their draft position in ordinary situations and added depth on the cheap. We did well, but it was an inevitability.
St Kilda has real shades of Port Adelaide in 2017 but arguably lost more. Looking forward to a similar dynasty.
St Kilda 2019:
- Hill
- Jones
- Howard
- Ryder
- Butler
Port Adelaide 2017:
- Rockliff
- Motlop
- Watts
- Lindsay Thomas
Camt see how the other trades would more from make up for those horrendous ones.That’s why you don’t look at single trades children. Derp
Jones and butler are very average players. Ryder 32 at start of next season. Hill is great at times but not consistent and never finds much ball. Paid way way to much for him. Howard is uncertain. And you lost some decent players.Please tell me your are trolling lol.
Watts isn’t an afl footballer.
Lindsay was about 35 years old.
Rockliff slow and washed up.
Motlop soft as butter.
Compare them to:
Hill one of the best wingman in the league.
Jones, only 24 years old.
Butler, only 23 years old. Premiership player.
Howard, rated by some as a future AA. Most port fans were ropable losing him.
Ryder. Old, but good mentor for Marshall and can rotate Ruck/FWD
If there was a loser for worst post in this thread, you take it out hands down.
Your getting carried away a little I watched howard at SANFL level as I did Frampton they were on a par, sorry to say not that great and we got FramptonPlease tell me your are trolling lol.
Watts isn’t an afl footballer.
Lindsay was about 35 years old.
Rockliff slow and washed up.
Motlop soft as butter.
Compare them to:
Hill one of the best wingman in the league.
Jones, only 24 years old.
Butler, only 23 years old. Premiership player.
Howard, rated by some as a future AA. Most port fans were ropable losing him.
Ryder. Old, but good mentor for Marshall and can rotate Ruck/FWD
If there was a loser for worst post in this thread, you take it out hands down.
Marty is really hurting over dangerfield. Its like 4 years ago. Let it go.West coast clearly the out and out winners brought in a player that could realistically win them get a flag, but on the opposite side a team lost a player that could have helped them win a flag
There are your winners and losers in a nutshell
On SM-G965F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Jenkins was terrible he was getting beaten by weekend warriors in the SANFL most if the year he was drop back there 2 or 3 times before he spat the chewy and decided not to playThey gave up a second round pick for a bloke who couldn't get a game in a team that finished 11th, played the last month in the SANFL, and who apparently no other club was chasing. I reckon they overpaid.
Good on yaMarty is really hurting over dangerfield. Its like 4 years ago. Let it go.
Geelong got far more for kelly then you thought was fair. So we won that trade in your eyes. You just wont admit it. Cos you know. You pine for danger. Him leaving ruined your childhood.
How was the crows trading. Lost 6 players. Brought in no one. Your club is literally at civil war with each other. There will be a movie aboit the crows self implosion since 2017. I will bring popcorn.
Camt see how the other trades would more from make up for those horrendous ones.
People are only rating saints by the players they got with no considerstion with the players these lost nor the draft picks.
We have 4 picks ahead of 37. Dont pine for 37 and our 37 was exchanged for a pick that will probably be around 37 next year given it will come in due to academy picks. The trade was essentially josh jenkins and next years pick 37 for pick 37 this year.it's about quality, not quantity.
We lose our 2nd best player and gain two old players who will be in and out of the starting line up over the remaining 2-3 years of their careers.
If we turn just one of the draft picks into a potential 200 game player then we may get a pass in years to come.
Turn two of them into long term players, it's a win.
Odds are, we end up losing out in this draft given how good Kelly is and the potential of our pick 37 turning into a player.
You lost a pick 6 and brought in no players remotely worth a pick 6.View attachment 766458
Bruce was the only considerable loss, but King needs to play so he’s expandable. Acres hasn’t done much in 6 years at the club. Steven May never play, did you watch the farewell video he did? The bloke is struggling hard.
Got 4 best 22 player into the club (Butler the only iffy one), gave away 1 DECENT pick in Pick 6 then a lot of junk picks.
You just have to laugh, posters were saying ‘no chance you Can get all these players in with little to trade’, and we did, now everyone saying ‘Well they’re not that great’ lol funny
Jones and Butler very average yet Acres, Steven and Bruce (the only one out of the 3 I would call decent) are ‘DECENT’Jones and butler are very average players. Ryder 32 at start of next season. Hill is great at times but not consistent and never finds much ball. Paid way way to much for him. Howard is uncertain. And you lost some decent players.
When you are talking up butler you are in trouble. Youve bought in a bunch of c grade players and one b plus player. Why? You arent a flag threat. It seems really stupid. Should of gone to the draft.Jones and Butler very average yet Acres, Steven and Bruce (the only one out of the 3 I would call decent) are ‘DECENT’
Jones > Acres
Butler > Steven right now
Fair callHawks went in looking for a key forward and a key defender and came out with a key forward and a key defender and all our picks.
Pittonet is a loss for us and gain for Carlton. Carlton will again have to rely on an ageing list (look at the top 5 in their B and F).
Freo have big shoes to fill but plenty of draft picks. So too Geelong.
Saints and West Coast paid up big but got their targets so will be happy.
Melbourne and Adelaide and Port and Sydney didnt do anything to suggest they will rise.
GWS offloaded salary cap but will again struggle with ruck and small forwards.
Richmond were in party mode so there is only some nude pics of dusty being traded.
You lost a pick 6 and brought in no players remotely worth a pick 6.
When you are talking up butler you are in trouble. Youve bought in a bunch of c grade players and one b plus player. Why? You arent a flag threat. It seems really stupid. Should of gone to the draft.
Yeah the average ones.Did you miss the part where most of our recruits are under 25 years old?
Geelong aren’t a flag threat either champ but bring in 30+ Rejects, good stuff
Well you did take jerka but I do Thank you for thatYeah the average ones.
We took him for nothing. Jerka better than rohan. Geelong is actually still competing for a flag.
it's about quality, not quantity.
We lose our 2nd best player and gain two old players who will be in and out of the starting line up over the remaining 2-3 years of their careers.
If we turn just one of the draft picks into a potential 200 game player then we may get a pass in years to come.
Turn two of them into long term players, it's a win.
Odds are, we end up losing out in this draft given how good Kelly is and the potential of our pick 37 turning into a player.
this is freo we are talking about here....I think Freo won, made the most of an elite talent leaving, gotten two decent players in Aish and Acres, and have three future second rounders to use in live trading this coming draft in case they need to. With us trading ourselves out of this years draft, Freo will have the pick of the WA talent and will get what they want using the picks they received.
Geelong like above made the most of a quality player, they'd have hoped to have traded up using the picks they received however there is still the live pick period for them to do so.
Hawks up there to, like every year they get quality for cheap. Frost will be a great get however I'm not entirely sold on Patton, multiple knee recos however if it works out it would be one of the all time steals.
You called it not meWe took him for nothing. Jerka better than rohan. Geelong is actually still competing for a flag.
Out of our prelim side: tim kelly and 4 hacks,
In: hawkins, duncan, clark, cocky, steven with jenkins as backup if hawkins hits someone again in the semi.
Yep. Flag threat. Crows: bottom 4 (your words not mine)