Banter FOOTY Banter! - Who will be better in 2026? Carlton or Collingwood Part 9

[Worm4]

There's not much upstairs but he's not a bad 1-2 player, at times

Kicks can go anywhere though, high and ugly

Four contested marks in four years, little Daicos has that many in his last 14 games

Daicos has 4 in his senior history.
We can laugh more at Perryman and Houstons contracts in reality. What a giggle those 2 has proven to be. And dont get me started on McStay. Those 3 alone would be up there with some most overpaod players in the league. Have a crack at Walsh all you like, those other 3 are way friggen worse for what you are paying them

 

[DaicosDisciple35]

Daicos has 4 in his senior history.
We can laugh more at Perryman and Houstons contracts in reality. What a giggle those 2 has proven to be. And dont get me started on McStay. Those 3 alone would be up there with some most overpaod players in the league. Have a crack at Walsh all you like, those other 3 are way friggen worse for what you are paying them

Perryman was awesome last year, Houston will improve this year and McStay was entirely critical to winning in 23. Hope that helps.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Perryman was awesome last year, Houston will improve this year and McStay was entirely critical to winning in 23. Hope that helps.

That 2023 flag is looking better every year now that our opponent that day is on a tear

McStay was a big part of it, worth every penny just for that

 

[Worm4]

Perryman was awesome last year, Houston will improve this year and McStay was entirely critical to winning in 23. Hope that helps.

Lol. Houston is going to improve at the age of 29. Walsh is 25 and he is cooked ? Is that your take ?

 

[DaicosDisciple35]

That 2023 flag is looking better every year now that our opponent that day is on a tear

McStay was a big part of it, worth every penny just for that

His game against GWS was immense.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Lol. Houston is going to improve at the age of 29. Walsh is 25 and he is cooked ? Is that your take ?

We didn't use Houston properly last year, that's on Fly who didn't have a good year imo

Houston is still a lethal weapon and will hopefully get the chance to show that this year

Walsh however is a broken down spud, who you just signed for another 8 years

 

[Worm4]

We didn't use Houston properly last year, that's on Fly who didn't have a good year imo

Houston is still a lethal weapon and will hopefully get the chance to show that this year

Walsh however is a broken down spud, who you just signed for another 8 years

So not taking walsh's injuries into consideration at all then ?

 

[Worm4]

His game against GWS was immense.

So Mcstay has 1 immense game 3 years ago. Youre quite brilliant at this

 

[Pistol Night]

So Mcstay has 1 immense game 3 years ago. Youre quite brilliant at this

Lawn update Wormy? **** we need some rain hey?

 

[txbyhull]

Can I vote for them both being shite?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

So not taking walsh's injuries into consideration at all then ?

Absolutely taking them into consideration Wormy, I don't think he'll recover

If he does, it will be a different conversation

But 4 contested marks in 4 years is not the Sam Walsh Carlton recruited, he's not right

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Can I vote for them both being shite?

Yep, that's a "draw"

Won't be much flexing if they're 14th and 16th for example

 

[Corn Cobbers]

So Mcstay has 1 immense game 3 years ago. Youre quite brilliant at this

Pretty important game Wormy!! And the margin was one point

 

[jezzajay]

So not taking walsh's injuries into consideration at all then ?

Walsh averages 19 games a season... And yes, he's had some niggles over his career but that's hardly 'broken down'.
But that would be lost on these nuffs.

 

[jezzajay]

So Mcstay has 1 immense game 3 years ago. Youre quite brilliant at this

So I wonder how much they've overpaid him for that one good game!?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

So I wonder how much they've overpaid him for that one good game!?

Worth every penny, flags are rare!! He helped us into the GF in a very tough game

 

[Art Vandelay_]

Won't be much flexing if they're 14th and 16th for example

Now now. If the baggers are 14th their fans will take any small win they can. 31 year flag droughts do that to you.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Now now. If the baggers are 14th their fans will take any small win they can. 31 year flag droughts do that to you.

Sorry, I forgot what I was dealing with there for a moment

 

[Pistol Night]

Can I vote for them both being shite?

Shut up minnow. Your team makes even Carlton look not shit

 

[txbyhull]

Shut up minnow. Your team makes even Carlton look not shit

touched a nerve, golly

 

[Worm4]

Absolutely taking them into consideration Wormy, I don't think he'll recover

If he does, it will be a different conversation

But 4 contested marks in 4 years is not the Sam Walsh Carlton recruited, he's not right

Listen, you shouldn't be talking about contested marks when you have Daicos in your side . he has taken 4 ( 1 of them disputable). Do you know for a fact that when Carlton recruited Sam Walsh, that they were after a contested marking beast ?

 

[Worm4]

Lawn update Wormy? **** we need some rain hey?

Here you go Pistol. Tiff tuff is drought tolerant so mine is green as fck

 

[jezzajay]

Here you go Pistol. Tiff tuff is drought tolerant so mine is green as fck
View attachment 2535758

I doubt collingwood supporters even have a blade of grass to work with!

 

[jezzajay]

Worth every penny, flags are rare!! He helped us into the GF in a very tough game

How many pennies?

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Listen, you shouldn't be talking about contested marks when you have Daicos in your side . he has taken 4 ( 1 of them disputable). Do you know for a fact that when Carlton recruited Sam Walsh, that they were after a contested marking beast ?

I do Wormy, I do

Thanks for proving my point so emphatically