Who will be better in 2025? Hawthorn or Collingwood?

[Strapping Young Lad]

Has Finn received coaches votes in any other game than the one he kept a second year player quiet, whilst only getting 6 possessions himself?

That day screwed with McRae and Collingwood so much that they..... went on to win the premiership.

Does it even matter whether he even got coaches votes other games?

He’s a depth player. A depth player that put “the best player in the comp” in his pocket and subsequently mind****ed McRae 12 months later with the mere prospect of his possible inclusion.

 

[Fadge]

Does it even matter whether he even got coaches votes other games?

He’s a depth player. A depth player that put “the best player in the comp” in his pocket and subsequently mind****ed McRae 12 months later with the mere prospect of his possible inclusion.

And as I said, in the meantime his team won a premiership.

On that basis, can Mitchell and Hawthorn 'mind****' McRae and Collingwood more regularly?

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

And as I said, in the meantime his team won a premiership.

On that basis, can Mitchell and Hawthorn 'mind****' McRae and Collingwood more regularly?

Not in 2024 they didn’t. Got smacked, in fact.

Finn didn’t even have to tag.

 

[Fadge]

Not in 2024 they didn’t. Got smacked, in fact.

Finn didn’t even have to tag.

Yeah, it's a shame we can't win the flag every year...

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Yeah, it's a shame we can't win the flag every year.

Only the best clubs can back it up.

 

[Nugett]

Finn Maguinness received coaches votes for his role on a 20 year old Nick Daicos in his second season.

How many possessions did Finn have that day?

1 more than St. Nick.

 

[Fadge]

1 more than St. Nick.

What a magnificent achievement for the best game of his career.

6 possessions from 83% game time, and 2 coaches votes.

 

[Nugett]

What a magnificent achievement for the best game of his career.

6 possessions from 83% game time, and 2 coaches votes.

It was a fine achievement, his side won

 

[Fadge]

It was a fine achievement, his side won

Whilst Collingwood won the flag.

 

[Nugett]

Whilst Collingwood won the flag.

That they did, albeit by a dubious play on call, but win they did.

 

[Robertio]

Hawks will finish higher, the Old Pies started their slide down the ladder last season and it won't get any better for them this season,

 

[Crankyhawk]

Hawks fans joining Blues fans in their delusion now are they.

No we are deathriding the blues all the way this year

 

[LoungeLizard]

If both teams make the 8 and have to play each other in a final, I home to christ it's not an elimination or GF.

 

[Fadge]

If both teams make the 8 and have to play each other in a final, I home to christ it's not an elimination or GF.

Hawthorn are the Pies kryptonite.

There are 16 other teams I'd rather face in a final than those campaigners.

 

[Fadge]

Hawks and Pies, together with GWS and Brisbane, will be the top 4 teams in 2025.

Any order.

 

[Worm4]

Hawks and Pies, together with GWS and Brisbane, will be the top 4 teams in 2025.

Any order.

Give you 50/1. Load up

 

[peetoo]

Hawthorn are the Pies kryptonite.

There are 16 other teams I'd rather face in a final than those campaigners.

Isn’t it pies 1 hawks 0 in finals hth

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Isn’t it pies 1 hawks 0 in finals hth

Hawks 3
Pies 2

Incredible how these teams have somehow avoided each other in finals

On SM-A225F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Fadge]

Isn’t it pies 1 hawks 0 in finals hth

That must have happened a long, long time ago...

Oops - 2011, of course. I can't recall any finals prior to that in my living memory...

 

[LoungeLizard]

That must have happened a long, long time ago...

2011 I think we beat them by 3 points, Buddy ran nearly the length of the ground to put the Hawks in front, then Ball kicked his longest kick ever, 20 metres to win the game.

 

[Blackhawk42]

Hawks and Pies, together with GWS and Brisbane, will be the top 4 teams in 2025.

Any order.

The Giants depth worries me now. For the first time ever in their existence.

Also have Brisbane missing the top 4 due to 1. Common post-premiership complacency, and 2. No natural replacement for Daniher.

Collingwood sit in that 7th-11th range for me personally, mostly because it's quite hard to gauge exactly how an old list/team will fare heading into any season.
Geelong bucked the trend and won a premiership.
Hawthorn completely stagnated then plummeted.

 

[WilloTree]

Oh it has to be Hawks and Hok ball.

Everthing we're hearing is top 2 and Premiership is thiers to lose.

Good luck to them. I've liked the Hawks ever since they got Bucky out of Subi.

 

[hawkman]

Isn’t it pies 1 hawks 0 in finals hth

It is Richmond 1 Hawthorn 0

We've played Collingwood a few times in the 70's and twice in the 10's

 

[Freomaniac]

Both will miss the 8 so don’t think it really matters.

I can see both clubs miss out on finals but that is about tightness of the ladder

 

[peetoo]

I can see both clubs miss out on finals but that is about tightness of the ladder

Indeed only 4pts 116% separated them in 2024. With carlton in between. Just made it in