Banter FOOTY Banter! - Who will be better in 2026? Carlton or Collingwood Part 8

[carlton_99]

Indeed.

So what are you arguing again?

That Hayward was a top 10 player at the Swans?
That Hayward has been a better player than Skunk?
That Hewett is better than Daicos?

#Carlologic

Like I said before to your mate reading a post before replying often helps with the confusion

 

[Andrewgtv05]

That Hewett is better than Daicos?

#Carlologic

As a Carlton fan you'd think Nick Daicos has superpowers to be better then anyone

 

[Fadge]

Haha the fact you are still defending this argument is hilarious

Who's defending an argument?

All I'm doing is assisting the lowest common denominator of BigFooty posters in terms of intelligence.

You might thank me one day.

 

[doppleganger]

Like I said before to your mate reading a post before replying often helps with the confusion

So you decided to pop in and use #Carlologic to argue ridiculous nonsense about stuff you don't even believe...to prove that #Carlologic is hopelessly flawed.

Well done

 

[Fadge]

Why did Carlton take him pick 1 rather than a skillful player like Rozee or Rankin? I think they might actually like losing.

Zac Butters also in the same draft.

Oh boy.

 

[LoungeLizard]

I know what would work.
WalshintheHaywardvicinity.

 

[carlton_99]

So you decided to pop in and use #Carlologic to argue ridiculous nonsense about stuff you don't even believe...to prove that #Carlologic is hopelessly flawed.

Well done

I didn't argue anything lol. Was just exposing how flawed your BnF logic has been.

 

[jezzajay]

Name calling.

Then stop doing it.. simple.

 

[CarmenSandiego]

Poor Shizen fan.

The off-season is made up of trade, free agency and drafts and the idea is to make your list stronger to compete.

Poor Blueshizen fans just accept they have become a development club these days.

Carlton bring in some 18 yr olds, and then when they enter their prime they leave to go play for the clubs who are trying to win flags.

So did Collingwood use the trade and draft period to make their list stronger, or younger? Which is it?

Please tell me it’s both, I need another laugh after Fadgeys Buller is a better player than Hayward howler.

 

[sr36]

I know what would work.
WalshintheHaywardvicinity.

I'm thinking a weekly name change depending on the opponent:

WalshToMoore
WalshToAndrews
WalshToStewart

 

[jezzajay]

Huh?
That's not what I asked.
There's lots of scenarios that could happen, you could get better and fall down the ladder, you could stay the same position and be a better team, you could be worse and rise because other teams turn to crap.

But what I asked is, do you need Collingwood to go backward for Carlton to go pass them, if Collingwood sayed the same could Carlton pass them?

“Sayed”
Haha…so it’s not just your comprehension that’s an issue…

 

[Worm4]

If Curnow went to Geelong where do you think Heyward would be playing? God you make up some dumb shit.

Im still waiting on his explanation of TDK being elite . Just makes up stuff on a whim in his posts.

 

[Fadge]

So you decided to pop in and use #Carlologic to argue ridiculous nonsense about stuff you don't even believe...to prove that #Carlologic is hopelessly flawed.

Well done

It really is quite pathetic.

The entire premise of their argument is that if you use the argument that Harris Andrews, who plays for the premiers Brisbane and finished 2nd in their B&F, had a better season than Nick Haynes, who plays for 11th placed Carlton and finished 4th in their B&F, you must also subscribe to the theory that the B&F from the wooden spooners West Coast, Liam Baker, had a better year than the runner up in 4th placed Collingwood's B&F, Nick Daicos.

Simple and pathetic Bloosers.

 

[LoungeLizard]

“Sayed”
Haha…so it’s not just your comprehension that’s an issue…

Well done, you found a mistake, jeeze you must be the soooooooooooooooooo proud of yourself.

I am soooooooooo embarrassed you have shown me up.

 

[Fadge]

“Sayed”
Haha…so it’s not just your comprehension that’s an issue…

Are you going to also pull up your Blooser brethren on their grammar?

As a Carlton fan you'd think Nick Daicos has superpowers to be better then anyone

 

[Robertio]

Im still waiting on his explanation of TDK being elite . Just makes up stuff on a whim in his posts.

He'll forget what he makes up by tomorrow.

 

[sr36]

“Sayed”
Haha…so it’s not just your comprehension that’s an issue…

I think you've got to do better than the below if you want to have a go at language use.

The analogy being pathetic was warranted…as is your comprehension.

 

[Robertio]

Are you going to also pull up your Blooser brethren on their grammar?

You do that enough so why should he bother?

 

[Fadge]

Im still waiting on his explanation of TDK being elite . Just makes up stuff on a whim in his posts.

It's a shame that TDK was completely demotivated at Carlton, and we didn't see the best of him in 2025.

Are you now saying that at his best, he can't be one of the best ruckman in the league?

This, after spending the last two seasons talking him up as a potential All- Australian, and far better than Darcy Cameron who has made an AA squad and won a Collingwood best and fairest in the past two seasons...

 

[Fadge]

You do that enough so why should he bother?

Because he'd be showing hypocrisy if he doesn't.

And believe me, if I pulled up all Bloosers on all their spelling and grammatical errors, BigFooty would be an 80 hour a week job for me.

 

[jezzajay]

Well done, you found a mistake, jeeze you must be the soooooooooooooooooo proud of yourself.

I am soooooooooo embarrassed you have shown me up.

Good.
Maybe you’ll learn from it.

 

[jezzajay]

Are you going to also pull up your Blooser brethren on their grammar?

No.

 

[jezzajay]

I think you've got to do better than the below if you want to have a go at language use.

Why…what’s the problem?

 

[Fadge]

No.

As expected.

(If even you understand the error).

 

[jezzajay]

It's a shame that TDK was completely demotivated at Carlton, and we didn't see the best of him in 2025.

Are you now saying that at his best, he can't be one of the best ruckman in the league?

This, after spending the last two seasons talking him up as a potential All- Australian, and far better than Darcy Cameron who has made an AA squad and won a Collingwood best and fairest in the past two seasons...

The Saints demotivated him. Money does talk when it’s more than a million a year you’re already earning. Not uncommon.