Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Would you still choose the first option if the midfielder was someone else other than Gaff? Could be any 580k and lower mid.

That's a hard price range, I'm struggling with my M3 with a similiar budget. Really need to find another 30-40K to get the Bont.

Cripps if you don't have him is the best under 570K imo. Andy Brayshaw next best for me.

 

[Lord De Goey]

That's a hard price range, I'm struggling with my M3 with a similiar budget. Really need to find another 30-40K to get the Bont.

Cripps if you don't have him is the best under 570K imo. Andy Brayshaw next best for me.

Already have Cripps and Brayshaw

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Already have Cripps and Brayshaw

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Butters vs Duggan?

 

[Flandersss]

Butters vs Duggan?

Butters

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Butters vs Duggan?

I like both

 

[ForeverHardcore]

I like both

Currently have both but have a Lloyd Neale option and would lose 1 of the 2

Butters

Yeah my thinking to
Best way to put it is I think butters will be closer to a top 6 forward then Duggan will be to a top 6 defender

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Quite a few trades here and to hard to explain so I have just put up team A & B. The defence is the same so I have left it out only Midfield and Forwards change. In team "A" Scott on the bench should become Waterman


A




B

 

[ForeverHardcore]

Quite a few trades here and to hard to explain so I have just put up team A & B. The defence is the same so I have left it out only Midfield and Forwards change. In team "A" Scott on the bench should become Waterman


A

View attachment 1067706


B


View attachment 1067707

Both look good
A
9 keepers 5 mid pricers

B
8 keepers 6 mid pricers

Think it will come down to where the rookies are. I personally like B I’m looking at a similar set up with green/Heppell

 

[Hawkboy62]

Duggan vs Williams
Taranto vs Butters

 

[Red Syrah]

SC - Cripps
Fantasy - Walsh

Have Cripps

Battle of the 500/550 club:
Rank for highest avg
Walsh v Brayshaw v Simpkin v Rowell

 

[Flandersss]

Duggan vs Williams
Taranto vs Butters

Williams
Taranto

 

[Lord De Goey]

Duggan vs Williams
Taranto vs Butters

Duggan
Taranto outscores Butters but Butters will rank better in the forwards compared to Taranto in the Mids

Have Cripps

Battle of the 500/550 club:
Rank for highest avg
Walsh v Brayshaw v Simpkin v Rowell

Brayshaw v Walsh v Simpkin v Rowell

 

[Significant]

Quite a few trades here and to hard to explain so I have just put up team A & B. The defence is the same so I have left it out only Midfield and Forwards change. In team "A" Scott on the bench should become Waterman


A

View attachment 1067706


B


View attachment 1067707

Just out of interest, what's your defence look like?

 

[A Bit Dusty]

Just out of interest, what's your defence look like?

Lloyd/Laird/Williams/Duggan/Harmes/Cox Bench Highmore/Chugg

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Butters vs Duggan?

I have both .....one is a future Brownlow Medalist according to Cornes .....and he's never wrong

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Williams
Taranto

Taranto .....resiliance

Williams ....hindenburg

 

[Flandersss]

Taranto .....resiliance

Williams ....hindenburg

Oh the calamity!

 

[Judd_Magic]

Dangerfield or Mitchell?

 

[Raveneyes]

Dangerfield or Mitchell?

Danger. Titch racing to be fit for round 1.

 

[stevebbb]

Dangerfield or Mitchell?

Starting a player with a limited preseason is always a no for me. Titch above $600k, he even struggled a bit last year. Rather wait and see.

Danger looked god-tier around the stoppages against my Pies the other day, think he'll be racking up clearances, kicks inside 50 and assists this year.

 

[Max the great]

Who for F1 and F2

Dangerfield and Dusty
v
Sidebottom and Dunkley

Dusty and Dunkley

 

[stevebbb]

I'm really Torn on this one.

Matthew Rowell M4 or Sam Docherty D3

Right now it's Docherty.
Need Rowell to show something in the preseason matches, he was very rusty the other day. He's still only very young and has only played a handful of games. Even if he goes nuts in 2021, I'll happily skip him this year, hope he plays every game, then pick him up next year (and every year after that) as a god-tier premo mid.

Stewart and Taranto or Williams and Gaff

Hard choice.
Stewart and Taranto

Callum Mills vs Caleb Daniel

pls

Similar floors, but Mills probably has a higher ceiling. Mills for me

Butters vs Duggan?

Butters

Duggan vs Williams
Taranto vs Butters

Taranto and Butters

 

[Judd_Magic]

Danger. Titch racing to be fit for round 1.

Starting a player with a limited preseason is always a no for me. Titch above $600k, he even struggled a bit last year. Rather wait and see.

Danger looked god-tier around the stoppages against my Pies the other day, think he'll be racking up clearances, kicks inside 50 and assists this year.

Cheers guys, my way of thinking too.

Just still hearing people who might be picking Mitchell if he lines up round 1 which had me wondering.

I hear he might play a VFL practice match this week and he is coming off shoulder surgery so maybe best to wait.

 

[Raveneyes]

Cheers guys, my way of thinking too.

Just still hearing people who might be picking Mitchell if he lines up round 1 which had me wondering.

I hear he might play a VFL practice match this week and he is coming off shoulder surgery so maybe best to wait.

I definitely want Titch. But he'll be an upgrade target for me. Doubt we will have to spend more than $40k-$50k more than his starting price.