Analysis Who will be better in 2025? Carlton or Hawthorn?

[Crankyhawk]

I'm jealous that Hawthorn has an all time generational death ride this season. More satisfying than a flag it would be.

While fun it’s not even the most beneficial death ride (tigers have norths first I think for an early 2nd last year)

 

[Elixuh]

While fun it’s not even the most beneficial death ride (tigers have norths first I think for an early 2nd last year)

North were expected to be like this. Whereas you get to death ride another all time Carlton capitulation. Its not about the benefit in draft capital its about how much the capitulation warms your heart.

 

[hawkman]

While fun it’s not even the most beneficial death ride (tigers have norths first I think for an early 2nd last year)

North are only 1.5 games behind Carlton and improving. They could actually pass Carlton by the end of the season

 

[threesixpio]

So the Will Day-less midfield got spanked... Mackenzie and Ward pretty invisible for most of the game too.

I'm taking Carltons midfield regardless of whether the rest of our team is a dogs breakfast atm. Far more depth in that area of the field.

 

[threesixpio]

If think it's time to close this thread and do the humane thing and put Blues fans out of their misery

View attachment 2348152

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Hok Tua

 

[matey]

With Day, Siss, Scrim, Dear, Lewis, Worps out you would think that the Hawks depth is better than the Blues ……. and keep an eye on a kid playing BH with the initials NM!

 

[SSSSSS]

North were expected to be like this. Whereas you get to death ride another all time Carlton capitulation. Its not about the benefit in draft capital its about how much the capitulation warms your heart.

It's even better because we get Eagles melts as well.

Took our future picks instead of Carlton's for TB.

The rare double melt.

 

[Bugs1977]

It's even better because we get Eagles melts as well.

Took our future picks instead of Carlton's for TB.

The rare double melt.

The best part about West Coast's Hawks Death Ride thread is that early on they were all getting upset because we were all over there communicating with them (most of us civilly) and they proceeded to drop their bundle and told us to nick off and locked the thread.

Then as soon as we lost a couple of games they re-opened the thread and started making comments like where are all the Hawks posters now. You just know if you make any comments now they will once again kick up a stink and throw out toys from the cot.

The delusional mofos over there think the only reason why Hawks aren't bottom 6 is because the umps favour us.

 

[Crankyhawk]

The best part about West Coast's Hawks Death Ride thread is that early on they were all getting upset because we were all over there communicating with them (most of us civilly) and they proceeded to drop their bundle and told us to nick off and locked the thread.

Then as soon as we lost a couple of games they re-opened the thread and started making comments like where are all the Hawks posters now. You just know if you make any comments now they will once again kick up a stink and throw out toys from the cot.

The delusional mofos over there think the only reason why Hawks aren't bottom 6 is because the umps favour us.

Tbf there were a few less than civil troll types from hawks. The fun was reading it without commenting

 

[hawkman]

Tbf there were a few less than civil troll types from hawks. The fun was reading it without commenting

Yep. Hawk posters rubbing it in was less fun than watching them wallow in self pity and misery

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

Carlton could play no one and still somehow lose.

 

[HairyO]

Carlton could play no one and still somehow lose.

With a full list theyd be a chance for a draw.

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

With a full list theyd be a chance for a draw.

Lol.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Carlton could play no one and still somehow lose.

Will they win another game this year?

Saints? Dees? That might be about it.

 

[Crankyhawk]

Will they win another game this year?

Saints? Dees? That might be about it.

Don't think they have the saints. THey have Essendon, Port in Melbourne and Melbourne I have as possible wins

 

[PowerfulPies2023]

Will they win another game this year?

Saints? Dees? That might be about it.

Haven't seen their schedule mate. They'll sneak in a couple.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Don't think they have the saints. THey have Essendon, Port in Melbourne and Melbourne I have as possible wins

Ahh yes, Port, Dees, Bombers. They are all 50/50 games I reckon.

 

[Bugs1977]

Ahh yes, Port, Dees, Bombers. They are all 50/50 games I reckon.

The only real reason why they'll be a chance in any of those games will be if Port, Dees or Bombers decide to tank. Depending on the TDK situation the Blues don't have a reason to tank. If TDK flags his intentions to leave then I suppose there's a chance to tank.

 

[Dewyyyyy]

The best part about West Coast's Hawks Death Ride thread is that early on they were all getting upset because we were all over there communicating with them (most of us civilly) and they proceeded to drop their bundle and told us to nick off and locked the thread.

Then as soon as we lost a couple of games they re-opened the thread and started making comments like where are all the Hawks posters now. You just know if you make any comments now they will once again kick up a stink and throw out toys from the cot.

The delusional mofos over there think the only reason why Hawks aren't bottom 6 is because the umps favour us.

They said hawks fans were hiding but complained when any hawks fan replied or reacted, despite often being civil. I got thread banned for nothing

 

[Delisted]

They said hawks fans were hiding but complained when any hawks fan replied or reacted, despite often being civil. I got thread banned for nothing

I haven’t seen it yet. I may have to give it a read. Sounds delightful

 

[Gavin Excell]

Ahh yes, Port, Dees, Bombers. They are all 50/50 games I reckon.

If Hawks make the 4 who would your preferred match up be wk1 finals

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

They said hawks fans were hiding but complained when any hawks fan replied or reacted, despite often being civil. I got thread banned for nothing

First rule of posting on an opposition club board: don’t be amazed that no one gives a **** about your opinion.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

If Hawks make the 4 who would your preferred match up be wk1 finals

I don’t really have one.

 

[Crankyhawk]

If Hawks make the 4 who would your preferred match up be wk1 finals

A non travel option if we are 3rd or 4th (either cats or pies, hopefully they finish 1-2)